Nic Mayhew

Nic Mayhew

Licensed Real Estate Agent at Bayleys Takapuna
  •   5   (30 reviews)

Nic's sales performance at a glance

See how Nic has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

19
Reviews
30
Median days on market
5
Properties for sale
17
Sold properties
$1.6m
Average sale price
$26.6m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.co.nz. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

About Nic

Nic grew up in Northcote Point and has always had an avid interest in property - from crunching the numbers to see what will make the perfect investment to unearthing a true family gem or discovering the untapped potential of a home through renovation. He knows property presents a lot of opportunities and considers it his job to unearth these for the benefit of his clients. Armed with a Bachelor of Business degree majoring in property and a tonne of personal experience puts Nic and his clients in a great position to experience better than expected results. Nic has an impressive background including 15 years as a full-time professional rugby player, which saw him playing all over the world for renowned teams including Harlequins in London, The Blues, Brumbies, New York as well as over 50 games for local NPC team, North Harbour. His sporting achievements include winning the English Premiership, an NPC championship and most recently a Major League Rugby title with New York in 2022. This has taught Nic how to perform in high-pressure situations, networking with a range of people, team collaboration, leadership and resilience in the face of challenges. All of these skills transitioned incredibly well to real estate. Extremely competitive and adaptable Nic knows how to remain calm under pressure. He thrives in high-stake, fast-moving environments and can expertly build and maintain a strong network of clients, colleagues and contacts. His leadership skills see him take charge of transactions, guiding clients through the process and providing expert advice and support. Nic has established a reputation for being hardworking, down to earth and easy-going with a strong solution-focused positive attitude. Outside of work Nic has a long time association with the Northcote Rugy Club including winning the championship in 2010 and playing nearly 100 games for the club. He is a keen sportsperson with an interest in rugby, cricket, golf and fishing. Choosing Bayleys was a natural decision for Nic, as it aligns with his family's longstanding connection to the agency and shares his commitment to family values. As a key member of 'Team Mayhew,' renowned for excellence in the Northcote Point and Birkenhead as well as surrounding suburbs, Nic is dedicated to facilitating real estate transactions to help his clients' fulfil their property dreams.

Nic's reviews

  5  
Nic has 30 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 6.
Review Nic
Seller review
    Exceptional Local Knowledge and a Seamless Sales Experience
18 days ago
Exceptional Local Knowledge and a Seamless Sales Experience

When selecting a real estate team to sell our home at 36 Queen Street, Northcote Point, we had a very clear set of criteria. We wanted agents who were deeply connected to the Northcote Point community, who genuinely understood and appreciated our home, and who shared our passion for presenting and selling it in the best possible way. From our first meeting, Nick, Sue and Anna from Team Mayhew exceeded those expectations. Their local knowledge, professionalism and understanding of the type of buyer our property would appeal to gave us complete confidence that we had chosen the right team. They developed a thoughtful strategy and took our property to market with a four-week campaign and a set date of sale. Remarkably, within just three weeks they had generated multiple offers — an exceptional result, particularly in what has been a very challenging Auckland property market. Throughout the entire process, Nick, Sue and Anna were outstanding. Their communication was excellent, they guided us through every step with honesty and professionalism, and they helped us manage expectations while always advocating for the best possible outcome. Their experience and negotiation skills ultimately resulted in a successful sale with a strong contract and minimal conditions. We are incredibly grateful for the dedication, commitment and care that Team Mayhew brought to the sale of our home. We would not hesitate to recommend Nick, Sue and Anna to anyone looking for a professional, knowledgeable and high-performing real estate team who truly cares about achieving the best result for their clients.

Buyer review
Smooth and Straightforward Experience
28 days ago
Smooth and Straightforward Experience

Nic was responsive and open in his communication, which made the whole experience easy and straightforward. He answered our questions promptly and clearly, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout the process. We appreciated his professionalism and would happily recommend him.

Seller review
Going above and beyond
about 1 month ago
Going above and beyond

Nic and Sue were fantastic throughout the process of selling our house in a very tough market. They truly went above and beyond in every regard. Sue even provided us with her own furnishings for staging. They gave great advice while explaining the potential risks and benefits of every option. Responding quickly at any time of day, they are extremely knowledgeable.

Seller review
Nic Works For You
2 months ago
Nic Works For You

Nic is all the things you would expect from a good agent. Along with great communication, he always maintained a professional but friendly manner. However, what stood out to me, was that I always knew he was working for me, and had my back. That's not something I've always been able to say in the past. He got the result I needed in a difficult market that allowed me to move on with the next phase of my life.

Seller review
Will miss working with Nic!
3 months ago
Will miss working with Nic!

Nic and Sue have been an absolute pleasure to work with. We now live overseas so we couldn’t make it to the house before selling it and they spent many hours at our house making sure it was looking good for the buyers. And it looked amazing. They were super responsive, always made sure we knew what all the legal information meant, talked us clearly through all of the pros and cons of each situation and made us feel really comfortable with the process. They were also super transparent with feedback and their thoughts which made making any decisions easier. We are so happy with the outcome but we will definitely miss working with Nic and Sue 👏🏼

Buyer review
Excellent service, such a seamless & easy process!
3 months ago
Excellent service, such a seamless & easy process!

Right from the beginning we knew we were in good hands with Nic. He was professional, prompt with responses, able to answer all of our questions, and always willing to help. Buying our second home was such an enjoyable and easy experience thanks to Team Mayhew!

Show all 30 reviews
map

Nic's properties

Nic has 5 properties for sale and sold 17 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldJun 18, 2026
Price not available
43 Athena Drive
Totara Vale Auckland
3
1
2
Other
SoldJun 8, 2026
$3,550,000
36 Queen St
Northcote Point Auckland
5
3
1
House
For Sale
Price by Negotiation
7A Lancelot Place
Glenfield Auckland
4
2
House
SoldMay 24, 2026
$1,135,000
3/57 Pupuke Road
Birkenhead Auckland
3
2
2
House
Show all 22 properties

Nic's sold properties

Nic has sold 17 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
43 Athena Drive, Totara Vale, Auckland
43 Athena Drive
Totara Vale Auckland
3
1
2
OtherUndisclosed PriceJun 18, 2026
36 Queen St, Northcote Point, Auckland
36 Queen St
Northcote Point Auckland
5
3
1
House$3,550,000Jun 8, 2026
3/57 Pupuke Road, Birkenhead, Auckland
3/57 Pupuke Road
Birkenhead Auckland
3
2
2
House$1,135,000May 24, 2026
6 Belle Vue Avenue, Northcote Point, Auckland
6 Belle Vue Avenue
Northcote Point Auckland
3
1
1
House$1,765,000May 7, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent