Nic's profile

Nic's reviews

  5  
Nic has 31 reviewsacross 9 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Seller review
Guiding Us Every Step of the Way
11 days ago
Guiding Us Every Step of the Way

We feel incredibly fortunate to have had Team Mayhew as the agents representing the sale of our humble home. From our very first meeting through to planning, marketing, open homes, and finally achieving a successful sale, they were professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely supportive every step of the way. As first-time home sellers, we had many questions and uncertainties, but Sue and Nic were always patient, proactive, and took the time to explain everything clearly. They made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and manageable. Their guidance, communication, and commitment gave us confidence throughout the entire process. We always felt that they had our best interests at heart and were working hard to achieve the best possible outcome for us. We were introduced to Sue and Nic through word of mouth, and now we completely understand why they came so highly recommended. Choosing them as our agents was one of the best decisions we made, and we wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Thank you, Team Mayhew - Sue and Nic, for your hard work, honesty, and dedication. It was an absolute pleasure working with you both. We wish you continued success in everything you do!

Seller review
    Exceptional Local Knowledge and a Seamless Sales Experience
about 1 month ago
Exceptional Local Knowledge and a Seamless Sales Experience

When selecting a real estate team to sell our home at 36 Queen Street, Northcote Point, we had a very clear set of criteria. We wanted agents who were deeply connected to the Northcote Point community, who genuinely understood and appreciated our home, and who shared our passion for presenting and selling it in the best possible way. From our first meeting, Nick, Sue and Anna from Team Mayhew exceeded those expectations. Their local knowledge, professionalism and understanding of the type of buyer our property would appeal to gave us complete confidence that we had chosen the right team. They developed a thoughtful strategy and took our property to market with a four-week campaign and a set date of sale. Remarkably, within just three weeks they had generated multiple offers — an exceptional result, particularly in what has been a very challenging Auckland property market. Throughout the entire process, Nick, Sue and Anna were outstanding. Their communication was excellent, they guided us through every step with honesty and professionalism, and they helped us manage expectations while always advocating for the best possible outcome. Their experience and negotiation skills ultimately resulted in a successful sale with a strong contract and minimal conditions. We are incredibly grateful for the dedication, commitment and care that Team Mayhew brought to the sale of our home. We would not hesitate to recommend Nick, Sue and Anna to anyone looking for a professional, knowledgeable and high-performing real estate team who truly cares about achieving the best result for their clients.

Buyer review
Smooth and Straightforward Experience
about 2 months ago
Smooth and Straightforward Experience

Nic was responsive and open in his communication, which made the whole experience easy and straightforward. He answered our questions promptly and clearly, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout the process. We appreciated his professionalism and would happily recommend him.

Seller review
Going above and beyond
about 2 months ago
Going above and beyond

Nic and Sue were fantastic throughout the process of selling our house in a very tough market. They truly went above and beyond in every regard. Sue even provided us with her own furnishings for staging. They gave great advice while explaining the potential risks and benefits of every option. Responding quickly at any time of day, they are extremely knowledgeable.

Seller review
Nic Works For You
3 months ago
Nic Works For You

Nic is all the things you would expect from a good agent. Along with great communication, he always maintained a professional but friendly manner. However, what stood out to me, was that I always knew he was working for me, and had my back. That's not something I've always been able to say in the past. He got the result I needed in a difficult market that allowed me to move on with the next phase of my life.

Seller review
Will miss working with Nic!
3 months ago
Will miss working with Nic!

Nic and Sue have been an absolute pleasure to work with. We now live overseas so we couldn’t make it to the house before selling it and they spent many hours at our house making sure it was looking good for the buyers. And it looked amazing. They were super responsive, always made sure we knew what all the legal information meant, talked us clearly through all of the pros and cons of each situation and made us feel really comfortable with the process. They were also super transparent with feedback and their thoughts which made making any decisions easier. We are so happy with the outcome but we will definitely miss working with Nic and Sue 👏🏼

Buyer review
Excellent service, such a seamless & easy process!
3 months ago
Excellent service, such a seamless & easy process!

Right from the beginning we knew we were in good hands with Nic. He was professional, prompt with responses, able to answer all of our questions, and always willing to help. Buying our second home was such an enjoyable and easy experience thanks to Team Mayhew!

Seller review
Professional, calm and considered
4 months ago
Professional, calm and considered

Nic was a pleasure to deal with. Responsive clear communication. Thoughtful in his approach and professional.

Buyer review
Trustworthy, calm and easy to deal with
4 months ago
Trustworthy, calm and easy to deal with

We were so pleased with the manner in which Nick helped us sell our former home and that meant when it came to buying we knew we could trust him. We got a very good outcome and I have no hesitation in recommending him.

Buyer review
Nic is awesome!
5 months ago
Nic is awesome!

Great communicator, quick to and thorough. Nic is really easy to get along with and made the process really smooth

Buyer review
Top North Shore Agents
5 months ago
Top North Shore Agents

We couldn't be happier with Nic and his team. They are a true professional who knows the market inside and out. If you want to sell your house for top dollar, this is the agent to call."

Seller review
Super helpful and easy to work with.
6 months ago
Super helpful and easy to work with.

We had an excellent experience working with Team Mayhew from start to finish. Communication was clear, timely, and proactive — we always felt informed and supported, and no question was ever too small. They guided us through every stage of the process with calm confidence and professionalism, which made what could have been a stressful experience feel far more manageable. Their market knowledge, practical advice, and willingness to go the extra mile really stood out. We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell a home and would gladly work with them again.

1 - 12 of 31
© 2026 RateMyAgent