Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
383 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, strategic, responsive, well-prepared, friendly, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great experience and result
about 1 year ago
Great experience and result

After being in the property game for a number of year's and selling multiple homes during that period, our experience with Andrew would have to be a Highlight. His Dedication, communication,commitment and enthusiasm in tough market conditions fetched us an outstanding result. His portfolio and other property listings attract the right buyer's, which then led to the sale of ours. Would highly recommend working with Andrew

Andrew Rochester

Andrew Rochester

  5   (65 reviews)
Seller review
Tony knowledge of the rural sector was extensive which he communicated very well
about 1 year ago
Tony knowledge of the rural sector was extensive which he communicated very well

Tony was very professional from the first day he came to look at our property. He had a strong knowledge of the rural sector, with all our questions answered. Communication was great. Tony would contact us after every open home, with feed back and was always available if we had further questions. Tony discussed the different options we could use to market our home, which he explained thoroughly. Tony made us feel at ease with the process which otherwise could have been very daunting. We would recommend Tony to any prospective seller. We built up a good rapport with Tony which we believe was important.

Tony Rasmussen

Tony Rasmussen

  4.8   (20 reviews)
Seller review
Professional
about 1 year ago
Professional

From purchasing a property to now selling my property Gretchen and her team have been professional and knowledgeable throughout, so lovely to deal with , I can’t recommend Gretchen enough to anyone that needs an agent.

Gretchen Paape

Gretchen Paape

  5   (182 reviews)
Seller review
Humble, trustworthy and a great communicator.
about 1 year ago
Humble, trustworthy and a great communicator.

From the get go, we both had strong and postive intuition when selecting Caleb at Bayley's to sell our home. Caleb's knowledge of the market, professionalism, high level of communication and integrity, was thorough and superb. We appreciated his insight of how to manage expectations, trusting in his capabilities, along with the assistance of lovely Wilma. Caleb was generous with his knowledge, dedication and care throughout our whole experience and gratefully, we were very happy with the outcome. If you are looking for an agent with proven knowledge, true integrity and transparency, Caleb is your man! We will certainly seek his help in the future of buying and selling in The Bay! Thank you so much Caleb, Wilma and the Bayley's Team.

Caleb Robinson

Caleb Robinson

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
Awesome to deal with and very professional
about 1 year ago
Awesome to deal with and very professional

Was advised by Andrew to go to auction with our property, best choice we made he exceeded our expectations with a great result. Andrew is very professional , great to deal with and very approachable I will be recommending him to people I know and will use him next year to sell our beach property in waimarama

Andrew Rochester

Andrew Rochester

  5   (65 reviews)
Seller review
The best there is!
about 1 year ago
The best there is!

If you’re searching for a real estate agent who truly goes above and beyond, look no further. Always proactive, attentive, and committed, this agent anticipated every step of our purchase, often addressing potential issues before they even arose. Their dedication to client satisfaction was evident in the countless extra efforts made—from thorough market research to flexible scheduling and clear communication throughout the process. With an impressive attention to detail and a sincere passion for helping clients succeed, this agent redefines what it means to go the extra mile in real estate. Highly recommended!

Caleb Robinson

Caleb Robinson

  5   (28 reviews)
Buyer review
Highly recommend
about 1 year ago
Highly recommend

We recently purchased a rural lifestyle block through Tony, and the experience was outstanding from start to finish. His communication was always clear, timely, and professional, which made the process smooth and stress-free. He went above and beyond to provide additional information we required to secure financing, which was incredibly helpful. We truly appreciated his honesty, responsiveness, and willingness to assist with every question we had. Highly recommended!

Tony Rasmussen

Tony Rasmussen

  4.8   (20 reviews)
Seller review
Sale of Te Maunga farms
about 1 year ago
Sale of Te Maunga farms

We had excellent service and a great result from Bayleys Our agent team of Jim Crispin and Monty Montieth did the business ( lead by Tony Rasmussen ) we were very happy with the result and the professionalism of the team. We certainly recommend them to you and you can have confidence in them , kind regards Andrew & Helen

Tony Rasmussen

Tony Rasmussen

  4.8   (20 reviews)
Seller review
Highly Recommend
about 1 year ago
Highly Recommend

From when we first purchased our home through Caleb back in 2017, we knew from then that when the time came, we would use Caleb when it came to selling. Roll forward 8 years and the we have now sold our home through Caleb and again we continue to be impressed by his upmost professionalism, clear communication and understanding. Particularly how he managed our expectations of the current market we were selling in to make sure that there were no surprises ahead of us. By working closely with Caleb, Wilma and his team we were able to achieve an outcome that far exceeded what we had originally hoped for. We would highly recommend Caleb, Wilma and the team to anyone looking to list their property.

Caleb Robinson

Caleb Robinson

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
Best Team in Hawke’s Bay!
about 1 year ago
Best Team in Hawke’s Bay!

Caleb and his team are absolutely outstanding! Incredibly insightful, genuine and honest, Caleb and his wonderful partners Aaron, Wilma and Shiloh are hands down the most wonderful team to work with in selling our beloved home. Fantastic communicators and wonderful expertise and knowledge, we could couldn’t be more thrilled to have chosen them to work with in producing an amazing result! Well done!! We are incredibly grateful to them. They are our first choice every time!

Caleb Robinson

Caleb Robinson

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
Highly recommended.
about 1 year ago
Highly recommended.

We found Caleb excellent to work with on the sale of our property. He was knowledgeable and professional and we felt he was a very ethical person to deal with. We would highly recommend him.

Caleb Robinson

Caleb Robinson

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
Very knowledgeable
about 1 year ago
Very knowledgeable

We have sold and bought a number of houses through Caleb as we trust his advise and judgement. He is helpful and has a great team behind him. We have had great results as a result of his diligence. Highly recommended.

Caleb Robinson

Caleb Robinson

  5   (28 reviews)
157 - 168 of 383
© 2026 RateMyAgent