Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1628 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Great Experience
about 1 year ago
Great Experience

Keeley was upfront and knowledgeable about the house and the area. She was very pleasant to deal with and nothing was a problem. She made the experience seamless. I would recommend Keeley to anyone that wants to buy a property.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (282 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent
about 1 year ago
Excellent

Kate was very professional and easy to work with :-)

Kate Andrew

Kate Andrew

  5   (115 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent communication
about 1 year ago
Excellent communication

Keeley was attentive to detail, right down to placement of furniture for photography, and knew the market thoroughly. I appreciated the ease of communication throughout the sale process. Keeley was easily contactable for questions and gave feedback and guidance with pricing and negotiation that was key to a straightforward sale.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (282 reviews)
Buyer review
First homers
about 1 year ago
First homers

We looked at several homes on our way to finding our first home, and soon noticed that we were following Kate around most weekends as she was hosting the majority of open homes we attended. We often commented that we admired Kate’s work ethic and preparation, presenting homes in a pleasant way and providing a welcoming feel, without being annoyingly pushy with endless follow up calls. Highly recommend.

Kate Andrew

Kate Andrew

  5   (115 reviews)
Buyer review
If I could give more than 5 stars I would
about 1 year ago
If I could give more than 5 stars I would

Keeley was absolutely incredible throughout the entire process of our purchase. She went above and beyond to make the process easy for me as a first home buyer. Her market knowledge and expertise is unmatched, and quality of service was spectacular. We would absolutely use Keeley to buy again and will use her when we sell ☺️

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (282 reviews)
Buyer review
Beautiful Omarama
about 1 year ago
Beautiful Omarama

Gary Sutherland Was exceptional with his knowledge and understanding of the property I bought through him. I would be more than happy to use him as my agent for any further dealings. Margie

Gary Sutherland AREINZ

Gary Sutherland AREINZ

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
Instant rapport with Peter & Dee
about 1 year ago
Instant rapport with Peter & Dee

We had a immediate rapport with Peter & Dee and they were able to make insightful suggestions as how to proceed with the sale process. To find a buyer in the short time frame they managed was amazing. I would not hesitate to recommend their services to potential vendors.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (313 reviews)
Seller review
Friendly, professional, excellent knowledge of local market, trustworthy, a pleasure to work with
about 1 year ago
Friendly, professional, excellent knowledge of local market, trustworthy, a pleasure to work with

Pip's combination of friendliness, expert local knowledge, and professionalism made her an outstanding (and easy) choice for us navigating selling a property from a distance. Her pricing was realistic - which she was able to do because she knows the Oamaru market in such depth. Pip guided us with dedication and expertise and went the extra mile. Her communication with us was fantastic. We wholeheartedly recommend Pip to anyone seeking a seamless and positive experience selling a property. She genuinely cared for us, and wanted us to get a good result. Thank you Pip.

Pip O'Connell

Pip O'Connell

  4.9   (238 reviews)
Seller review
Always professional with an awesome smile
about 1 year ago
Always professional with an awesome smile

Kate made the whole sales process very easy always communicating and giving 110% offering to help if needed . Her Market knowledge was exceptional spot on with her sale price. I had purchased my home through Kate and would not have chosen anyone else to sell it.

Kate Andrew

Kate Andrew

  5   (115 reviews)
Seller review
Kate The Great
about 1 year ago
Kate The Great

We picked Kate to market our property because of previous dealings I have had with her (I was a Project Manager for a house that she built). She has been amazing to deal with. Her marketing plan was awesome, and we achieved a sale in a reasonable period of time in a current market. We would definitely choose Kate to market a property for us in the future.

Kate Andrew

Kate Andrew

  5   (115 reviews)
Seller review
A great experience with Gary selling the house. Very knowledgeable about the area and very helpful
about 1 year ago
A great experience with Gary selling the house. Very knowledgeable about the area and very helpful

Gary’s knowledge of the area was invaluable to the sale of the house. He listened to what we were wanting and was always in communication with us about offers etc. Very helpful with his pointers in presenting the house to its best advantage. Worked very hard to get us what we were wanting for the house. All in all he made the selling of the home go smoothly. We would definitely recommend Gary to anyone looking at selling their place.

Gary Sutherland AREINZ

Gary Sutherland AREINZ

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
Highly recommend Leanne
about 1 year ago
Highly recommend Leanne

Leanne has been a fantastic agent throughout the whole selling process. She really gets the emotional side of selling and displays genuine support and empathy. Leanne is very efficient and professional with great communication every step of the way. Her knowledge of the area and expertise supported a quick sale of my property. Thank you Leanne, couldn't have done it without your fantastic support!

Leanne Black

Leanne Black

  4.8   (42 reviews)
337 - 348 of 1,628
Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
Contact Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent