From 261 reviews overall

Jayden Matthews
Tall Poppy Real Estate - Wellington Region

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Otaki
Median days on market
50 Dunstan Street Otaki
Jayden kept in touch throughout the sale process. He was very willing to provide advice and to meet with family. He also was willing to help with minor repairs. He kept us well informed and what might help in a sluggish sale environment.
4A Millhaven Place Otaki
We would definitely recommend working with Jayden to sell your property. He was always honest with us, and made a point to never apply pressure to decisions. They were always our decision to make and he presented us with all the information and advice he could gather. He also always made himself available for a call or update whenever we wanted one. We appreciate having dealt with a few agents over the years, how Jayden makes you know he cares about you and the property you are selling. Even though he has a lot of listings going at the same time, he makes you feel as though hes never too busy for you. He also makes an effort to learn about the intricacies of your property to ensure he can have informed conversations with potential buyers. Our house had an unorthodox construction type, but his experience in the building industry and his own research meant that if anyone asked about it he would actually know what hes talking about. Thanks for everything Jayden we really appreciate it!
Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Otaki2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
New Zealand2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Otaki Beach2026From 26 reviews overall

Te Ataahua Telford-Epiha
Kelly&Co Otaki (Andco Realty 11 Ltd)

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Otaki
Median days on market
10 Matene Pl Otaki
As a first home buyer, the process felt really intimidating and I was worried I would make mistakes. Te Ataahua was so supportive and helped me navigate the purchase easily. Answering all my questions and checking in with me so I knew what was coming up and what to prepare. The whole process was really smooth and enjoyable!
3 Renata Rd Otaki
Te Ataahua was outstanding to work with as the agent for the sale of my investment property. She was incredibly supportive from start to finish and genuinely went above and beyond what we expected. Her market knowledge is sharp, her communication is clear and consistent, and her professionalism is second to none. In a challenging market, she leveraged her network and expertise to secure a great result quickly, and made the entire process feel smooth and well-managed. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her to friends and whanau. She is excellent at what she does, and I’m genuinely grateful for the work she put in to get this across the line.
From 76 reviews overall

Derek Kelly
Kelly&Co Otaki (Andco Realty 11 Ltd)

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Otaki
Median days on market
22 Ludlam Way Otaki
Dealing with Derek from start to finish as a buyer was easy, stress free and a positive experience. Unlike dealing with agents in the past and especially coming in as a buyer, Derek worked with myself and the vendor to ensure a smooth sale and an outcome that we were both happy with. I would not hesitate to recommend Derek to others.
98 Rahui Road Otaki
I had total confidence in Derek and his team, that they would met expectations on sale of property. From the moment I approached Derek, he explained the process, options for type of sale, suggestions with presentation of property, staging of house, realistic expectations for best outcome. I took his advice and left the property in Derek and his teams professional hands. Amazing outcome for me and the new owners. I highly recommend Derek Real Estate to both sellers and purchasers.
From 120 reviews overall

Maureen Wallace
Kelly&Co Otaki (Andco Realty 11 Ltd)

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Otaki
Median days on market
81A Forest Lakes Road Otaki
This is the second property Maureen has sold for us in 3 years, she is very professional in her role, keeps you informed and has extensive up-to-date market knowledge. We appreciated Maureen’s forthright, direct and down to earth communication skills. She kept us informed and was always available to be contacted, or to discuss progress or any other concerns. Maureen gave us good information and options with her negotiation skills. Always tactful and diplomatic. We would highly recommend Maureen as your Real Estate Agent. Regards Deb and Barry
28 Brandon Street Otaki
Working with Maureen and Derek has been a great experience. They were both incredibly helpful, consistently available, and genuinely committed to supporting me through the entire process. Their communication was clear, timely, and reassuring, and their knowledge made everything feel smooth and well-managed.