From 261 reviews overall

Jayden Matthews
Tall Poppy Real Estate - Wellington Region

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Otaki Beach
Median days on market
49 Seagrass Place Otaki Beach
Reading all of Jayden’s 5 star reviews encouraged us to use him for two property sales in Otaki Beach. Jayden kept us in touch with everything that was happening with our sale and always encouraged us with his positive attitude. After dealing with Jayden, we found his level of service and dedication went above and beyond any other real estate agent we have ever used before. Jayden is an outstanding agent. He is very professional, honest, caring, and a really lovely guy to deal with. We were very happy with the results from both house sales.
18 Robert McKeen Street Otaki Beach
Having previously on sold 4 properties Jayden is the only agent who demonstrated total commitment, genuine care, regular updates and his trade back ground was an asset with my sale . He carried this attitude from start to finish and totally believe he made the house sale. Could not thank him enough. Peter.
15 Hewson Crescent Otaki Beach
Absolutely easy is how I describe Jayden’s representation on selling my brothers house. Always keeping us in touch with the process and kept a strong positive outlook. I live in Perth Australia so emails were coming regularly. Very happy with the whole process.
Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Otaki Beach2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
New Zealand2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Otaki2026From 47 reviews overall

Natalie Malloy
Harcourts Otaki (Team Group Realty Ltd)

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Otaki Beach
Median days on market
90/20 Tasman Road Otaki Beach
Natalie has always been positive about my sale! It wasn’t an easy home to sell, in a large complex, but she sold it! And, was always informative, and motivated. Natalie is very humble and honest! We worked well together, with the sale! I would use her again!
79 Norfolk Crescent Otaki Beach
We found Natalie had a excellent understanding of the market within our area. Natalie was great to deal with, very easy going and was very honest regarding our expectations. We would highly recommend Natalie and the Harcourts team in Otaki to others.
From 76 reviews overall

Derek Kelly
Kelly&Co Otaki (Andco Realty 11 Ltd)

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Otaki Beach
Median days on market
5 Toi Street Otaki Beach
We found Derek to be very friendly, enthusiastic and knowledgeable. He gave us feedback regularly and kept us right up to date with how things were going. It made the process of selling our house much less stressful than it could have been and we felt that he was doing all he could to get the best result for us. He has a really relaxed, casual style a great sense of humour and we now consider him a friend too.
5 Toi Street Otaki Beach
Our home buying experience with Derek was nothing short of exceptional . From our very first connection at the open home . Derek was genuinely interested in us and listened and provided sound advice for us to consider and move forward if we wished . The second stage of making our offer , we felt supported and then when accepted Derek could not of been happier for us . Authentic and knowledgeable. His team also have the same traits , Your in very good hands with Kelly & Co . We would not hesitate to recommend .
From 26 reviews overall

Te Ataahua Telford-Epiha
Kelly&Co Otaki (Andco Realty 11 Ltd)

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Otaki Beach
Median days on market
45 Seagrass Place Otaki Beach
Even though Te was technically working for the Sellers, my wife Jeanette and I were treated as a friend by her, assisting us wherever possible in this matter, like a family member, and coming across knowledgeable, helpful and professionally. We have bought/sold about 9 homes in our 50-odd years of marriage, and this transaction I must rank as one of the smoothest and problem-free of all. Thank you, Te.
19 Karaka Street Otaki Beach
Te Ataahua and Derek did an absolutely outstanding job selling our dad’s home. From the very beginning, they showed exceptional kindness and genuine thoughtfulness, taking the time to understand our family’s situation and guide us through each step with care. Their communication was clear, timely, and always reassuring, which made us feel confident throughout the entire process. What impressed us most was their professionalism and the result they achieved. They brought in four strong offers within just ten days, far exceeding our expectations. Their strategy, market knowledge, and dedication clearly paid off, and it was obvious that they were committed to securing the best possible outcome for us. The whole process was incredibly smooth, stress-free, and surprisingly easy. At every stage, Te Ataahua and Derek handled everything with efficiency and calm, allowing us to focus on what mattered without feeling overwhelmed. We are truly grateful for their hard work and the care they showed our family. We highly recommend Te Ataahua and Derek to anyone looking for real estate agents who go above and beyond.
33 Mountain View Terrace Otaki Beach
Te Ataahua was exceptional with her friendly approach and attentiveness to our wants and needs as a whānau purchasing our first home. Being a local and invested community member of Ōtaki, Te Ataahua was able to offer us really good insights and knowledge about the right house for us. We would work again with Te Ataahua in a heart beat and we highly recommend her services to anyone looking to buy or sell.