Ailsa McArthur

Ailsa McArthur

Lifestyle and Residential Sales at Bayleys Coatesville (Bayleys Realty Group Ltd)
  •   5   (106 reviews)

Ailsa's sales performance at a glance

See how Ailsa has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

20
Reviews
97
Median days on market
21
Properties for sale
36
Sold properties
$2.2m
Average sale price
$80.1m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.co.nz. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

About Ailsa

Ailsa McArthur is part of the Bayleys lifestyle and residential sales team bringing a valued set of skills to the real estate table. Selling both residential and lifestyle properties, Ailsa is supported by her own skilled team; Chelsea Allen, a licensed Real Estate Salesperson and Paula Blaxall, Administration Manager also licensed under the REA Act 2008, allowing Ailsa to focus 100% on achieving the best possible result for her clients. Ailsa draws on personal experience living on a lifestyle property plus an awareness of customer requirements honed through the last 16 years as a Real Estate Salesperson. Previous roles in the construction industry add real value to the real estate process for her clients. Ailsa’s business within the Bayleys banner has proved to be a rewarding partnership. The company’s profile, reach and innovative approach together with Ailsa’s professional ethics and strong vision is realised as her consistent successes demonstrate. Whilst working in the building industry, Ailsa gathered a wealth of knowledge about residential building processes and an astute understanding of fundamentals around the marketing of sections. Ailsa is a proven professional who takes the time to tailor to individual needs. She has a strong drive and puts multiple layers of marketing techniques together for her clients, delivering a superior client service that ensures a solid ongoing referral business. Professional connections enhance the personal database of clients that Ailsa has built up. Ailsa prides herself on forming lasting working relationships with a broad range of people and one of her key values is “to do the right thing” in all aspects of business. Keen to play an active role in her community, Ailsa belongs to her local Residents and Rate Payers Association, and sponsors Coatesville School and the Homelink Road Safety School Workbooks (Albany, Coatesville, Kristin and Pinehurst Primary Schools). Ailsa is also proud to have previously sponsored the Coatesville Classic Running Event, Dairy Flat Tennis Club and organised the local primary school Agricultural Day Judges. Ailsa is an award-winning agent; her achievements include: • Top 5% of Bayleys Salespeople 2025/26, 2024/25, 2023/24, 2022/23, 2021/22, 2020/21 • Bayleys Salesperson No.1 Coatesville Office 2025/26, 2024/25, 2023/24, 2022/23, 2021/22, 2020/21 • Bayleys Salesperson No.1 North Shore 2021/22, 2019/20 & No.14 NZ wide 2019/20 • Bayleys Salesperson No.2 North Shore 2020/21, 2018/19, 2017/18, 2016/17 • Bayleys Salesperson No.1 Albany Office 2019/20, 2018/19, 2017/18, 2016/17 • Bayleys Top Achiever Nationwide 2024/25, 2021/22 • Bayleys 700 Million+ Sales Club Member • Bayleys Auction Club Member 2025/26, 2022/23, 2021/22

Languages spoken

English

Social profiles

Ailsa's reviews

  5  
Ailsa has 106 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 6.
Review Ailsa
Ailsa's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, responsive, supportive, honest, reliable, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
All round excellence!!!
1 day ago
All round excellence!!!

I’ve been extremely happy with the way Ailsa has handled the sale of my property. Her communication has been excellent throughout: prompt, clear and proactive. I’ve always felt informed about what was happening and what the next steps were. Ailsa has a great eye for detail and is very thorough, which has made the whole process feel well managed. I’ve value her knowledge of the local market. Her advice has been practical, well considered and grounded. She has a strong understanding of both the area and current buyer activity. I’d also add Ailsa, and her team are very approachable, professional and very easy to work with. I’ve felt in very capable hands. A special mention that on Ailsa’s team is the talented Chelsea Allen. Chelsea was key to securing my sale. She is an asset to any sales process and compliments Ailsa beautifully. Chelsea particularly helped getting fantastic marketing photos, as well as supporting negotiations. I would very happily recommend Ailsa and Chelsea. Definitely call them!

Buyer review
Experienced, patient and always easy to reach.
1 day ago
Experienced, patient and always easy to reach.

