Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
446 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Knowledgeable, warm and frank
9 months ago
Knowledgeable, warm and frank

I really appreciated Sharon’s warm, candid and efficient approach. She was knowledgeable about the market, and provided quick responses and sensible advice.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (252 reviews)
Buyer review
I had a great experience with Sharon and her team.
9 months ago
I had a great experience with Sharon and her team.

Nothing was too much trouble and all queries were answered very quickly. Highly recommend Sharon’s professionalism and market knowledge.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (252 reviews)
Buyer review
Professional approach and great advice
9 months ago
Professional approach and great advice

I have really liked working with the Donnelly team (Jamie and Sharon). They worked with me and showed me a number of properties, until I finally purchased a property that suited me. I appreciated Jamie’s advice and patience and low key non pushy approach. The Bayley’s team has a well-deserved great reputation in the region for sure.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (252 reviews)
Seller review
Honest reliable efficient caring agent in Wanaka
9 months ago
Honest reliable efficient caring agent in Wanaka

I had an excellent experience working with Scott.From start to finish, he was honest, reliable, and incredibly efficient. It’s rare to find someone in the real estate industry who truly cares about their clients the way Scott does Scott took the time to understand what I needed, provided clear and honest advice throughout the process, and was always quick to respond to any questions or concerns. I never felt rushed or pressured — just supported and well-informed. If you’re looking for a real estate agent who is trustworthy, dependable, and genuinely invested in your best interests, I highly recommend Scott.

Scott McGoun

Scott McGoun

  5   (49 reviews)
Buyer review
Sharon is extremely professional and her communication is outstanding.
9 months ago
Sharon is extremely professional and her communication is outstanding.

We worked with Sharon and Jamie on the sale of a property and purchase of another property which required a lot of administration and organisation. Jamie and Sharon's level of communication, helpfulness and timeliness with supply of information was truly impressive.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (252 reviews)
Seller review
Great and very detailed market knowledge.
9 months ago
Great and very detailed market knowledge.

Very genuine conversations and detailed knowledge of the Wanaka Market. Great team behind her.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (252 reviews)
Buyer review
Fantastic agent
10 months ago
Fantastic agent

We recently purchased a house through Scott, and his cool calm professional manner made it a stress free experience. Would recommend!

Scott McGoun

Scott McGoun

  5   (49 reviews)
Buyer review
13 Mills Road
10 months ago
13 Mills Road

Sharon and Jamie were amazing to work with! The entire purchasing process was smooth and completely stress-free. Everything on our end went perfectly, thanks to their professionalism and great communication. We would definitely buy from them again! Thanks again Steph & Matt Ryan

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (252 reviews)
Seller review
Great experience
10 months ago
Great experience

Thanks Scott, great job. Marketing was very impressive. Knew the local market extremely well.

Scott McGoun

Scott McGoun

  5   (49 reviews)
Buyer review
Very Helpful
10 months ago
Very Helpful

We recently purchased through Matt and he was very helpful from the start. Willing to show us through properties at short notice and communicated really well. Matt was quick to solve and answer questions during the sales process. We would highly recommend using Matt as an agent

Matt Ecroyd

Matt Ecroyd

  5   (89 reviews)
Seller review
Excellence, yet again!
10 months ago
Excellence, yet again!

I have used Sharon and Jamie for several transactions now and each one has been superb. Their ability to get results is amazing and they are supported by a fabulous team in the office. Sharon's network is extensive and very useful indeed. I principally deal with Jamie and he is just a great young man to work with; great communication, unfettered access, real honesty and humility. Most sincere thanks to the Sharon Donnelly Team for yet another great transaction.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (252 reviews)
Seller review
Great Result, Excellent Communication
10 months ago
Great Result, Excellent Communication

We recently sold our home with Matt and had a fantastic experience from start to finish. Matt was professional, approachable, and honest throughout the process. He communicated clearly, kept us fully informed, and made what can be a stressful time feel much more manageable. His knowledge of the Wanaka market and calm, confident approach gave us real peace of mind. We’re really grateful for his support and would absolutely recommend Matt to anyone looking to buy or sell in the area. Thanks Matt! Jenny and Jared S

Matt Ecroyd

Matt Ecroyd

  5   (89 reviews)
97 - 108 of 446
© 2026 RateMyAgent