Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago - Verified Reviews & Real Estate For Sale

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

318

Reviews

134

Properties for sale

329

Sold properties

$374k

Average sale price

$123m

Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) as lead and supporting agent and published on ratemyagent.co.nz. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Our customer service awards

See what RateMyAgent awards Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago has won

Suburb WinnerBridge Hill
Suburb WinnerClyde
Suburb WinnerCromwell
Suburb WinnerSawyers Bay

6x Suburb WinnerCromwell - 2026, 2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021
5x Suburb WinnerClyde - 2026, 2025, 2023, 2022, 2021
5x National Top 100New Zealand - 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020
5x Suburb WinnerAlexandra - 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020

Meet the team

Get to know the 20 agents at Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago.

Peter Hishon

Franchise owner/Sales person

4.9

(312 reviews)

About Peter

Since joining Real Estate in 2014 Peter has developed a reputation for achieving great results for his clients. Peter joined Tall Poppy as a franchise owner in 2018 and along with supporting his team of salespeople has had great success in Central Otago. With a lifetime of sales and negotiation experience working as a stock agent it was an easy transition to helping clients buy and sell property - ensuring he provides a friendly, professional and knowledgeable service. A testament to his hard work, Peter placed second in the NZ Tall Poppy annual sales awards in 2019 and was recognised by Rate my agent as being in the top 30 for Agent of the Year throughout NZ in 2020 and 2021. Agent of the year for Alexandra 2023 and Otago agency of the year 2023. Peter loves the Central Otago lifestyle having raised his children here and is actively involved in local business affairs, sports and cultural activity and enjoys auctioneering for local fundraising. He looks forward to continuing to bring fair fees, exceptional service and New Zealand’s number 1 marketing package to Real Estate in the area.

View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievements

Keeley Anderson

Sales Consultant

(281 reviews)

About Keeley

Setting the standard for success in real estate, Keeley Anderson brings a powerful blend of professionalism, charisma, and determination to every transaction. Since beginning her real estate career in 2019, she has achieved exceptional results—most recently being recognised as the Runner-Up Individual Sales Consultant of the Year at Tall Poppy for both 2024 and 2025. Keeley’s success has been acknowledged with multiple industry accolades, including the prestigious 2022 Rate My Agent Rising Star Award, placing her in the top 4% of active agents nationwide. Her consistent performance has also secured her place among Tall Poppy’s top 10 sales consultants year after year, with ongoing recognition through Rate My Agent and Tall Poppy Awards. With a strong background in luxury fashion and publishing sales and marketing, Keeley brings strategic thinking, creativity, and professionalism to every listing. Her reputation is built on exceptional customer service, honesty, and integrity, paired with a warm and positive approach that clients consistently value. A proud Southern woman and dedicated mum of two, when she’s not negotiating property deals from Cromwell to Queenstown, you’ll find her skiing, enjoying local water sports, or immersing herself in the communities she loves. With international experience spanning London, Paris, New York, and Sydney, she now thrives in a place where the mountains far outshine the skyscrapers—sharing the magic of Central Otago with buyers and sellers alike. Teamed with experienced agent Niki Lord, Keeley offers clients a dynamic and high-performing partnership. Their combined knowledge, energy, and client-first approach ensure a seamless experience and outstanding results across every campaign.

View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievements

Andrew Berryman

Licensed Real Estate Agent / Property Consultant / Principal

(245 reviews)

About Andrew

Tall Poppy Dunedin business owner and licensed salesperson. Experienced, with great local knowledge and a personable manner. Known for his honesty, integrity, helpfulness and wicked sense of humour, Andrew takes the drama out of selling and buying property in Dunedin.

View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievements

Pip O'Connell

Sales Consultant

4.9

(237 reviews)

About Pip

Real Estate is not about just selling properties, for me it’s about listening to you and working with you to get the very best results, you deserve it. Working with such a precious asset requires care, honesty, energy and commitment, and my past clients will tell you that this is what I am all about. I’m an industry professional, I’d love to talk to you about your property and how together with Tall Poppy and their fair flat fees, I can bring to you the best of everything! me and let's discuss how I can meet your Real Estate needs. Offering Real Estate with passion, professionalism and a vast knowledge of the local market. Committed to delivering you top service with an honest and friendly approach. Totally committed to my VENDORS, Tall Poppy is the company for YOU!!

