Ailsa's profile

Ailsa's reviews

  5  
Ailsa has 104 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Ailsa's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, responsive, supportive, honest, reliable, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Excellent Agent Ailsa & Fabulous Team - Brilliant to work with and best in class at what they do!
1 day ago
Excellent Agent Ailsa & Fabulous Team - Brilliant to work with and best in class at what they do!

Ailsa McArthur and her team at Bayleys were fantastic to work with. Ailsa was instrumental in getting the deal done, working thoughtfully with both us as the buyer and the vendor to bring the two sides together. She was highly professional, proactive and solution-focused throughout, and made what could have been a complicated process feel straightforward. Ailsa, Chelsea and Paula were a genuine pleasure to work with, and we would happily and highly recommend their team whether you’re buying or selling. Absolutely best in class!

Seller review
Great honest communication
13 days ago
Great honest communication

Ailsa kept us well informed during the whole sale process. We got a sale result in a tough market with an agent who was dynamic enough to make it all work!

Seller review
Ailsa is an exceptional agent—professional, trustworthy and caring, with outstanding local expertise
27 days ago
Ailsa is an exceptional agent—professional, trustworthy and caring, with outstanding local expertise

We couldn’t recommend Ailsa and her team more highly. From the outset, they were professional, knowledgeable and excellent to work with. Ailsa is a true expert in the area. What truly sets Ailsa apart is her genuine care and commitment to her clients. I have the utmost respect for Ailsa, both personally and professionally, and hold her in the highest regard. I would have no hesitation recommending Ailsa and her team to anyone looking to sell their home.

Buyer review
Ailsa and the team were amazing!
about 1 month ago
Ailsa and the team were amazing!

We had a great experience working with Ailsa. She was incredibly helpful and supportive throughout the whole process, always friendly and easy to deal with. She was available whenever we needed her, quick to answer our questions, and made everything feel straightforward and stress-free. We really appreciated her help and would happily recommend her to others.

Seller review
Good communication.
about 2 months ago
Good communication.

Know the market and respond quickly.

Seller review
Two out of two
2 months ago
Two out of two

This is the second property we have entrusted to co agents Ailsa and Paul Arundel. Both properties sold in a timely manner and with great professionalism. We would thoroughly recommend Bayleys Coatesville and would have no hesitation in using again.

Seller review
Seamless and Speedy
3 months ago
Seamless and Speedy

We have known Ailsa & Chelsea over some years and a couple of different houses! They know their market well, have excellent communication and a relaxed professional style. In todays difficult market, they had us sold within 3 weeks! Thanks for all your hard work. Glad to be another one of your success stories!

Seller review
An amazing professional in every aspect of lifestyle real estate
4 months ago
An amazing professional in every aspect of lifestyle real estate

I can't thank Ailsa enough for making the selling of my family home as straightforward and effective as possible. Ailsa is an amazing real estate professional with her knowledge of the current market trends in the local lifestyle market and with her effective negotiating skills bringing the sale to such a positive outcome. She was always honest, constructive and respectful of where I was at, having clear and effective communication systems throughout the whole process. A very big thank you .

Seller review
Team Ailsa is amazing
6 months ago
Team Ailsa is amazing

We were under pressure to sell our home in Coatesville after we relocated to Whangarei. The market wasn't good and the war in Iran had taken away the expactation that there would be a relief for sellers in the first quarter of 2026. We made contact with Ailsa, and signed up. It was the best decision we made. Ailsa and Chelsea were always available to talk and they kept us updated with how our marketing campain was going over the 4 week period. There were a few issues with our land which I believe scared purchasers off, however on auction day our property sold! We are so thankful for the professional and friendly service we received from Team Ailsa, and the cherry on the cake - our property sold at auction. Thank you Ailsa and Chelsea. We are so grateful! I would highly reccommend tom anyone wanting to sell in the Coatesville area.

Buyer review
Incredible and informative
8 months ago
Incredible and informative

Ailsa is an incredible real estate agent. She was patient, informative and streamlined the whole purchase process for us! Very grateful to her and her team!

Seller review
Ailsas communication and professionalism
8 months ago
Ailsas communication and professionalism

Ailsas communication was excellent and she worked with every possible buyer that enquired and showed some interest. It was a very long campaign due to market conditions but Ailsa continually worked every buyer. Ailsa kept giving me buyer feedback and made me realise that my expectations were too high in the changing market. At no stage did Ailsa mislead either party and worked hard to make a deal work for both parties

1 - 12 of 104
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent