Tara Menzies

Tara Menzies

Sales & Marketing Consultant at Bayleys East Coast Bays
  •   5   (34 reviews)

Tara's sales performance at a glance

See how Tara has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

4
Reviews
53
Median days on market
6
Properties for sale
11
Sold properties
$2.7m
Average sale price
$23.5m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.co.nz. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

About Tara

With over 25 years of successful sales experience, Tara is a seasoned professional renowned for her ability to negotiate exceptional outcomes and maximise value. Joining Bayleys in 2008 and partnering with her multilingual sales associate, Cindy Leong, the team specialises in residential, waterfront, and lifestyle properties, consistently achieving outstanding results. Tara believes in working closely with her clients, placing strong emphasis on respect, open communication, and a collaborative approach to achieve the very best outcomes. Her drive and dedication to service are balanced by a calm, approachable nature, enabling her to build genuine, long-term relationships with both vendors and buyers. As a property investor herself, Tara has a deep passion for real estate and a thorough understanding of the local community, where she has lived and worked for many years. She maintains a solid database of qualified buyers ready to make a purchase, and Bayleys’ extensive national and international networks ensure exposure to expats and future immigrants - maximising opportunities and achieving premium results. Tara is deeply rooted in her community, actively involved in local sports including sailing and equestrian. She loves the outdoor lifestyle whether it be mountain biking in Riverhead Forest or walking the coastal trails in the East Coast Bays. She sponsors Murrays Bay School and is a gold sponsor of the Murrays Bay Sailing Club, demonstrating her commitment to supporting and enhancing the local community. With Cindy Leong as part of her team, Tara offers even broader reach and understanding of the market. Cindy is a fluent speaker of English, Mandarin, Cantonese, and Malay. She is known for her empathy, tenacity, and ability to connect with a diverse range of clients. Together, Tara and Cindy deliver a comprehensive, high-calibre real estate service - defined by professionalism, integrity, and results.

Tara's reviews

  5  
Tara has 34 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 6.
Review Tara
Seller review
First class professional service. Genuine care of people and process. Gets Results.
6 months ago
First class professional service. Genuine care of people and process. Gets Results.

Our fourth sale together! Add the two purchases you have helped me with and it should be obvious to anyone that I completely trust you and your process. We have had a lot of success together over the last 10 years and, no matter the market, I have always been relaxed in the knowledge you will always go the extra mile to get the best result. Your personal commitment and care are unwavering which is why I would personally recommend you to any potential vendor. They would be lucky to have you represent them! Keep in touch. I am sure there will be another sale I will need you for. 😊

Seller review
Score: 10/10
9 months ago
Score: 10/10

Tara and Cindy have different skill sets and backgrounds which makes them appealing to a wide range of clients. They are personable and very easy and pleasant to work with. Tara and Cindy.... * Are good communicators and kept us well informed on a regular basis * Verified all potential buyers resulting in no time wasters * Followed up with potential buyers to obtain realistic and helpful feedback * Kept in regular contact with potential buyers who had showed interest but "weren't quite ready" to purchase Their perserverance and combined skill set ultimately resulted in getting two offers for us to consider, leading to a successful sale. We found Tara and Cindy easy and effortless to deal with. We would highly recommend this duo. John and Sandy Boyd

Seller review
Sunny Success: Solid Auction Sale Achieved!
9 months ago
Sunny Success: Solid Auction Sale Achieved!

I had a great experience working with Tara, Anna and the Bayleys’ Team! The marketing campaign for my property sale was very well executed — professional photography, compelling listing descriptions, attractive signage and a strong online presence generated significant interest in the property. Tara and Anna guided me through the auction process resulting in a great result selling under the hammer. What really stood out was the communication from the Bayleys’ Team. I was always kept in the loop and there was clear communication throughout the entire sale process, including very detailed weekly vendor reports. I would highly recommend Tara, Anna and team to anyone looking for local dedicated agents!

Seller review
Excellent Agent
12 months ago
Excellent Agent

Tara worked very hard for us and keeper us fully informed at all steps in the sale process. We would highly recommend her to anyone.

Seller review
It was a pleasure to work with Tara
about 1 year ago
It was a pleasure to work with Tara

Tara & Cindy were very helpful & worked tirelessly to ensure a sale for us. They were both communicative & kept us informed. Thank you both, it was a pleasure to work with you.

Show all 34 reviews
map

Tara's properties

Tara has 6 properties for sale and sold 11 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 20, 2026
Price not available
35 Rothesay Bay Road
Rothesay Bay Auckland
5
3
2
House
For Sale
Asking Price $850,000
3/7 Newhaven Terrace
Mairangi Bay Auckland
2
1
1
House
SoldFeb 25, 2026
Price not available
35 Waymau Lane
Coatesville Auckland
5
2
2
Rural
For Sale
Price by Negotiation
18 Folkestone St
Murrays Bay Auckland
7
4
3
House
Show all 17 properties

Tara's sold properties

Tara has sold 11 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
35 Rothesay Bay Road, Rothesay Bay, Auckland
35 Rothesay Bay Road
Rothesay Bay Auckland
5
3
2
HouseUndisclosed PriceApr 20, 2026
35 Waymau Lane, Coatesville, Auckland
35 Waymau Lane
Coatesville Auckland
5
2
2
RuralUndisclosed PriceFeb 25, 2026
29 Schopolo Place, Schnapper Rock, Auckland
29 Schopolo Place
Schnapper Rock Auckland
5
3
3
House$2,300,000Jan 7, 2026
24 Toanui Road, Hobsonville, Auckland
24 Toanui Road
Hobsonville Auckland
4
3
2
House$1,640,000Nov 2, 2025

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent