
Reviews in Papatoetoe
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Buyer of 405/23A Pollen Street, Grey Lynn
If you are looking for a real estate agent who genuinely delivers then I recommend Carl Watkins from Barfoot & Thompson, Ponsonby. Carl has a deep knowledge of the local market. Equally impressive is his responsiveness. No matter the time of day he was always prompt in responding to questions, providing updates, and keeping the momentum going. Throughout the entire sale process Carl maintained the highest level of professionalism, handling every detail with care and integrity. Buying or selling real estate can be stressful, but Carl’s expertise and proactive communication made it seamless. Carl is an agent who is knowledgeable, incredibly fast on his feet and completely professional.
(0 reviews)
Reviews in Papatoetoe
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Reviews in Papatoetoe
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 88 St Andrews Rd, Epsom
We needed to sell fast. It was April/May 2026, the market was flat, and we'd already had an offer accepted on our next place — no time to wait for the "right buyer" to wander in. Cheryl's first move was pragmatism. The house had a CV of $3.56m, but rather than anchor to that number and hope, she talked us through the market realistically and helped us land on a floor of $3m — a number we could actually sell at, not one we wished we could. That distinction mattered more than anything else. From there she pushed for a proper campaign, not a quiet listing. We moved out so the house could be cleaned and staged, invested in a high-end photo package, and put real weight behind marketing on Trade Me and realestate.co.nz. She brought her own network of stagers, decorators, cleaners and photographers, so presenting the house at its best was her job, not ours. She arrived early to every open home — clearing leaves, heating on, lighting right — and followed up after every viewing with buyer feedback. Nothing was too hard. The response spoke for itself: over 35,000 website views, 88 viewings, four building inspections. Four weeks after listing, we went to auction with five registered bidders and a reserve of $3.2m — in a market where comparable properties were struggling for traction. The house sold under the hammer for $3.35m — over 10% above our $3m floor. Selling at auction at all, in that market, was an outcome in itself. Advice to other sellers: when Cheryl tells you something about pricing or strategy, listen. You wouldn't do your own dentistry because you think you know better — this isn't the place to overrule a professional either. Whether you're a first-home seller, under time pressure like we were, or moving a high-value property — Cheryl is who you want in your corner. Unqualified recommendation.

(476 reviews)



Reviews in Papatoetoe
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 60 Maskell Street, St Heliers
If you are after an excellent agent, choose Kelly Millwood. She will look after you and make sure that the experience of having your house on an extremely tough market goes as smoothly as possible. Kelly's communication and ways of keeping in touch is outstanding. She made sure we were informed every step of the way and was tremendously reassuring when something was not straightforward. Kelly combines warmth, caring and professionalism with a great depth of knowledge and experience. She also reads people very well. She knows when to negotioate and when to let go. Kelly is one of the rare agents who is so busy that she had a PA. Shasha was great too and excellent at keeping in touch. I highly recommend Kelly to you.
Buyer of 11 Alamein Road, Panmure
Jane was very responsive and showed genuine passion for the property we were interested in. She was warm and friendly in all our interactions while remaining a true professional, offering sage advice and market information.
Seller of 11 Alamein Road, Panmure
From the very beginning, she was professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly dedicated. She kept us informed throughout the entire process, communicated promptly, and always made herself available to answer our questions. We especially appreciated her honesty and strategic advice, which gave us confidence every step of the way. Selling a home is never easy, particularly during a significant life transition, but Jane handled everything with care, professionalism, and genuine kindness. She worked tirelessly to bring qualified buyers to the table and negotiated an excellent outcome. Jane's commitment didn't stop at the auction—she consistently went above and beyond, making what could have been a very stressful experience much smoother. We are truly grateful for all her hard work and would highly recommend Jane to anyone looking to buy or sell a property. Thank you, Jane, for helping us achieve such a wonderful result!
Suburb Winner
Glendowie2026Suburb Winner
St Heliers2026
Reviews in Papatoetoe
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price

Reviews in Papatoetoe
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 4/19 Eltham Road, Kohimarama
I found Michael to be very professional in the recent listing and selling of my property. He kept me well informed throughout the process which was very informative for me. He did open homes on a regular basis and always gave me feed back. I felt very comfortable with him and he had a very approachable manner. I would highly recommend him as a very experienced agent.

Reviews in Papatoetoe
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 52D Capstick Road, Otara
Rozie did an excellent work in selling my Development property. Her marketing strategy, negotiation skills, friendly approach and attention to detail made the selling process easy in a difficult market condition. We achieved a great outcome and highly recommend Rozie.
Reviews in Papatoetoe
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

(104 reviews)


Reviews in Papatoetoe
Sold
For Sale
Total sales value
Avg. sale price
Seller of 6 Vivaldi Place, Mount Roskill
We were very impressed with Ricky's service throughout the sale of our home. He was highly responsive, professional and kept us well informed at every stage. He shared his knowledge of the market with us and was very diligent, particularly with checking documents and ensuring everything was in order. We also appreciated the care he took to explain the process clearly and with patience. We would happily recommend him to anyone looking to sell their home.
Buyer of 146E Methuen Road, New Windsor
Buying my first home felt overwhelming, but my agent made the whole process smooth and stress-free. They were knowledgeable, responsive, and always took the time to explain everything clearly. I never felt pressured and always knew they had my best interests at heart. Highly recommend to any first-home buyer!
Buyer of 74A Awaroa Road, Sunnyvale
Prince was able to communicate very well for us being first home buyers. He was always available to answer any questions and understood the market for the time of purchase. He managed to effectively communicate and explain the structure to buying a house since this was all new to us. Prince was very helpful.