Polly's profile

Polly's reviews

  5  
Polly has 72 reviewsacross 31 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
Beautiful inside and out
12 months ago
Beautiful inside and out

I’ve really enjoy my experience with Polly. She’s so kind and understanding and not at all pushy. She was so helpful throughout the entire buying process and felt confident in her. She was very knowledge and fair and answered all my questions with such poise and grace and could recommend her enough. Thank you for making this an easy experience.

Buyer review
First-Home Dream Come True – Fast, Safe, and Seamless with Polly
about 1 year ago
First-Home Dream Come True – Fast, Safe, and Seamless with Polly

Buying our first home was a huge milestone, and we couldn’t have asked for a better agent than Polly Matena-Schaaf to guide us through it. From day one, Polly showed exceptional market knowledge, clear and timely communication, and a level of professionalism that instantly put us at ease. She acted quickly and confidently, yet always made sure we fully understood each step and felt safe in her hands. Her support was genuine and personal—we truly felt like she cared as much as we did. Thanks to Polly, the process felt less overwhelming and more exciting. We’re incredibly grateful to her for making our first home journey so smooth and positive. We wish her nothing but continued success and highly recommend her to anyone looking for a trustworthy and dedicated real estate professional.

Seller review
A pleasure to work with
over 1 year ago
A pleasure to work with

Selling a house can be stressful, and add a short turnover even more so! We placed our trust in Polly and she pulled it off in 3 weeks. With great communication and knowledge, she made the whole process a breeze! we could not recommend Polly enough :)

Buyer review
Caldwell Street property
over 1 year ago
Caldwell Street property

Polly was really good to deal with, if she couldn’t answer something immediately she would get clarification and come back to us as quickly as she could

Seller review
Polly is super supportive and knowledgable
over 1 year ago
Polly is super supportive and knowledgable

one of best real estate agents, keep us right advice and what we need to improve our sale chance, highly recommended. Awesome.

Buyer review
Thoroughly enjoyed working with Polly. She is a professional and trustworthy Agent.
over 1 year ago
Thoroughly enjoyed working with Polly. She is a professional and trustworthy Agent.

I purchased a house which was in Dunedin and I live in Auckland. Polly managed all facets of the inspections - to which there were many due to the fact that I could not view the house myself. Polly provided a very professional service and communicated with me immediately throughout the whole process. I had had one, to me, mayor issue which was resolved within a minute thanks to Polly. Polly made the whole process feel easy. She's very professional and such a lovely person.

Buyer review
Genuine care for her clients
over 1 year ago
Genuine care for her clients

Given the chance, we would definitely choose Polly for our next investment property. Her thorough knowledge of the market and prompt responses to our inquiries made the entire process smooth and enjoyable. We felt supported and well-informed every step of the way.

Seller review
The Best Agent
over 1 year ago
The Best Agent

Polly's dedication, positivity and proactive communication make her stand out as the best agent we have ever worked with. She provided helpful market research, was always prompt and proactive in communication and her negotiating skills were a real asset. Polly is a pleasure to work with and we wouldn't hesitate to recommend her to anyone.

Buyer review
Can’t recommend Polly enough!
about 2 years ago
Can’t recommend Polly enough!

From the get go Polly was amazing to work with. Her open communication was something we really appreciated. Polly ensured all our questions were answered and guided us through the buying process so well. Polly was always so friendly, and professional. We never felt out of the loop or in the dark at any stage. We can’t thank Polly enough for the time and patience she gave us and for making the whole process feel so much less stressful. We can’t recommend Polly enough!

Seller review
Absolutely Amazing!
about 2 years ago
Absolutely Amazing!

Polly has been truly amazing to our whānau, she has gone above and beyond to make sure the whole process has run as smoothly as possible. Her communication is outstanding and she has been super supportive in every aspect of the sale. We felt really looked after and are incredibly grateful to have been able to work with Polly!

Buyer review
Excellent service
about 2 years ago
Excellent service

We would like to thank you Polly for the awesome service give us for buying our first home. Polly is very professional. Excellent communication and very helpful from the start. Highly recommended. Thanks

13 - 24 of 72
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent