Back Waiheke Island

Find a real estate agent in 6 easy steps

Share your situation without sharing personal details, and we'll find the right real estate agent to help you.

Find Me An Agent

73 real estate agents in Waiheke Island

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Waiheke Island over the past 12 months.
View Tobias Roebuck-Ward's profile
5.0

From 30 reviews overall

Tobias Roebuck-Ward

Tobias Roebuck-Ward

Waiheke Homes

Last 12 months in Waiheke Island

N/A

Avg. sale price

15

Sold (as lead agent)

20

Reviews in Waiheke Island

N/A

Median days on market

A masterclass in creativity, persistence, professionalism… and a few laughs along the way

Selling a unique property on Waiheke isn’t the same as selling a house in a standard suburban street. It takes creativity, patience, resilience, and someone willing to think differently when the obvious path isn’t working. Tobias delivered all of that and more. From day one, he approached the sale with a level of professionalism and commitment that gave us confidence we had the right person in our corner. What stood out most was his willingness to think outside the box. Whenever a challenge appeared, Tobias wasn’t looking for reasons why something couldn’t be done… he was looking for new ways to make it happen. His tenacity throughout the campaign was exceptional. He consistently followed up opportunities, kept momentum alive, and remained focused on finding the right buyer rather than simply waiting for one to appear. Selling property can often feel stressful and uncertain, but Tobias’ communication was excellent throughout. We always knew where things stood, what the next steps were, and what he was doing behind the scenes to progress the sale. Beyond the professional side, Tobias is simply a great person to deal with. He has outstanding interpersonal skills, quickly builds trust, and knows how to connect with people from all walks of life. He strikes the perfect balance between being highly professional and genuinely personable, with a nice sprinkle of top shelf banter too. What impressed us most was that Tobias genuinely cared about achieving the best possible outcome, not just completing a transaction. His energy, enthusiasm, and commitment never wavered, and the successful sale of our bach is a direct result of the effort he put in. If you’re looking for an agent who combines professionalism, creativity, persistence, strong negotiation skills, and the ability to make the journey enjoyable along the way, we would recommend Tobias without hesitation. Five stars isn’t enough. Thank you Tobias and Team ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Paul A. 24 days ago
Email
View Hayden Ringrose's profile
4.9

From 15 reviews overall

Hayden Ringrose

Hayden Ringrose

Bayleys Waiheke

Last 12 months in Waiheke Island

$1.4m

Avg. sale price

15

Sold (as lead agent)

14

Reviews in Waiheke Island

70

Median days on market

Hayden was an excellent agent for us. Perfect balance of advice assistance and easy to deal with.

Everything we needed skills wise and knowledgeable. Happy to recommend to anyone on or off Waiheke

Jacquelyne and Craig Taylor about 2 months ago
Email
View Karen McMahon's profile
5.0

From 31 reviews overall

Karen McMahon

Karen McMahon

Harcourts Cooper & Co - Devonport

Last 12 months in Waiheke Island

$1.2m

Avg. sale price

8

Sold (as lead agent)

9

Reviews in Waiheke Island

31

Median days on market

Karen and Greg – The Best of the Best

Karen and Greg were professional, well organised, and wonderfully easy to work with. They were extremely encouraging and supportive. They helped us through the necessary processes, paperwork and hurdles we faced. Many times they provided assistance that was far beyond that which would usually be expected from real estate agents. Karen and Greg embody the wonderful community spirit of Waiheke. We were blessed to have them as our agents, and we cannot recommend them highly enough.

15 days ago
Email
View Jacob Heatley-Adams' profile
5.0

From 5 reviews overall

Jacob Heatley-Adams

Jacob Heatley-Adams

Bayleys Real Estate Limited

Last 12 months in Waiheke Island

$1.7m

Avg. sale price

9

Sold (as lead agent)

5

Reviews in Waiheke Island

30

Median days on market

Free Market ReportEmail
1 - 9 of 73

Suburbs in Waiheke Island

View nearby Cities

© 2026 RateMyAgent