
From 1112 reviews overall



Reviews in Whitby
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
4 Botany Lane Whitby
From our first visit to site till the day we went unconditional we have received the utmost friendliest and professional reception from Leanne. She was always available when we had questions even when we were sending her questions after hours and expecting an answer the following day we will still receive an answer the same night. We appreciate all the assistance and it was a real pleasure going through the first home purchase experience with Leanne.
Region Top 5
ratemyagent award
Wellington2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Whitby2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
New Zealand2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Aotea2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Papakowhai2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Paremata2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Plimmerton2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Titahi Bay2026Reviews in Whitby
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
60 Molyneux Cl Whitby
There are moments in life when we need someone who truly understands, someone with empathy, compassion, and a genuine heart. Too often, people focus on doing a good job but forget the human side of things, the emotions and challenges faced by those on the other end of the phone. When my fiancée and I invited Holly from Bayley’s Real Estate to sell our house, we had just been through hell. Another Real Estate agent from the area, (whom we have been informed is no longer in the area) had made such an awful, unprofessional, and unethical attempt to sell our home, even sabotaging the process multiple times, whether intentionally or not, that we were left devastated. We were upset, exhausted, and unsure how things would go moving forward. After months of difficult experiences, our trust in the process, and in people, had been shaken. Holly came in with honesty, integrity, professionalism, and a humble heart. She listened to us, to what we had been through, and approached everything with a fresh perspective on selling our home and helping us move forward. She took away the overwhelming aspects of the process. Having Holly on board felt like an angel had walked among us. Calm, caring, and empathetic qualities that are rare and precious. Despite the stress of her role, she always spoke with kindness and understanding. She listened, offered thoughtful feedback and solutions, and never rushed us. Instead, she made us feel like we were the only people who mattered in that moment. Both my fiancée and I work in demanding government roles, spending much of our lives giving, supporting, and volunteering. Yet it is rare to meet someone as genuine and beautiful in character as her. On inner beauty and character, this is Holly: “Ruia taitea kia tū ko taikaka anake.” Strip away the sapwood, and only the heartwood remains. We have no words other than thank you, and even that feels inadequate. With much love, Bronnie and Mark x

From 56 reviews overall



Reviews in Whitby
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
21 Resolution Drive Whitby
Both my wife and i have known Philip over a long period of time and this is the 3rd house we have sold with Philip and bought 1 with his assistance overall we have owned and sold 4 houses over 46 yrs living in Whitby. Philip has been very committed and with some of sales at times when the market has been soft for sellers he has always managed to get our sale over the line in tough economic times. Phil is punctual friendly professional, at all times has kept us informed of the processes and decisions we highly recommend Phil as an agent. When not buying or selling and we see Philip around the suburb he always has time to stop for a chat and catch up about what is happening locally. As we bid farewell to Whitby after 46 yrs we wish Philip and his team all the best and every success for the future. Neil & Jane Hickey
144 Endeavour Drive Whitby
We had an excellent experience working with Blair Thompson. From start to finish, he was professional, respectful of our needs, and genuinely committed to helping us achieve the best outcome. Communication was clear, timely, and consistent throughout the entire process, which made everything feel smooth and stress-free. What really stood out was his willingness to go above and beyond. Nothing ever felt like too much trouble, and he was always available to answer questions, provide guidance, and offer reassurance when needed. His knowledge and attention to detail gave us complete confidence every step of the way. We truly appreciated Blair's dedication and would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a reliable and supportive real estate professional. Thank you so much Blair!
Reviews in Whitby
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
7 Madeira Close Whitby
Mel has made our house sale seemless and as stressfree as possible. Every step of the process Mel has kept us informed and guided us through the selling process. We would recommend Mel to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate. Thank you Mel for the swift sale!
From 4 reviews overall
Reviews in Whitby
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
33 Lynda Avenue Paparangi
People say “Real estate agents only work for themselves, not the buyer or the seller”. I was viewing many houses and met many agents from different real estate agencies for 8 months. Most of the time, I agree with this saying. However, Marie is the one that changed the stereotypes that I perceived from an agent. Not only did she provide me with helpful information about the house; she was also willing to answer questions that most agents would not answer. She has always been enthusiastic about helping me to find all the answers that I need to make decisions, from the vendor, the council, the trade people, or any one that could help. What I like the most about her was that treated me like a dear friend of hers, rather than a client. She exceeded all the expectations I had toward an agent. In every single step, from viewing the house, to making an offer, and then to the negotiation process, all the way to the settlement date, she was there to help. She gave me advice, she showed me ways of searching for the information that I need. She made me feel safe and certain about every decision that I made along the way. Honest, kind, caring, helpful and trustworthy; that’s Marie. She is truly a God sent gift. I am very grateful that I met her.

From 514 reviews overall



Reviews in Whitby
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
19/30 Adventure Drive Whitby
We loved working with Mike to sell our property. His genuine care for us showed in the way he made an effort to get to know us and our needs. His commitment to building positive connections with us and our family made the relationship easy, and meant that we trusted him from the get-go to get the job done. He has high standards and works for the best outcome. We highly recommend Mike, and are very grateful for his guidance through the whole process of selling our house.
10/30 Adventure Drive Whitby
Buying our first home was such an important milestone, and we couldn’t have asked for a better real estate agent than Michael. From day one, he went above and beyond — keeping us updated every single day, following up promptly, and making sure we always knew where things stood. Michael’s communication was clear, kind, and completely transparent, which made the whole process feel smooth and stress-free. He guided us through every step with genuine care and professionalism. Even worked late into the evening — to make sure the deal got done. We truly felt supported and well-informed from start to finish. Michael’s dedication and commitment are second to none. We would absolutely recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. He genuinely deserves every bit of this 5-star rating!
From 37 reviews overall
Reviews in Whitby
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
37 Ferry Street Seatoun
We had a great experience buying through Steve, Elise and Mitch at Sotheby's. They were professional, approachable, and genuinely helpful throughout the process. Communication was always clear and timely, which made what can often be a stressful experience feel straightforward and well-managed. Having worked in the property industry for a number of years, we really noticed and appreciated how well everything was handled. It was a standout level of service, and we’d happily recommend them to others.

From 890 reviews overall



Reviews in Whitby
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
212A Staithes Drive Whitby
From day one Mark & i were on the same page with respect to an estate sale. We were in constant contact with updates on the market which has been challenging but in order to meet the market there has to be flexibility and some common sense applied to get a result. Mark stuck at the process which resulted in a sale that we were comfortable with in the end. As a family we would like to thank Mark & The Professionals and would certainly recommend them both in the future.
Reviews in Whitby
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
69 Joseph Banks Dr Whitby
Dans experience really helped in this process. Knowing the market, understanding what buyers need to see and hear are the insights that Dan offers. Perseverance is important in a slow market, Dan continued to work for us and provided good advice which ultimately got us to a sale we were very happy with.