Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
148 reviewsacross 37 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Professional, caring, and achieved a quick sale
almost 3 years ago
Professional, caring, and achieved a quick sale

We’ve been very fortunate to have Tara and Cindy as our agents selling our home in Mairangi Bay. They’ve been highly professional and caring throughout, with regular detailed updates from Tara helping us get a realistic expectation going into auction. Tara gave us great advice on how to prepare the property appropriately for the photos and video, which were incredible, as well as the open homes. They ran a short but intense campaign leading into auction which resulted in over 90 groups through the open homes and 5,500 views online. We were thrilled with the interest at auction day, and whilst a nerve-racking time they made it a wonderful experience with their Bayleys auctioneer, and importantly to us exceeded our reserve. Highly recommend you reach out to Tara and Cindy when considering the sale of your property!

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, caring, and achieved a quick sale
almost 3 years ago
Professional, caring, and achieved a quick sale

We’ve been very fortunate to have Tara and Cindy as our agents selling our home in Mairangi Bay. They’ve been highly professional and caring throughout, with regular detailed updates from Tara helping us get a realistic expectation going into auction. Tara gave us great advice on how to prepare the property appropriately for the photos and video, which were incredible, as well as the open homes. They ran a short but intense campaign leading into auction which resulted in over 90 groups through the open homes and 5,500 views online. We were thrilled with the interest at auction day, and whilst a nerve-racking time they made it a wonderful experience with their Bayleys auctioneer and support team. Highly recommend you reach out to Tara and Cindy when considering the sale of your property!

Cindy Leong

Cindy Leong

  5   (6 reviews)
Seller review
Craig – Castor Bay​
over 3 years ago
Craig – Castor Bay​

Huge thanks again to you, Cindy and the rest of the Bayleys team for yet another outstanding campaign and sale. Putting our faith in you was a no brainer as we knew you would work so hard for us to get the best possible result. For the third time you did just that, again exceeding all expectations!

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
Seller review
Debra – Castor Bay​
over 3 years ago
Debra – Castor Bay​

10/10​ Tara Menzies goes above and beyond to provide a level of service that really makes selling houses a relatively stress free experience which is why she has now sold 3 houses for me. I would have no hesitation in recommending Tara and Cindy as an excellent team who go the extra mile.

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
Seller review
Such a lovely lady to work with
about 4 years ago
Such a lovely lady to work with

Tara was very professional and approachable. She listened and met our needs and understood our concerns. Very obliging, did more than we expected from an agent. We were very lucky to have Tara working for us.

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
Seller review
Exceeded our expectations!
about 4 years ago
Exceeded our expectations!

We first met Tara at an open home and were immediately impressed with her professional and friendly manner. When it came time to list our property, Tara was the perfect fit for us. She is highly responsive, organised and diligent. She kept in constant communication and managed to keep us calm and reassured during the whole stressful process, as well as obtaining a fantastic result on the sale of our property at auction. But it doesn't end there! Tara genuinely cares and if it wasn't for her we would not have secured our dream home. Not only did she suggest a house we wouldn't have thought possible, she organised and guided us through the purchasing process for it. We are so happy with the result. Thank you Tara, we actually can't thank you enough!

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, knowledgeable, caring
over 4 years ago
Professional, knowledgeable, caring

Our experience with Tara was absolutely superb, and we would have no hesitation in working with her again. We found her approach to be very professional and calm, which was very reassuring in what was an often stressful affair. More than anything though, the standout quality in Tara’s approach was her ability to make us feel like we were her only customers. She maintained this kind and caring approach all the way through our house sale journey, all the while being very honest and refreshingly open with feedback and suggestions. We are very grateful to have worked with her.

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
Seller review
Great experience with Tara and the Bayleys team.
over 4 years ago
Great experience with Tara and the Bayleys team.

We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Tara to anyone thinking of selling their home. Tara kept us well informed every step of the way. We were really impressed with her professionalism and judgement. We would like to thank Tara and Ailsa and the team for a fabulous effort and result.

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
Buyer review
A great buying experience with Tara
over 4 years ago
A great buying experience with Tara

Tara was great to deal with - excellent knowledge of the local area, quick to respond to messages and very accommodating of our various questions and requests. She delivered the perfect mix of showing us what was to love about our new home without the hard sales push - just what we'd hope for in an agent.

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
Seller review
A great, professional agent and reliable friend.
over 4 years ago
A great, professional agent and reliable friend.

Ronelle is a very professional agent, and has accurate acknowledgement for the market. She knew our thoughts and house value, then did her best for our interests. She is not just an agent, also a reliable friend. My family and I appreciate your wonderful service. We look forward to have business with you soon again. Thank you.

Ronelle Henning

Ronelle Henning

  5   (67 reviews)
Seller review
We cannot speak highly enough of Tara's professionalism.
over 4 years ago
We cannot speak highly enough of Tara's professionalism.

We have absolutely no hesitation in recommending Tara. She managed the recent listing and subsequent sale of our home exceptionally well. Her communication was spot on, her feedback informative, and the volume of potential buyers she showed the property was outstanding even with the limitations that Covid viewings created. Tara was completely transparent and realistic to the property's value, something we very much valued. The sale price exceeded our expectations and we feel was credited to the professionalism Tara displayed at all times and her knowledge of potential buyers and their requirements. We'd always recommend Tara as a first choice of real estate agent. Thank you Tara, we're very grateful for your outstanding work.

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
Buyer review
Informative and helpful
over 4 years ago
Informative and helpful

Tara was very helpful and clear in her communications firstly leading up to the auction and although we were in COVID level 3, Tara managed to get us sufficient access to view the property fairly. Post purchase, the support was still there helping to the end. Thanks lot.

Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

  5   (35 reviews)
109 - 120 of 148
© 2026 RateMyAgent