Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1635 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Keeley and Niki made the purchasing experience efficient, simple and honest
about 2 months ago
Keeley and Niki made the purchasing experience efficient, simple and honest

Keeley and Niki responded instantly to any questions I had, information I needed or connections I asked for. Keeley's knowledge of the local market ensured we identified the right property and her and Niki's recommended approach ensured all parties had closure and could relax and enjoy the rest of their weekend.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (283 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Duo
about 2 months ago
Excellent Duo

Keeley and Nikki provide top level service. They are very responsive and thorough and this approach meant they had great success with selling our home. The write up about the property was exemplary and they both had a really good understanding of the needs of the buyers and the wishes of us as sellers. Everything was done exactly as we would have hoped and we were delighted with the fast sale. We would recommend them to anyone and they were both lovely to deal with.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (283 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent communicator
about 2 months ago
Excellent communicator

Kate was absolutely amazing she answered every question I needed to know without hesitation, it was our first time buying and she made everything very easy!

Kate Andrew

Kate Andrew

  5   (115 reviews)
Buyer review
Seamless & Stress-Free
about 2 months ago
Seamless & Stress-Free

We had a fantastic experience working with Keeley and Niki throughout our home buying journey. They are both incredibly personable and easy to deal with, which made what can often be a stressful process feel smooth and enjoyable. Their efficiency really stood out, everything was handled promptly and professionally, giving us confidence every step of the way. One of the highlights was their portal system, which made submitting an offer extremely easy and straightforward. It removed a lot of the usual hassle and made the whole process seamless. We’d highly recommend Keeley and Niki to anyone looking to buy or sell. Keeley and Niki’s ability to simplify the process made a real difference, and we wouldn’t hesitate to work with them again in the future.

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (283 reviews)
Buyer review
Great team to work with
2 months ago
Great team to work with

I found dealing with Andrew and Lydia very easy. Both wonderful people and is very much appreciated

Andrew Berryman

Andrew Berryman

  5   (246 reviews)
Seller review
INCREDIBLE!
2 months ago
INCREDIBLE!

I received a few emails asking me to “rate my agent,” and it’s taken me some time to finally sit down and write this message! But honestly, how do you rate a team as amazing as these two? I feel like there aren’t enough words to truly describe how incredible they are. From the very beginning, they welcomed us into the Tall Poppy family and have been nothing short of an absolutely fantastic team to be a part of. They brought so much joy to every conversation and consistently went above and beyond, always pushing for the best outcome for us. Their dedication and effort far exceeded what you’d expect from a “real estate agent”—they genuinely care, and it shows in everything they do. We wouldn’t go anywhere else—you have us for life! It feels a bit like we’re children who’ve now flown the nest with the sale of our home… but we’ll definitely be back, haha! Many, many thanks to you both—you truly are an epic duo. Jax and hemi 🫶🏼

Stacey Gillies

Stacey Gillies

  4.9   (172 reviews)
Seller review
Fiona Chapman was extremely helpful with suggestions as to prepare the house for a sale.
2 months ago
Fiona Chapman was extremely helpful with suggestions as to prepare the house for a sale.

Fiona knew an excellent tradesman for a small repair job. She was totally involved with the clients were viewing my house and I remain extremely grateful to her. She was also excellent at keeping me informed with updates and progress. I could not be happier with her efforts.

Fiona Chapman

Fiona Chapman

  4.9   (31 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent communication
2 months ago
Excellent communication

Stacey was great to deal with and kept the communication flowing through the whole process and was very clear on what I needed to do next. Thank you for your knowledge and guidance to help me get my wonderful new home.

Stacey Gillies

Stacey Gillies

  4.9   (172 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Service
2 months ago
Excellent Service

Pip was fantastic, she went over and above for us, organising contractors on our behalf as we don’t live locally and it took a long time to finally sell the section, so it needed some maintenance, she organised a guy to do that. She jumped on every inquiry she had and 3rd time lucky, it finally sold. Pip was amazing, excellent communication and very friendly. Very happy with her service. 😊🥰

Pip O'Connell

Pip O'Connell

  4.9   (239 reviews)
Buyer review
Kate makes the process seamless. Her communication and effort is outstanding.
2 months ago
Kate makes the process seamless. Her communication and effort is outstanding.

Buying a property is extremely consuming and stressful. Kate keeps in touch through the entire journey, but isn't at all pushy or in your face. She follows up on all aspects and goes the extra mile for all parties involved. Kate provides an extremely satisfactory outcome for not only the vendor but the purchaser. Thank you.

Kate Andrew

Kate Andrew

  5   (115 reviews)
Seller review
Best Agency in Cromwell!
2 months ago
Best Agency in Cromwell!

We really enjoyed working with Keeley and Niki, both very knowledgeable of the local housing market, really nice people, professional, personable, always positive and supportive - we could not have wished for a better service and are very happy with the result. Highly recommend Tall Poppy Services!

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (283 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent communication
2 months ago
Excellent communication

We had a couple of highly skilled agents on our list. I chose Kate in the end as I wanted to give her the opportunity. It’s a tuff market for any agent. She delivered everything she states in her Bio. She listened and acted to our wishes She believed us in our goal as to why we priced our house and where it sat on today’s market. She never put any pressure on us and working with her was a pleasure. She understood my emotions once we sold it. Thank you Kate and keep up your professional standard.

Kate Andrew

Kate Andrew

  5   (115 reviews)
61 - 72 of 1,635
Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
Contact Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent