Nic's profile

Nic's reviews

  5  
Nic has 33 reviewsacross 9 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
Top North Shore Agents
7 months ago
Top North Shore Agents

We couldn't be happier with Nic and his team. They are a true professional who knows the market inside and out. If you want to sell your house for top dollar, this is the agent to call."

Seller review
Super helpful and easy to work with.
8 months ago
Super helpful and easy to work with.

We had an excellent experience working with Team Mayhew from start to finish. Communication was clear, timely, and proactive — we always felt informed and supported, and no question was ever too small. They guided us through every stage of the process with calm confidence and professionalism, which made what could have been a stressful experience feel far more manageable. Their market knowledge, practical advice, and willingness to go the extra mile really stood out. We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell a home and would gladly work with them again.

Seller review
Front Row Service
10 months ago
Front Row Service

We could not have asked for more from Nic and Team Mayhew. He has a very calm and positive approach to his work and gave us excellent advice right from when we first discussed going on the market through to, and including, the auction itself. In a still tricky market we got an excellent outcome. Importantly we never felt under any pressure, the decisions were ours to make but he ensured we had all the information we needed to make the right calls. Highly recommended.

Seller review
 Professional expertise and service
10 months ago
Professional expertise and service

Team Mayhew have been great communicating with us over the sale of our property, especially important to us as we have not been in the area during the process. Great attention to detail.

Buyer review
Great experience
10 months ago
Great experience

Nic has been straightforward to deal with; he is proactive and contactable. Highly recommended

Buyer review
Excellent service
11 months ago
Excellent service

Nic was always super responsive, and has been awesome to work with as buyers. He is transparent and genuine. He is also calm and not pushy which we appreciate.

Seller review
Made it happen
11 months ago
Made it happen

We couldn’t be happier with our experience working with Team Mayhew. Selling a home in this market wasn’t easy, but their professionalism, dedication, and expertise made all the difference. From the very first meeting, they provided honest advice, clear communication, and a solid strategy that gave us confidence every step of the way, they went above and beyond — from staging suggestions and high-quality marketing to negotiating effectively when offers came in. Even when the market was slow, they stayed positive, proactive, and always kept us informed. Thanks to their hard work, our house sold, the process was smoother than we ever expected.

Buyer review
Super responsive and great to work with!
12 months ago
Super responsive and great to work with!

Nic was fantastic to work with, especially as we were overseas at the time of purchase and we are new to the country and he guided us through the process. He was helpful, patient, and trustworthy. He continues to be super helpful and accommodating in the the lead up to settlement. I would definitely recommend.

Buyer review
Great Agent
12 months ago
Great Agent

Nic was so great as the agent when we purchased our first home. He didn’t pressure or push but was there for any questions and promptly responded. Thanks Nic!

Seller review
Team Mayhew
about 1 year ago
Team Mayhew

Working with Sue Mayhew and Nic Mayhew was an absolute pleasure from start to finish not to mention the amazing result they achieved at Auction. They were very professional throughout the process displaying deep market knowledge, and genuine care for our needs made the entire selling process smooth and stress-free. They were always available to answer questions, provided honest advice, and went above and beyond to ensure we felt confident every step of the way. Thanks to their dedication and expertise, we achieved a fantastic result and couldn’t be happier. We highly recommend Team Mayhew to anyone looking for a trustworthy and results-driven real estate partnership.

Seller review
Team Mayhew 10/10
over 1 year ago
Team Mayhew 10/10

Team Mayhew had the task of selling our lovely home on Northcote point, in a market that had really stalled. They persevered and provided ongoing support to us, giving us confidence that the strategy we had would work. We could not recommend them more highly. A wonderful team of real estate professionals.

13 - 24 of 33
© 2026 RateMyAgent