Back Bethlehem, Bay of Plenty

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

Agencies in Bethlehem, Bay of Plenty

Sorted by most reviews for agencies in Bethlehem over the past 12 months.
View Harcourts Papamoa Advantage Realty Ltd Papamoa's profile

Harcourts Papamoa Advantage Realty Ltd Papamoa

4.9

From 625 reviews overall

2026 Award Winner

Meet the team

Rachel ColeScott SymesLance McFarlane
+26

Last 12 months in Bethlehem

3

Reviews in Bethlehem

3

Sold

2

For Sale

$2.6m

Total sales value

$854k

Avg. sale price

Accolades

Region Top 5

ratemyagent award

Bay of Plenty2026

National Top 100

ratemyagent award

New Zealand2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Papamoa2026
Email
View Collab Realty - Bay of Plenty's profile

Collab Realty - Bay of Plenty

5.0

From 222 reviews overall

Meet the team

Paige SmithMel TaylorDee Gillard
+4

Last 12 months in Bethlehem

3

Reviews in Bethlehem

6

Sold

2

For Sale

$6.7m

Total sales value

$1.1m

Avg. sale price

Email
View EVES on Cameron's profile

EVES on Cameron

5.0

From 171 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Bethlehem

3

Reviews in Bethlehem

4

Sold

3

For Sale

$4.3m

Total sales value

$1.1m

Avg. sale price

Excellent service. The agent was friendly, professional,

“Excellent service from start to finish. The agent was very professional, knowledgeable, and always quick to respond. They made the buying process easy and stress-free. I would highly recommend them.”

2 months ago
Email
View EVES Cherrywood's profile

EVES Cherrywood

5.0

From 199 reviews overall

2026 Award Winner

Last 12 months in Bethlehem

2

Reviews in Bethlehem

9

Sold

16

For Sale

$9.1m

Total sales value

$1.1m

Avg. sale price

Totally professional and presented to us a very good Team approach.

From the first meeting we were very impressed with their presentation skills and market knowledge. It certainly helped with their dress sense as well together with clean black cars. It helped that we were after a Team to assist us selling our property, two heads better than one. Plus Eves has a good reputation in Tauranga.

Tim & Ro 2 months ago
Email
View Arizto's profile

Arizto

4.9

From 5553 reviews overall

2026 Award Winner

Meet the team

Leigh JacksonAnna JamesBev Waller
+346

Last 12 months in Bethlehem

2

Reviews in Bethlehem

2

Sold

1

For Sale

$1.2m

Total sales value

$1.2m

Avg. sale price

Accolades

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Amberley2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Ashhurst2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Burwood2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Castlecliff2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

East Gore2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Edgecumbe2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Fairy Springs2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Gonville2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Gore2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Hampstead2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Kaiapoi2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Kawaha Point2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Lincoln2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Mangakakahi2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Matarangi2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Mataura2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Methven2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Netherby2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Ngongotaha2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Pegasus2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Pukehangi2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Riversdale2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Riwaka2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Southbridge2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Springvale2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Westbrook2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Westport2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Whakatane2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Whanganui East2026

Suburb Winner

ratemyagent award

Woodend2026
Email
View Trueman & Co's profile

Trueman & Co

5.0

From 52 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Bethlehem

2

Reviews in Bethlehem

2

Sold

0

For Sale

$2.3m

Total sales value

$1.2m

Avg. sale price

Professional, honest and gets that sold sign up!

Lisa and her team were absolutely amazing. They came on board at a time when we were feeling exhausted and discouraged by the selling process, and they completely turned things around for us. Their positivity, energy, and clear plan helped us feel motivated and confident again. Our home had been on the market for four months before we engaged Lisa and her team. With their fresh approach, it truly felt like a new beginning, and we were very happy to achieve a sale within just six weeks. Lisa and Craig were a pleasure to work with — always professional, honest, and genuinely available whenever we needed them. They took the time to patiently guide us through each step, explained things clearly, and offered thoughtful options whenever we had questions. Any small challenges along the way were handled calmly and with practical solutions. We couldn’t recommend Lisa and the Trueman team more highly. Thank you all for your hard work, care, and dedication. Thanks guys!

Sarah & John 13 days ago
Email
View EVES Bethlehem's profile

EVES Bethlehem

5.0

From 5 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Bethlehem

2

Reviews in Bethlehem

12

Sold

8

For Sale

$9.2m

Total sales value

$1.1m

Avg. sale price

Rate my agent

Neil was a super agent to deal with throughout all stages of our property sale. He was knowledgeable, professional and above all dealt with an emotional situation with empathy. Neil's communication throughout the sale process was excellent. We would highly recommend Neil as an agent.

David Fuller 7 months ago
Email
View Bower Omokoroa's profile

Bower Omokoroa

4.9

From 121 reviews overall

Last 12 months in Bethlehem

2

Reviews in Bethlehem

7

Sold

1

For Sale

$9.1m

Total sales value

$1.3m

Avg. sale price

Noel is a genuinely lovely person! What you see if what you get.

We met Noel many years ago at an open home and when it was time to list our house we knew it had to be him! Great communicator, always kept in the loop and always had our best interests at heart. Being a local we felt also helped as everyone knows Noel and Angela in our neighbourhood and local knowledge a real advantage. Noel has also gone above and beyond trying to help us find our next house sending links through to places we might like and also attending an open home with us. We would highly recommend Noel if you are looking for an agent that really is not your standard agent, more like a family member! Thanks so much Noel we couldn’t have done this without you. Kelly, Brad and the girls.

Kelly Cross about 1 month ago
Email
View EAST REALTY's profile

EAST REALTY

5.0

From 103 reviews overall

Meet the team

Tracey EastNandi FreemanJude McIsaac
+1

Last 12 months in Bethlehem

2

Reviews in Bethlehem

5

Sold

0

For Sale

$4.6m

Total sales value

$920k

Avg. sale price

Email
10 - 18 of 44

View nearby Suburbs

© 2026 RateMyAgent