

Gavin Faulke
Sales Consultant
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Median days on market
Seller of 17 Botany Ln, Whitby
Gavin has great knowledge of the local market where we live. Marketing was aimed to getting as many people through the first couple of open homes. Quick follow up with potential buyers and asked us questions from the buyers promptly which led to a pre-auction offer.
Buyer of 36 Oakum Road, Whitby
This was the third time Gavin helped me buy/sell - Gavin and his team are simply exceptional at what they do. Every time, Gavin has given me excellent advice, been completely straight with me about the market and the best approach to take, and ultimately secured the result I wanted. He knows the market inside out, communicates brilliantly, and is always calm, responsive and pragmatic.
Suburb Winner
Whitby2026
Mel Troy
Licensed Real Estate Agent
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Median days on market
Buyer of 10 Joseph Banks Drive, Whitby
Mel was absolutely amazing to deal with from start to finish, making the whole process feel easy and stress-free. Mel was friendly, approachable, professional, and always happy to help with any questions we had. Her communication was fantastic, and we always felt well looked after throughout the process. I would also like to include Nicola who was so friendly and approachable and was always happy to answer questions when we had them. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and would happily recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Thank you for making the whole journey such a positive one!
Seller of 94 Omapere Street, Whitby
I couldn’t recommend Mel more highly! She was fantastic to deal with throughout the entire process of selling my home. Communication was always easy, clear and prompt, and she kept me informed every step of the way, which made what can be a stressful process feel so much easier. She was professional, approachable, knowledgeable and genuinely lovely to deal with. I always felt like I was in good hands and that she had my best interests at heart. Her advice was great, she was easy to get hold of whenever I had questions, and she made the whole experience as smooth and straightforward as possible. I’m so grateful for all her hard work and would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a property. Thank you for making the experience such a positive one!
Buyer of 15 Holystone Road, Whitby
Mel and her team have been great to work with. As a first home buyer she has been very supportive help us with all our questions. Nothing was too difficult and Mel worked around our busy schedules to achieve quick results. Definitely would recommend Mel and her team!


Paula Ritchie
Sales Consultant
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Median days on market
Buyer of 4 Petrel Lane, Whitby
Paula was honest and open at every step, and she lived the team motto, 'we're here to help,' through the whole process. Buying your first home can be very daunting, but she made it easy. From helping with the auction process, arranging viewings, from start to finish Paula was awesome!
Seller of 4 Petrel Lane, Whitby
Paula was instrumental in ensuring we got everything aligned from the beginning. She updated me regularly and was truly just a phone call away. She demonstrated strong negotiation skills and got a great price in a slow economy. The sale was completed within the time frame she initially communicated. She is trustworthy, approachable and available.
Buyer of 191 Navigation Drive, Whitby
We highly recommend Paula to anyone either looking to sell or buy as she is genuinely committed to achieving the best outcome for both seller and purchaser. We appreciated her professionalism, clear communication and negotiation skills. Paula would definitely be our first choice should we be selling in the future.
National Top 100
New Zealand2026Suburb Winner
Aotea2026

Holly Williams
Sales Consultant
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Median days on market
Seller of 202 Navigation Drive, Whitby
Holly did a wonderful job of selling our house. Her communication is exceptional and really put us at ease through the whole process. I cannot recommend Holly enough! Thanks Holly, we appreciate all the hard work you put in to get our house sold.
Seller of 60 Molyneux Cl, Whitby
There are moments in life when we need someone who truly understands, someone with empathy, compassion, and a genuine heart. Too often, people focus on doing a good job but forget the human side of things, the emotions and challenges faced by those on the other end of the phone. When my fiancée and I invited Holly from Bayley’s Real Estate to sell our house, we had just been through hell. Another Real Estate agent from the area, (whom we have been informed is no longer in the area) had made such an awful, unprofessional, and unethical attempt to sell our home, even sabotaging the process multiple times, whether intentionally or not, that we were left devastated. We were upset, exhausted, and unsure how things would go moving forward. After months of difficult experiences, our trust in the process, and in people, had been shaken. Holly came in with honesty, integrity, professionalism, and a humble heart. She listened to us, to what we had been through, and approached everything with a fresh perspective on selling our home and helping us move forward. She took away the overwhelming aspects of the process. Having Holly on board felt like an angel had walked among us. Calm, caring, and empathetic qualities that are rare and precious. Despite the stress of her role, she always spoke with kindness and understanding. She listened, offered thoughtful feedback and solutions, and never rushed us. Instead, she made us feel like we were the only people who mattered in that moment. Both my fiancée and I work in demanding government roles, spending much of our lives giving, supporting, and volunteering. Yet it is rare to meet someone as genuine and beautiful in character as her. On inner beauty and character, this is Holly: “Ruia taitea kia tū ko taikaka anake.” Strip away the sapwood, and only the heartwood remains. We have no words other than thank you, and even that feels inadequate. With much love, Bronnie and Mark x
Buyer of 44 Tradewinds Drive, Whitby
Holly was a fantastic to purchase a house through. Right from our first call to Holly about the house all the way through to settlement, Holly was the upmost professional agent I have dealt with. Her communication was excellent and she has an emphatic manner, really getting to know us as buyers and helping us through the stressful journey. Holly will be my first call in the future and I highly recommend her.