Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
347 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, friendly, honest, supportive, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
We couldn’t have asked for a better agent!
about 2 years ago
We couldn’t have asked for a better agent!

When it came time for selling our home, we didn’t know where to start! Shelly came highly recommended to us and she was amazing. Every step of the way we found Shelly approachable, professional and highly competent - from talking us through our options, to advising us on how to get our home ‘open home’ ready, through to the selling of our home. Our home was well presented and marketed well which brought many potential buyers through our open homes. Anyone looking to sell their home, or considering their options, we highly recommend giving Shelly a call!

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Buyer review
Epitome of a great agent
about 2 years ago
Epitome of a great agent

Kelvin has been amazing with us over the last 6 weeks. We thank him immensely for helping us to buy our new forever home. Recommend to all.

Kelvin Winnie

Kelvin Winnie

  4.9   (34 reviews)
Buyer review
Thorough and proficient
about 2 years ago
Thorough and proficient

Shelly is a very easy person to work with, approachable, friendly, direct and honest. She makes a point of developing a good working relationship with her clients so she can relate to them. She always answers every question asked. If the answer is not readily available, she will research until she finds it. She certainly goes the extra mile and definitely earns her commission. :) I find Shelly's straight forward open manner refreshing. She doesn't need props, drives an average car and is simply herself in dealing with people. My experience with Shelly was one of the most positive I have ever had with an agent, and I've had many. Highly recommended.

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Buyer review
Truly Exceptional
about 2 years ago
Truly Exceptional

We met Shelly at an open home she was holding and from the first encounter she was fantastic to deal with. She took the time to understand who we were and what we needed. Shelly was always available to talk to and always went over and above for us. Any time we asked to visit the property again she made it happen. She was incredibly helpful with any queries we had and made the process of purchasing our home as smooth as possible. We will definitely use Shelly in the future should we sell or buy again.

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Buyer review
Got exactly what we wanted
about 2 years ago
Got exactly what we wanted

Shelley listened to us regarding our wants of a new property, and kept us well informed through the process. She catered to our needs during all steps, and guided us to a successful purchase of our new home

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Seller review
Terrific experience. Thank you Nathan.
about 2 years ago
Terrific experience. Thank you Nathan.

We have had a great experience selling our property with Nathan. From the outset we received clear and friendly communication and quality, professional advice. Nathan went the 'extra mile' to ensure the sale was completed to both parties expectations. We highly recommend Nathan to anyone selling property in Napier. You will not find a better partner to sell your property with.

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (99 reviews)
Seller review
Knowledgeable, approachable, goes the extra mile.
about 2 years ago
Knowledgeable, approachable, goes the extra mile.

Nathan kept us informed through the entire sales process and when we ran into some issues he assisted with various professionals and trades people to give us advice with how to proceed. Would certainly recommend to others

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (99 reviews)
Buyer review
Gets it done
about 2 years ago
Gets it done

Nathan used all of his experience and contacts to get the sale over the line.

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (99 reviews)
Buyer review
Transparent, approachable and professional
about 2 years ago
Transparent, approachable and professional

I found Nathan to be transparent and approachable as a first time buyer, had a really good experience.

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (99 reviews)
Seller review
Gets the job done effortlessly
about 2 years ago
Gets the job done effortlessly

How do we put into words what Nathan did for our family, nothing short of phenomenal. We met with Nathan on a Wednesday to ask if he could help us sell our home fast and for a specific price in order for us to secure our new home which was under contract. By Sunday that week, he had 6 families through our home (no online marketing), Monday afternoon 3 families returned for a second viewing and by that same evening two contracts on the table...just like that the house was under offer...5 days from meeting Nathan to the house being sold...ABOVE what our expectation was. So thank you Nathan! You truly are a cut above the rest and we are so grateful for what you did for our family. We will most definitely recommend you to any one wanting to sell their home.

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (99 reviews)
Seller review
Selling our family home
about 2 years ago
Selling our family home

Shelly was instrumental in selling our family home after our mother passed. She was kind and courteous throughout the whole time. Shelly stayed in contact the entire time and kept us up to date and kept us informed. It was hard for me as I was out of region but Shelly was always contactable when I called. I highly recommend Shelly. All the best for the future Shelly

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
229 - 240 of 347
© 2026 RateMyAgent