Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
347 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, friendly, honest, supportive, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Excellent
about 2 years ago
Excellent

Shelly went out of her way several times to clearly explain certain processes necessary with buying a house. She was friendly and very understanding and ensured we understood what we as first home buyers needed. On behalf of Hamish and myself, we Thank You Shelly for being a part of us buying our first home . Happy to supply a review anytime for 👍

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Seller review
First home sale
about 2 years ago
First home sale

Thanks Sarah for your help selling my first home, excellent, prompt communication that made the whole process a breeze! happily recommend Sarah for anyone looking to purchase or sell property.

Sarah Pinckney-Welch

Sarah Pinckney-Welch

  5   (3 reviews)
Seller review
A committed & professional Agent.
about 2 years ago
A committed & professional Agent.

Shelly had great market knowledge. This was an deceased Estate sale of a family members home so we weren't very knowledgeable of the area. She kept us informed every step of the way. She offered great advice on preparing the property for sale. The time frame she suggested to list was realistic without undue pressure at what was already a difficult time. We'd highly recommend Shelly to anyone who wants an honest, committed & professional agent. We're glad we had Shelly for our sales journey.

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Seller review
3 Menin Road
about 2 years ago
3 Menin Road

Nathan was very open and honest. We both sold a house with him and bought a house too. Both experiences were great he explained the processes well and we were always aware of what we needed to do. Would recommend Nathan to anyone and would definitely use him again. He never gave up on us even when the market was not great he always tried and managed to achieve our goals. He also would answer us and went out of his way when we needed something. Definitely has a great work ethic. Extremely genuine. Would recommend 100%

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (99 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent service
about 2 years ago
Excellent service

Shelly was outstanding to deal with. She was very knowledgeable & helpful. If we were ever to need a real estate agent in the future, we would certainly contact Shelly. We can highly recommend her.

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Buyer review
Stress free
about 2 years ago
Stress free

I found Shelly to be a very professional agent to deal with. She was open and honest and helped get the deal done. When I first viewed the property she wasn’t pushy and let me take time. She accommodated extra viewings and I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her for buying or selling.

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Buyer review
Sarahs communication and professionalism was great!
about 2 years ago
Sarahs communication and professionalism was great!

Sarah, took me seriously and supported me through the whole process of purchasing my first home. She was responsive and helpful. Would definitely work with her again.

Sarah Pinckney-Welch

Sarah Pinckney-Welch

  5   (3 reviews)
Seller review
Connected and personable
about 2 years ago
Connected and personable

Nathan sold us our first home in 2020 after a really tough search. He made an effort to get to know us and helped us get our foot in the door. It was no surprise that we opted to sell with him again when we moved city. He gave good advice, was quick to respond to any worries or queries and ensured that we got a great offer across the line (both as a purchaser and vendor).

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (99 reviews)
Seller review
Caroline was very attentive and gave a great service
over 2 years ago
Caroline was very attentive and gave a great service

Caroline did everything I asked. The price I got for the flats was a bit lower than I was hoping for. However the purchaser was buying three and the discount reflected the amount I received

Caroline Hughes

Caroline Hughes

  4.9   (45 reviews)
Seller review
Informative
over 2 years ago
Informative

Nathan has gone above and beyond with the sale of the house. Highly recommend him to anyone wishing to sell their property.

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (99 reviews)
Buyer review
Caroline Hughes - A Real Estate Superstar!
over 2 years ago
Caroline Hughes - A Real Estate Superstar!

Caroline Hughes is an absolute rockstar in the world of real estate! I can't thank her enough for turning what could have been a stressful property purchasing process in Napier into an absolute breeze. From the moment we started hunting for properties to closing the deals Caroline was there every step of the way, ensuring I felt informed and confident in my decisions. Her knowledge of the local market is well informed and impressive, and I felt like I was in the best hands possible. But what truly sets Caroline apart is her genuine warmth and kindness. In an industry where it's rare to find someone who truly cares about their clients, Caroline stands out. She took the time to listen to all my questions, concerns, and even my random musings, making me feel valued and supported throughout the entire journey.

Caroline Hughes

Caroline Hughes

  4.9   (45 reviews)
241 - 252 of 347
© 2026 RateMyAgent