We had a great experience working with Ailsa. From the outset she was incredibly helpful, down to earth and genuinely easy to deal with, which made a big difference throughout the whole process. Our settlement ended up being quite complex and took much longer than expected, but Ailsa was patient, calm and supportive the entire way through. Her vast experience really showed, and was a big part of why we felt so comfortable and confident throughout the process. She never made anything feel like a problem and was always happy to help us work through whatever came up. During the auction process she was also incredibly flexible, including making some last-minute changes before it began and without any fuss, which we really appreciated. One of the things we valued most was how accessible she was. Ailsa was always easy to get hold of, quick to respond and happy to talk things through whenever we needed. That level of communication gave us a lot of confidence during what could otherwise have been a fairly stressful process. We really enjoyed working with Ailsa and would happily recommend her to anyone looking for an experienced, friendly, patient and genuinely supportive agent.

Buyer review
Excellent Agent Ailsa & Fabulous Team - Brilliant to work with and best in class at what they do!
5 days ago
Excellent Agent Ailsa & Fabulous Team - Brilliant to work with and best in class at what they do!

Ailsa McArthur and her team at Bayleys were fantastic to work with. Ailsa was instrumental in getting the deal done, working thoughtfully with both us as the buyer and the vendor to bring the two sides together. She was highly professional, proactive and solution-focused throughout, and made what could have been a complicated process feel straightforward. Ailsa, Chelsea and Paula were a genuine pleasure to work with, and we would happily and highly recommend their team whether you’re buying or selling. Absolutely best in class!

Seller review
Great honest communication
16 days ago
Great honest communication

Ailsa kept us well informed during the whole sale process. We got a sale result in a tough market with an agent who was dynamic enough to make it all work!

Seller review
Ailsa is an exceptional agent—professional, trustworthy and caring, with outstanding local expertise
about 1 month ago
Ailsa is an exceptional agent—professional, trustworthy and caring, with outstanding local expertise

We couldn’t recommend Ailsa and her team more highly. From the outset, they were professional, knowledgeable and excellent to work with. Ailsa is a true expert in the area. What truly sets Ailsa apart is her genuine care and commitment to her clients. I have the utmost respect for Ailsa, both personally and professionally, and hold her in the highest regard. I would have no hesitation recommending Ailsa and her team to anyone looking to sell their home.

Buyer review
Ailsa and the team were amazing!
about 1 month ago
Ailsa and the team were amazing!

We had a great experience working with Ailsa. She was incredibly helpful and supportive throughout the whole process, always friendly and easy to deal with. She was available whenever we needed her, quick to answer our questions, and made everything feel straightforward and stress-free. We really appreciated her help and would happily recommend her to others.

Show all 106 reviews
map

Ailsa's properties

Ailsa has 21 properties for sale and sold 36 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldSep 29, 2026
Price not available
750 Ridge Road
Coatesville Auckland
4
2
2
Rural
SoldSep 23, 2026
Price not available
141a Glenmore Road
Coatesville Auckland
Rural
For Sale
$2,930,000
A/282A Coatesville-Riverhead Highway
Coatesville Auckland
5
3
2
Other
SoldSep 11, 2026
Price not available
47 Sunnyside Road
Coatesville Auckland
5
4
3
Acreage Semi-Rural
Show all 57 properties
See Ailsa at work
Get a genuine perspective of what it’s like working with Ailsa.
Auctions
Huapai

Ailsa's sold properties

Ailsa has sold 36 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
750 Ridge Road, Coatesville, Auckland
750 Ridge Road
Coatesville Auckland
4
2
2
RuralUndisclosed PriceSep 29, 2026
141a Glenmore Road, Coatesville, Auckland
141a Glenmore Road
Coatesville Auckland
RuralUndisclosed PriceSep 23, 2026
47 Sunnyside Road, Coatesville, Auckland
47 Sunnyside Road
Coatesville Auckland
5
4
3
propertyTypes.acreage-semi-ruralUndisclosed PriceSep 11, 2026
87 Hartway Grove, Coatesville, Auckland
87 Hartway Grove
Coatesville Auckland
5
3
2
RuralUndisclosed PriceSep 10, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent