Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1680 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
In a league of their own- Top communicators and strive for the best outcome for you
about 2 months ago
In a league of their own- Top communicators and strive for the best outcome for you

This is the second time we have dealt with Keeley, the first being the purchase of our house and it was an easy decision to engage her again to sell it as we relocate. The team of Keeley and Niki is a powerful combo. You get a huge wealth of experience and exceptional advice partnered with fantastic online marketing. When the pressure came on and we risked loosing the house we were purchasing, they shifted up a gear and secured us an offer. throughout the whole process Keeley was in constant comunication and was reassuring me throughout making what could have been a stressful situation a far easier one for us. I recommend anyone wanting an agent who has exceptional knowledge of the market in Cromwell and surrounding areas to get i ntouch with Keeley.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (307 reviews)
Seller review
Stacey and Rebecca were very approachable from our first meeting.
about 2 months ago
Stacey and Rebecca were very approachable from our first meeting.

After having had a few interactions with other agents I felt really comfortable and open with discussing the sale of my home with Stacey and Rebecca. They were very honest and seemed to know the market well with pricing my house. I felt very supported through the whole process which I found really stressful and they always kept in touch or were easy to contact when needed. I would recommend this team to anyone looking at anything real estate. Thankyou team. Ngamihinui Liz.

Stacey Gillies

Stacey Gillies

  4.9   (186 reviews)
Buyer review
Seamless service
about 2 months ago
Seamless service

I couldn't have asked for a more straight forward purchase, the communication from Stacey and Rebecca was outstanding and nothing was a problem. Highly recommend.

Stacey Gillies

Stacey Gillies

  4.9   (186 reviews)
Seller review
Great appreciation
2 months ago
Great appreciation

We had been through an unsuccessfull campaign with other agents a year ago which left us wary of another campaign with its accompanying dramas. However miracles do happen and without even an open home, the property was sold within 48 hours. We are more than grateful with the professionalism, advertising and empathy of Peter and Dee. Highly recommended

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (326 reviews)
Seller review
Hard working and dedicated
2 months ago
Hard working and dedicated

We engaged Fiona on recommendation from a friend. We found her to be hard working and dedicated with her associate Hannah to achieve a sale. A sale was accomplished, albeit notably less than the expected achievable and agreed market value. Comments from Hannah during the negotiation process felt like the focus on a sale took priority over achieving the best outcome for the vendor.

Fiona Chapman

Fiona Chapman

  4.9   (35 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Team work , excellent communication.
2 months ago
Great Team work , excellent communication.

Absolutely fantastic team! From start to finish, everyone was friendly, professional, helpful, and genuinely caring. The whole experience was smooth and stress-free, and you can really tell that the team takes pride in what they do. A big thank you to the entire team for the great service and positive attitude. I really appreciate the effort and would happily recommend them to anyone. Keep up the amazing work! πŸ‘πŸ˜Š

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (307 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent communicator with in deep understanding of the local market
2 months ago
Excellent communicator with in deep understanding of the local market

This is the second time I've worked with Keeley and I just love having someone I can call and get a frank assessment of the current situation. I got regular updates from Keeley and Niki, and data from the Tall Poppy marketing process, however the property sold so quickly, I barely had a chance to review that. I would (and do) recommend Keeley to anyone buying or selling in the Cromwell market.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (307 reviews)
Buyer review
Above and beyond
2 months ago
Above and beyond

Our experience with Kate was nothing but smooth and stress free. She went above and beyond to help us, answering phone calls out of hours, communicating with the seller when necessary, and even gifting us a moving in present. We would recommend her to anyone who is looking to purchase a house.

Kate Andrew

Kate Andrew

  5   (122 reviews)
Seller review
  Fantastic service!
3 months ago
Fantastic service!

Kate was great to work with. Strong local market knowledge paired with professionalism made our sale a smooth process. Her communication and regular reports were helpful at keeping us up to date. We are very happy with the result!

Kate Andrew

Kate Andrew

  5   (122 reviews)
Buyer review
Easy process from start to finish
3 months ago
Easy process from start to finish

We were overseas when we noticed this property and ended up purchasing it 'sight unseen'. Andrew was very helpful in this situation, allowing our friends who viewed the property on our behalf to take comprehensive videos. Communication was good throughout ... our questions to the vendor and their responses were relayed promptly. The purchase proceeded smoothly from when we made our initial offer right through to the handover, including Andrew's associate Lydia facilitating a video call as we had a relative carry out the pre-settlement inspection. Overall a very positive experience with Andrew and Tall Poppy.

Andrew Berryman

Andrew Berryman

  5   (265 reviews)
25 - 36 of 1,680
Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
Contact Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
What information would you like?
Β© 2026 RateMyAgent