Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1680 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Absolutely Amazing
12 months ago
Absolutely Amazing

She waltzed into our house and said, “do this, do this and start packing” - and then bugger me, she sold it!!! And then we said, “what about the section, and she said, “don’t worry, it’s happening “ and it’s now gone too! Hard to do better! With great appreciation John and Tasha

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (307 reviews)
Seller review
Very Happy
12 months ago
Very Happy

Very happy with Keely and Nikki. Very clear information throughout the marketing and sale process Excellent communication and a very satisfactory result. Highly recommend.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (307 reviews)
Seller review
One of a kind
12 months ago
One of a kind

Selling our property was never going to be straightforward — the home overlooked a race track and even had a vehicle showroom upstairs. It was unique, and we knew it wouldn’t appeal to the typical buyer. But Keeley never wavered. Keeley stayed patient, committed, and genuinely enthusiastic throughout the entire process. Week after week, she ran open homes, followed up every enquiry. Her determination and positivity kept us going when most people might have walked away. Thanks to Keeley's dedication, we found the right buyer for our one-of-a-kind property. We’re incredibly grateful for all her hard work and can’t recommend her highly enough.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (307 reviews)
Buyer review
Professional and Efficient - Hassle Free
12 months ago
Professional and Efficient - Hassle Free

Keeley was excellent to deal with. Her and the teams' professionalism was superb. Quick and directly to the point, no mucking around and very pleasant to boot. Would highly recommend Keely at Tall Poppy to anyone looking to purchase in the area.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (307 reviews)
Seller review
Seamless selling success
12 months ago
Seamless selling success

As an absentee owner following a medical event, Peter undertook everything necessary on our behalf to present the property to the market. His knowledge, understanding of the property & local market greatly assisted the listing & successful sale process. In all aspects our family have been impressed with Peter and his team, Brian Jones.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (326 reviews)
Seller review
Great to work with
12 months ago
Great to work with

Thank you so much, Andrew and Lydia, for helping us sell our house. Andrew’s extensive experience and thoughtful advice made the entire process smooth and stress-free. He provided all the information we needed at every step and was truly a pleasure to work with. A big thank-you as well to Lydia for her prompt responses and constant support throughout the process. We really appreciate everything you both did for us.

Andrew Berryman

Andrew Berryman

  5   (265 reviews)
Buyer review
Outstanding Service from Start to Finish
12 months ago
Outstanding Service from Start to Finish

My husband and I had an excellent experience working with Lydia as the selling agent on our recent property purchase. From start to finish, she was incredibly responsive and kept the process moving smoothly, even with the vendors being overseas and responding in different time zones. We never felt left in the dark - Lydia always got back to us promptly with answers and made sure actions were completed without delay. One of the things we appreciated most was her skill in negotiating a fair price. The property was initially listed well above market value, but Lydia was able to work with the vendors to reach a reasonable agreement that worked for everyone. Her ability to bridge that gap showed real professionalism and market knowledge. What really sets Lydia apart is her approachable, down-to-earth personality. She's friendly and genuine without any of the pushy or overconfident attitude you sometimes encounter in real estate agents. She made what can be a stressful process feel manageable and positive. We were so impressed with Lydia's work that when it comes time to sell our property, she'll be the first person we call. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, responsive, and trustworthy agent.

Lydia Dickson

Lydia Dickson

  5   (46 reviews)
Seller review
Johnny (Janie?) on the spot!
12 months ago
Johnny (Janie?) on the spot!

That was my experience working with Fiona: always at the ready to help. Quick to respond and always cheerful. A pleasure to work with. Thank you, Fiona.

Fiona Chapman

Fiona Chapman

  4.9   (35 reviews)
Seller review
Local Knowledge
12 months ago
Local Knowledge

Local knowledge is key. Dee and Peter have a full understanding of the local market, and that’s a big help in getting your property sold. The end result was exactly what we had targeted and so it doesn’t get better than that. Their fee structure was significantly cheaper than other agents and this was also helpful. Polite and punctual, thanks for your help.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (326 reviews)
Seller review
Goes above and beyond
12 months ago
Goes above and beyond

Hannah and Fiona are one of the most professional, customer-oriented, and fun agents we have ever had the pleasure of working with. Nothing is too hard. They worked tirelessly at all hours to get our home photographed, published, viewed, and sold within 8 days. We couldn’t have asked for better representation or a better result. Thank you, both. You are a credit to your industry.

Hannah Walker

Hannah Walker

  5   (141 reviews)
Seller review
Fiona demonstrated a very heigh level of professionalism, integrity, and honesty.
12 months ago
Fiona demonstrated a very heigh level of professionalism, integrity, and honesty.

Selling our property with Hannah and Fiona was an exceptional experience throughout the entire process. The process was seamless, stress-free, and with exceptional communication. We were kept well informed regularly and promptly. Both Hannah and Fiona demonstrated a very heigh level of professionalism and integrity throughout the entire journey and their honesty was refreshing. We would have no hesitation in recommending Fiona and the Tall Poppy team to anyone wanting to sell their property.

Fiona Chapman

Fiona Chapman

  4.9   (35 reviews)
Seller review
See comments below
12 months ago
See comments below

We used Peter as our agent for the 2nd time which speaks for itself. His property appraisal was realistic and he communicated well. Peter and Dee are a good team, acting with integrity. Thankyou.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (326 reviews)
241 - 252 of 1,680
Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
Contact Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent