Polly's profile

Polly's reviews

  5  
Polly has 72 reviewsacross 31 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
Polly a real gem
over 2 years ago
Polly a real gem

I had a very limited time in Dunedin to attend to my property purchase and Polly was readily available, always pleasant and made the whole sale process efficient and less frenetic than it might have been. If you are buying or selling, I think you will find Polly a real gem to deal with.

Seller review
Considerate and personable
over 2 years ago
Considerate and personable

Polly went above and beyond to sell two properties for us during a really difficult time. She was constant with her approach, got in with out hesitation to sort a ex rental property, and even continued to mow the lawns at a property out of town for the duration of the marketing period. I would highly recommend Polly as an estate agent and wish her all the best for her bright future moving forward.

Buyer review
Happy home owners
over 2 years ago
Happy home owners

Not the smoothest of rides but when met with such professionalism it felt like a breeze, keeping an open line of communication without being pushy or overbearing. You can tell Polly cares about what she does and all the small touches really do make all the difference. Very happy with the outcome and the purchase of our first home.

Seller review
Outstanding
over 2 years ago
Outstanding

I first met Polly during a very difficult and distressing time for me personally. I knew when I met Polly that she was the only person I would trust to sell my property when the time came to go to market. We stayed in touch and the time did finally come. Polly is an empathetic person who connects with people, listens and goes above and beyond for, I think, everyone that she comes into contact with. She is intelligent, knowledgeable and exceptional at her job. I rarely write reviews, however Polly is an exception. Whether selling or purchasing I absolutely highly recommend Polly Matena-Schaaf.

Seller review
Outstanding
over 2 years ago
Outstanding

I first met Polly during a very difficult and distressing time for me personally. I knew when I met Polly that she was the only person I would trust to sell my property when the time came to go to market. We stayed in touch and the time did finally come. Polly is an empathetic person who connects with people, listens and goes above and beyond for, I think, everyone that she comes into contact with. She is intelligent, knowledgeable and exceptional at her job. I rarely write reviews, however Polly is an exception. Whether selling or purchasing I absolutely highly recommend Polly Matena-Schaaf. Verified by RateMyAgent

Buyer review
Polly is Amazing!
over 2 years ago
Polly is Amazing!

We were first home buyers and we were in the market for 6 months. Out of all the REA that we met, we find Polly as one of the best REA in Dunedin! Polly was really accommodating! Her communication to us was exceptional and she assisted us along the way. Polly was able to make things easier for us despite the great stress that came with buying our first home. We would like to thank Polly for everything and keep up the great work that you do! ☺️

Seller review
Polly is amazing - she get's results
over 2 years ago
Polly is amazing - she get's results

Polly was a delight to work with in every aspect of the real estate process. She delivered invaluable marketing advice backed by profound knowledge and extensive experience. Polly’s commitment to her work was evident; she went above and beyond, working tirelessly to ensure our needs were met and yet her approach is wonderfully relaxed, creating a stress-free environment while navigating the real estate complexities. I couldn't be happier : )

Seller review
Proactive and efficient
over 2 years ago
Proactive and efficient

Selling our house in Dunedin using Polly was an absolute pleasure to work with, she was an absolute expert at advertising our house and took advantage of many aspects that today's market has to offer in regards. Would be more than happy to use her again.

Seller review
Excellent and easy
over 2 years ago
Excellent and easy

Polly has been fantastic to deal with, professional, punctual and thoughtful. A fresh approach to marketing which sold our house in a couple of weeks! Highly recommend 😊✅👍🏻

Seller review
Thank you Polly 😃
over 2 years ago
Thank you Polly 😃

Second to none in our book! Polly is a fantastic listener who seamlessly takes you under her wing through what can be a very stressful undertaking and created a journey alongside us that was faultless in its reliability and integrity. We leaned into Polly and her sound advise all the way through with no regrets just gratitude 🩷 Thank you Polly!!!

Seller review
Outstanding professionalism and very personal touch
over 2 years ago
Outstanding professionalism and very personal touch

We chose Polly to undertake the sale of our home, because of her upbeat, no-nonsense, bright and personal approach to selling property, along with a youthful knowledge and understanding of the technology that now surrounds the market. Polly went above and beyond with helpfulness and advice towards getting the property ready. Communication through the whole experience was respectful, professional and light, with the minimum of stress. We have really enjoyed our whole experience listing with Polly, and absolutely recommend her for anyone wanting efficiency, respect, honesty, kindness and even laughs. Thank you so much Polly, From Jelte and Sonia

Buyer review
Wonderful lady
over 2 years ago
Wonderful lady

Absolutely wonderful lady to work with, very patient. Excellent communication very highly recommended. Thank you so much for everything.

37 - 48 of 72
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent