Polly's profile

Polly's reviews

  5  
Polly has 72 reviewsacross 31 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
Polly is Amazing!
over 2 years ago
Polly is Amazing!

Polly was very professional and helpful. Made the process easy for me.

Seller review
Second house sold for us by Polly!
almost 3 years ago
Second house sold for us by Polly!

Yet again, we have received an excellent result from our favourite agent Polly! Polly is a pleasure to work with. Her professionalism, tenacity & knowledge is the reason that we continue to list with her. Thanks for another great experience.

Seller review
Top professional knowledge and communication !
almost 3 years ago
Top professional knowledge and communication !

In our situation, good market knowledge and frank conversations were important. Central to our success was Polly’s professional understanding of the market, the property, the vendor and buyers needs, and she connected us with the right deal that we could walk away from, knowing things had been done well. Polly took care of details along the way, keeping us informed at every step. Because of this communication, we had total confidence in her ability to represent us and to achieve a favourable outcome. We can fully recommend her - thank you so much :)

Buyer review
Absolutely brilliant!!
almost 3 years ago
Absolutely brilliant!!

Polly has been absolutely brilliant. She made selling the house to me such a breeze! All of my questions and concerns were answered in a timely manner, she was always so friendly and communicated really well. During the time to make an offer, she explained the entire process, what each part of the contract meant and answered all of my questions. I felt extremely comfortable and confident. Thank you soooo much Polly!!! If I ever need to sell my house, I'll be using you! :D

Buyer review
Recent Purchase - Polly Matena - Schaff
almost 3 years ago
Recent Purchase - Polly Matena - Schaff

Upon first meeting with Polly at the property we have now purchased, we found her to be extremely welcoming. She had a great appreciation for the property and our family needs when showing us around. Throughout this experience, Polly has maintained great communication and I certainly believe has gone above and beyond by making herself available in the evening to talk through the next steps, any concerns we may have had or simply coordinating another viewing on the property in those earlier days, With this being our third property purchase, I'm pleased to say it's been the simplest by far and most enjoyable to date which is a testament to how Polly has managed the process both professionally and with that personal down to earth touch. We would happily recommend Polly and wish her continued success. Kind Regards Lee & Sonia

Seller review
Exceded all expecations we had!
almost 3 years ago
Exceded all expecations we had!

I can simply recommend Polly without hesitation. Polly made everything about selling this property a breeze, especially since we live outside of Dunedin. She was methodical, had excellent time management & honest. She assisted with our previous tenants, management of getting the property open home ready, and had great industry knowledge on items that would add more value. Her communication was outstanding and I had full faith and trust in her ability to deliver. You would be silly to list with someone else.

Buyer review
An asset to both buyers & sellers
almost 3 years ago
An asset to both buyers & sellers

We cannot speak more highly of Polly. As first time home buyers she was supportive and informative at every step of the process. She was amazing at understanding our needs as a young family and communicating that to her vendor, as well as communicating back her vendors needs to us, which made for a quick and friendly sale and conditional period. We feel so lucky to have had Polly as the agent for our first home purchase, it would not have been such an amazing experience without her!

Seller review
Polly made things happen!
almost 3 years ago
Polly made things happen!

Thank you Polly for your energy, your insight into who would be buying my property and following through to secure the sale. You made this happen and I am so grateful to you. I loved having you at my home, your positive energy and can-do attitude made all the difference. Knowing the statistics from you throughout the process meant that I could reach the correct market. I was not expecting to sell my home after 3 open homes! Great result! Thank you Polly! xx

Seller review
Amazing experience
almost 3 years ago
Amazing experience

Polly has been amazing and gone way beyond expectations in the sale of my Father inlaws house , it wasnt easy as we do not live close and Polly has pretty much taken care of everything and done personal visits to Robin instead of phone calls and emails ❤️

Seller review
The most beautiful, helpful and honest agent I've ever worked with!
almost 3 years ago
The most beautiful, helpful and honest agent I've ever worked with!

Polly was an absolute dream to work with, I was on a tight deadline to sell my house so I could purchase my new property, and Polly was so helpful.. she even got on the vacuum cleaner to help! Such a genuine person, who cares about her vendors. Even when things got a bit exhausting for me, Polly was right there supporting me, I always knew she had my back. Her communication was top notch, and she went the extra mile to get my property sold! I would happily recommend Polly to anyone who wants an agent to sell their home who is not just interested in getting their commission. My experiences with real estate agents haven't been great, so Polly is definitely a breath of fresh air! Thanks again Polly, you're amazing!

Buyer review
Outstanding Performance
about 3 years ago
Outstanding Performance

Polly was great help with our recent purchase. Very helpful, resourceful and reliable. She will go out her way to help. Thank you for everything Polly wish you a great success!

49 - 60 of 72
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent