Sylvia Wildermoth & Kylie Baron

111 High Street North, Carterton
Salesperson: 10013855
  •   4.9   (38 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Sylvia Wildermoth & Kylie Baron has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

23
Reviews
8
Properties for sale
20
Sold properties
$685k
Average sale price
$13.7m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.co.nz. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 2 agents at Sylvia Wildermoth & Kylie Baron.

Kylie Baron
Kylie Baron

Licensed Real Estate Agent

  4.9   (37 reviews)
About Kylie
Real estate, for me, is about being someone people can trust. Buying or selling a home is a big step, and my role is to make the process feel clear, comfortable and well supported from beginning to end. I have made my home in the Wairarapa and built strong connections within the local community. I know the towns, rural roads, people and character that make this region such a special place to live. Living on a dairy farm on the outskirts of town also gives me a practical understanding of both town and rural life. With more than ten years of real estate experience, I bring strong local knowledge and practical experience in marketing, negotiation and sales. Just as importantly, I bring a friendly and straightforward approach. I take the time to listen, answer questions and understand what really matters.
View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievementstop20badgetrustedbadgepriceExpertbadgeaotybadge
Sylvia Wildermoth
Sylvia Wildermoth

Licensed Real Estate Agent

  4.9   (35 reviews)
About Sylvia
I love calling Carterton my home and am deeply committed to this community. Facilitating connections between people and properties is the essence of real estate, and I thrive on it - successfully closing deals and delivering exceptional service. As a natural people person, I enjoy meeting clients from diverse backgrounds, understanding their unique needs, and guiding them through their real estate journey with empathy and expertise. With strong negotiation skills and a focus on achieving mutually beneficial outcomes, I excel in selling property. My results have earned numerous industry awards and amongst my peers I am held in high regard, underscoring my commitment to excellence. As an experienced, enthusiastic, and highly motivated sales professional, I consistently go the extra mile to achieve results.
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge

About us

Proud to call Carterton home, I’m passionate about helping people successfully buy and sell property across the Wairarapa. With many years in the real estate industry, I bring extensive experience, strong local knowledge and proven negotiation skills to every sale. I’m known for my energy, commitment, straight-talking approach and determination to achieve outstanding results for my clients. Recognised as one of Carterton’s leading real estate agents on Rate My Agent, my business has been built on results, repeat clients and recommendations. For me, real estate is about people first. I take the time to understand what matters to my clients, provide honest advice and work hard to make every property journey a positive one. If you’re thinking of selling, talk to someone who knows Carterton, knows the market and knows how to get results.

Social profiles

Facebook logoInstagram logo

Our reviews

  4.9  
40 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 6.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Professional, Supportive and Great to deal.
about 6 hours ago
Professional, Supportive and Great to deal.

I had a fantastic experience purchasing my first home. The team was professional, supportive and great to deal with throughout the entire process. They were always efficient in getting back to me, answering any questions and liaising with the vendor to keep everything moving smoothly. I really appreciated their help and communication and would highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell. Thank you for making my first home purchase such a positive experience!

Sylvia WildermothKylie Baron
Seller review
Great people to work with and achieved a fantastic result in such a short time.
about 21 hours ago
Great people to work with and achieved a fantastic result in such a short time.

Sylvia and Kylie were a winning team combination from the start. Presented a great package with the latest market sales for the area. Layed out a strategy for us to go to market with a realistic price, which we achieved in one week. Four offers on the table in seven days!!!! The purchase price was around the figure we hoped to reach and wasn’t an inflated estimate from the agency. Honest appraisal was appreciated Once we took the best offer ,they negotiated a deal that was suitable for both parties . Some minor issues were raised in the building report that were dealt with in a swift and efficient manner. The outcome was fair and reasonable due to their ability to negotiate and to communicate effectively with both parties involved. I would highly recommend Sylvia and Kylie and the Tremains company to anyone looking to sell or purchase a house or property. Great Work Team!!! Many thanks from Sean Michael and Mum.

Sylvia WildermothKylie Baron
Seller review
Easy to work with, communicated well and listened to our views and concerns as the customer
18 days ago
Easy to work with, communicated well and listened to our views and concerns as the customer

As well as for open homes, they brought in viewers at other times. This was very positive understanding the market downturn at the time. When we got to the negotiating phase, they went back and forth until we had the sale agreement. They were prepared to work at it until the contract was signed. Whilst we did not get a price settlement that we had wished for, it was very close and we understood both how the market was situated, and also the advantages of the sale agreement that was secured. A little bit of compromising ensured a successful ending.

Kylie BaronSylvia Wildermoth
Buyer review
Great communication and stress free buying
about 2 months ago
Great communication and stress free buying

Sylvia and Kylie made the whole process buying Taverner street feel really straight forward and stress free, communication was great they always kept me in the loop. They work great as a pair and would highly recommend Sylvia and Kylie

Kylie BaronSylvia Wildermoth
Seller review
Professional, empathetic and successful
about 2 months ago
Professional, empathetic and successful

Once again Sylvia and Kylie have successfully sold my property but this time with a few additional challenges. My property is placed at the top end of the market for Carterton so not many houses to compare it to while facing decreasing house prices. In addition to this I had recently lost my husband. Sylvia and Kylie guided me through the process with professionalism and empathy, always checking that I was OK through the process. They managed the viewings with my diary in mind and kept me well informed of progress. They achieved four written offers plus one verbal then successfully negotiated the final fifth offer at the amount that I had hoped for. Their knowledge of the market was exceptional due to their years in the area. They are still continuing to support me through to the final move out day. This was all done in a few short months from first engagement to signing.

Sylvia WildermothKylie Baron
Show all 40 reviews
map

Our properties

Sylvia Wildermoth & Kylie Baron has 12 properties for sale and sold 20 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
Buyer Enquiries Over $395,000
29 Railway Crescent
Masterton Wellington
3
1
House
For Sale
Deadline Sale (unless sold prior)
15 Elizabeth Street
Masterton Wellington
3
1
House
SoldNov 9, 2026
Price not available
4 Casel Street
Masterton Wellington
3
1
1
House
For Sale
By Negotiation
43 Blakes Road
Mount Holdsworth Wellington
4
2
2
Rural
Show all 32 properties
© 2026 RateMyAgent