View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievements

Leona Munro

Sales & Marketing Consultant / Property Consultant / Licensee

4.9

(180 reviews)

About Leona

Leona Munro brings with her over fifteen years’ experience in the Dunedin Real Estate Market, she is recognized amongst her peers and clients as a very strong negotiator with a careful attention to detail. Leona is a salesperson who thrives on surpassing expectations, her integrity, Honesty, professionalism and dedication to her clients is unquestionable. Her honest, warm and genuine personality is apparent from the first meeting. Leona’s actions and the sales she achieves for her clients speak louder than words. She is a multi-award-winning agent recognised time-and-again for her exceptional customer service. This means whether you’re a seller or a buyer working with Leona is a collaborative process rewarded with outstanding results. Prior to real estate, Leona managed, renovated and sold a large portfolio of property, both commercial and residential. It’s this background that gave her an understanding of what is expected of a real estate sales person. “I found out quickly what I liked and did not like in real estate agents and used this knowledge to establish a benchmark for my business” "I understand the pressures involved in the selling and purchasing of a property, it can be a very emotional and stressful time and this is where I will help. If you are looking for professional service and outstanding results, energy and enthusiasm, contact me today” Leona’s hardworking nature, teamed with Tall Poppy's industry leading resources and innovation, ensures that no stone is left unturned when it comes to securing a premium result for her clients. "Committed to delivering outstanding service”

View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievements

Stacey Gillies

Sales Consultant / Sales & Marketing Consultant / Licensed Real Estate Agent

4.9

(172 reviews)

About Stacey

“Your property Our Priority” A dynamic team of dedicated real estate professionals with over 20 years of combined experience serving the Central Otago community. They have an exceptional ability to engage with clients, armed with professionalism, quality service and results that are proven. Repeat business, backed up with a strong client database, has earned Stacey and Rebecca the reputation as trusting agents that care, helping client’s aspirations come true. They listen to clients’ needs and are relentless in the pursuit of finding the perfect fit, negotiating the best terms, and ensuring a smooth transaction. Skilled negotiators, marketing experts, savvy analysts, and compassionate individuals who understand that buying or selling a home is more than just a transaction—it’s a lifechanging experience. Local area experts, Stacey and Rebecca have an exceptional ability to match clients with their dream homes. Stacey and Rebecca love spending quality time with their families both being Mums know how important it is to balance work with family life and that is why they chose to be a team. Outside of this they both love Central Otago and what it has to offer. If you are looking to buy or sell in this beautiful part of New Zealand then be sure that these ladies will make your dream become a reality. We look forward to working with you Stace and Bec

View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievements

About us

In 2012, we established Tall Poppy, a home grown Kiwi business with a fresh take on Real Estate. We offer award winning customer service, and our sales consultants are specially trained in managing offers to guarantee they sell their vendors properties for the very best price. We do this by investing in people, not infrastructure and embracing technology, not the status quo. Our heritage is built on the foundation of fairness. Fairness in the way fees are charged, fairness in the exceptional service we provide our customers and fairness in the way we treat our people. Thinking of selling? Let’s talk!

Seller review

about 16 hours ago

Would use again!

Brilliant knowledge of the market, set sale price exactly where it should be for our section, after showing us near by values. Nice open communication. Made our busy lives very easy with helping us sell our section.

Peter Hishon

4.9

(312 reviews)

Buyer review

about 20 hours ago

Excellent communication

Communication with Andrew is always pleasant. He is responsive and nice.

Andrew Berryman

(245 reviews)

Seller review

1 day ago

Soultions focused professional who provides a reassuring presence in the property market

Andrew was great to deal with always bringing professionalism and reassurance to every interaction. No question was too difficult and I appreciated Andrew's willingness to assist with both mundane and complex situations in a timely manner. Andrew instills confidence with his knowledge of the property market allowing novices like myself to feel comfortable navigating the sales process. And all done with a calm demeanour and sense of humour.

Andrew Berryman

(245 reviews)

Buyer review

2 days ago

Nice to talk to, Helpful and patient.

Leona was very quick to respond to all my enquiries and helped me through the process with patience and friendly approachable disposition. I enjoyed the experience.

Leona Munro

4.9

(180 reviews)

Seller review

3 days ago

Excellent Agent!!

Keeley was an absolute dream to work with. Her market knowledge is exceptional and her professionalism is second to none. She kept us informed every step of the way and made the entire process feel easy and stress-free. Keeley went above and beyond, offering valuable styling advice and practical tips - she really knows her stuff. The wrap-around services provided by Tall Poppy were also excellent and made the whole experience seamless. We would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking for a great result.

Keeley Anderson

(281 reviews)

Seller review

3 days ago

Fantastic!

Keeley and Niki were fantastic to deal with. We would highly recommend them if you are thinking of selling and trying to decide which realtor to use. They are both super efficient, organised and great at what they do, they work hard behind the scene to find buyers. We loved how friendly, knowledgeable and stress free they were to work with. Also communication was so fast - which we really appreciated. Using the Tall Poppy client portal was great and kept us up to date in real time throughout the selling process. They had our house sold within the first week for exactly what we had asked for.

Keeley Anderson

(281 reviews)

Our properties