Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
492 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Exceeded expectations again
1 day ago
Exceeded expectations again

We had an exceptional experience purchasing a new home for my elderly mother through Jamie and Sharon. From our first meeting through to settlement day, they went above and beyond to make the entire process as smooth and stress-free as possible. Their attention to detail, responsiveness, professionalism, and genuine commitment to helping us achieve our goals were second to none. This is our third time working with the Donnelly Property Team, both as buyers and sellers, and every experience has been outstanding. We have always felt valued, supported, and well-informed throughout the process, and once again, we are thrilled with the outcome. If you're looking for real estate agents who truly care about their clients and consistently deliver exceptional service, we highly recommend the Donnelly Property Team.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (277 reviews)
Seller review
Genuine, Straight Up Refreshing Approach.
3 days ago
Genuine, Straight Up Refreshing Approach.

We have now had the pleasure of having Sharon and her team sell four properties for us, and we wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them. What we love most about Sharon is that she tells it like it is. There’s no fluff, no sugar-coating and no telling you what you want to hear — she calls a spade a spade. Her honesty and straight-up approach are incredibly refreshing, and we have always trusted that the advice she gives us is genuine and in our best interests. Her knowledge of the market is exceptional, and she has an amazing network of clients and buyers on her books. She knows what is happening in the market, understands how to position a property and, most importantly, knows how to get the best result. What has really stood out to us is that her advice hasn’t stopped at simply selling our houses. She has also given us valuable, honest advice and ideas around our future property investments, which we really appreciate. On top of all of that, she is just a great person to deal with — professional, knowledgeable, straight-talking and genuinely invested in getting the best outcome for her clients.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (277 reviews)
Buyer review
Sharon showed us exactly what we were looking for.
4 days ago
Sharon showed us exactly what we were looking for.

Sharon has an excellent knowledge of the Wanaka market due to her experience in the local market, her communication style is direct and to the point. Her direct and friendly approach made the negotiation process quick and successful.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (277 reviews)
Seller review
• Exceptional Service and a Fantastic Outcome
6 days ago
• Exceptional Service and a Fantastic Outcome

"Bringing impeccable market intuition and a calm, collected approach, they seamlessly matched us with the perfect buyers to deliver a fair result in an impressively short timeframe."

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (277 reviews)
Seller review
First Class Team
10 days ago
First Class Team

Sharon and the team at Bayleys are the consummate professionals in every aspect of the sale process - i can't recommend them highly enough. Thank you Sharon and team!

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (277 reviews)
Buyer review
Easy to deal with and found me a house!!
22 days ago
Easy to deal with and found me a house!!

Very professional and very easy to deal with. Knew the market well, great communication!

Matt Ecroyd

Matt Ecroyd

  5   (98 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic communicator
24 days ago
Fantastic communicator

We couldn’t have asked for a better real estate agent than Matt. His communication was absolutely outstanding. He kept us updated every step of the way, often before we even had a chance to think of asking. He was incredibly positive, proactive and always got things done quickly and efficiently. Matt made the whole process feel easy and stress free, and we always felt like we were in very capable hands. His professionalism, communication and positive attitude really stood out. We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Matt to anyone looking to buy or sell, and we will definitely be using him again in the future!

Matt Ecroyd

Matt Ecroyd

  5   (98 reviews)
Seller review
Baileys - the perfect recommendation.
25 days ago
Baileys - the perfect recommendation.

Sharon and her team are very knowlegable about the Wanaka market. We approached Sharon to sell this property having been advised to use her services 7 years ago when we bought it. She and her team have been responsive, professional and well organised. The process of selling this property has been seamless and we would not hesitate to use Sharon again or recommend her to others.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (277 reviews)
Buyer review
Brilliant!
25 days ago
Brilliant!

Alice is a pleasure to work with, timely communication and responded to everything we needed to complete the purchase of our Cardrona Valley property. Super happy, thanks Alice!

Alice Mason

Alice Mason

  5   (9 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent
28 days ago
Excellent

Alice recently sold my property. She comes with great communication skills, market knowledge and professionalism My property wasn't an easy one to sell but with her perseverance and skill Alice did an amazing job

Alice Mason

Alice Mason

  5   (9 reviews)
Buyer review
Strong industry knowledge and we appreciated her direct and frank approach...
about 1 month ago
Strong industry knowledge and we appreciated her direct and frank approach...

Sharon was great to deal with. She clearly has a huge bank of experience behind her and we loved seeing how passionate she was about the property she is selling. We also appreciated how direct she was with us and is very timely in her responses via email, phone or in person (in our case face time).

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (277 reviews)
1 - 12 of 492
© 2026 RateMyAgent