Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1687 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Exceptional Service
almost 6 years ago
Exceptional Service

From our first meeting right through to selling our home, Keeley was honest, genuine and caring throughout the whole process. We had 3 appraisals done by 3 different real estate firms and felt that Keeley was honest, knowledgeable and had a modern approach to the market which was refreshing. We love that Tall Poppy have been realistic in their view on how real estate agents and the industry works today which is reflected in their fees and focus on what people want and need. Keeley is efficient, keeps things simple and was a dream to work with. If you want to deal with a genuine person who wants the best outcome for you, give Keeley a call today!

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (302 reviews)
Seller review
great work
almost 6 years ago
great work

Peter is really easy to communicate and responsive ,thanks for all the work selling our house. All the best for 2021.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (325 reviews)
Seller review
A job well done
almost 6 years ago
A job well done

We sold our home recently with Pip as our real estate agent. She is a friendly, witty person who is great at what she does. She is a pleasure to deal with, had good communication and secured our sale with ease and efficiency. We recommend her to all. Thanks Pip

Pip O'Connell

Pip O'Connell

  4.9   (252 reviews)
Seller review
Always in good hands with Peter!
almost 6 years ago
Always in good hands with Peter!

Peter was a great match for us from the start - down to earth and trustworthy. Great communication and kept things moving along without us feeling rushed.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (325 reviews)
Buyer review
very good and enjoyable
almost 6 years ago
very good and enjoyable

Stacey has a lot of knowledge and is willing to help.

Stacey Waldron

Stacey Waldron

  4.9   (185 reviews)
Seller review
very helpful in what was a difficult sale
almost 6 years ago
very helpful in what was a difficult sale

Peter kept us well informed with good updates it was a difficult sale which he handled very well

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (325 reviews)
Seller review
Great Sale with Keeley!
almost 6 years ago
Great Sale with Keeley!

After a long time on the the market and an unsuccessful offer we decided to list our house with Keeley. From the first time Keeley stepped foot in our house she told us she would have no problem selling it, would bring us multi offers and get us the price we want. She did exactly that! Along the way she gave us tips and tricks to help us out and went above and beyond to make sure we were happy through the whole process. We cannot recommend Keeley enough and will definitely use her again in the future

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (302 reviews)
Seller review
House sale
almost 6 years ago
House sale

Peter was easy going and easy to work with. Would highly recommend him if your looking for an agent. Very professional.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (325 reviews)
Buyer review
Great communication and knowledge
almost 6 years ago
Great communication and knowledge

Excellent communication throughout and felt at ease with his industry knowledge and advice

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (325 reviews)
Seller review
I found Peter very approachable and confident.
almost 6 years ago
I found Peter very approachable and confident.

All went smoothly with the sale of my Aunts house. Tall Poppy fees seemed to be cheaper than other Realestates and covered appropriate advertising. It was my first time selling and with the added responsibilities of being an executor (jointly) and both of us executors living far away Peter was very helpful in organizing cleaning of house and the presentation of the house. He is local and has the contacts and experience.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (325 reviews)
Seller review
A True Pro
almost 6 years ago
A True Pro

Pip is very professional in all aspects of her work. Her communication skills are excellent and she carried out her work effectively and timely. Pip went the extra mile for us and got us over the line. Her combination of skills and attitude make her an agent you can trust. We would highly reccommend her.

Pip O'Connell

Pip O'Connell

  4.9   (252 reviews)
Seller review
We had confidence in Keeley right from first point of contact in every way, total professional.
almost 6 years ago
We had confidence in Keeley right from first point of contact in every way, total professional.

Keeley's communication right from the start was faultless. We asked for an appraisal not long after lockdown which she returned within 24 hours. We did not list at that point and then contacted her again late October, she did another appraisal which was significantly higher and thought no way we would get that for our property. Well Keeley really knows her stuff, she marketed the property so professionally and came in over and above what we expected. Her attention to detail in all areas could not be more professional. We also felt her customer service was very personalised to our needs, we would highly recommend Keeley and would us her again without a doubt.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (302 reviews)
1549 - 1560 of 1,687
Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
Contact Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent