Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1659 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Worst experience I’ve had with any real estate agent
about 4 years ago
Worst experience I’ve had with any real estate agent

I don’t say that lightly and it’s taken us a long time to decide whether to write this review or not. From the first interaction Stacey was rude and blunt. We were treated like tire kickers from the moment we walked in the door. Not good enough. The property was a lifestyle block, so when we asked questions about key aspects of the lifestyle block like irrigation and she knew nothing. She had no knowledge of any aspect of the property at all really. When we tried to submit an offer it was hard to get her to take our cash offer, we had to follow up multiple times, and tried to phone her business partner as we would have preferred dealing with someone else. Then when we took over the property she rushed us through the property inspection in a few minutes, then made us feel like it was a privilege to even be standing in the house. During the time between offer acceptance and settlement we had questions about the property which we have no doubt the owners, now meeting them, would have been happy to answer, but felt completely unwelcome to ask due to Stacey. It was a disappointing experience as we’ve had some amazing experiences with other Tall Poppy agents when both buying and selling properties. This by no way reflects their company at all.

Stacey Waldron

Stacey Waldron

  4.9   (176 reviews)
Seller review
Jane and Pip made everything simple
about 4 years ago
Jane and Pip made everything simple

Both Jane and Pip gave endless support, used communication methods that worked for us and gave advice and support when needed. When we couldn't even be in the same island for the sale, it was great to know everything was in good hands.

Pip O'Connell

Pip O'Connell

  4.9   (244 reviews)
Seller review
Review for Pip O’Connell
about 4 years ago
Review for Pip O’Connell

I first met Pip while looking for property approximately a year ago. I have since viewed several properties with Pip and have always been impressed by her approach to real estate, her manner and ethics. It is refreshing to deal with a genuine person rather than the all too common “used car salespeople” that appear to be ubiquitous in the industry. When it became necessary to sell a property, I did not think twice about who I wanted to work with. Pip is a professional with a human heart and I cannot speak highly enough of her.

Pip O'Connell

Pip O'Connell

  4.9   (244 reviews)
Seller review
Superstar salesperson
about 4 years ago
Superstar salesperson

We approached Leona to sell our property in Waihola. Leona's bright and bubbly personality is second to none! Her experience and knowledge in real-estate is reassuring when it's time to sell your investment do not hesitate to make contact. Leona sold our house which was in a higher price bracket than most in a tough market in a few weeks. Communication Personality Professionalism Ability Along with other qualities makes Leona a standout. Thank you from your happy vendors.

Leona Munro

Leona Munro

  4.9   (181 reviews)
Buyer review
Stress free experience
about 4 years ago
Stress free experience

Pip is an excellent agent who made the process of buying my property, stress free. She is organised, knowledgeable and is great with communication and advice. Thank you!

Pip O'Connell

Pip O'Connell

  4.9   (244 reviews)
Buyer review
Thanks Peter you made our part easy. Such good advice
about 4 years ago
Thanks Peter you made our part easy. Such good advice

Thanks Peter for your local knowledge, experience and professionalism. Your friendly approach to making our deal come together was an easy process for us.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (319 reviews)
Buyer review
Seamless transaction
about 4 years ago
Seamless transaction

I was on a tight timeframe to view properties in Central Otago in just two days . Following a phone call the night before, Peter was able to meet me at the property. He was up front about the property and why it was for sale, also gave suggestions for improvements in the short term. Peter kept me fully informed throughout the purchase process which was a straight forward transaction and completed quickly. Peter was always cordial and accommodating of my questions and very helpful with getting information. A good experience overall, thanks Peter.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (319 reviews)
Buyer review
I was the buyer.
about 4 years ago
I was the buyer.

Peter was very trustworthy and great to deal with I would definitely go to him again.

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (319 reviews)
Buyer review
Thank you Keeley
about 4 years ago
Thank you Keeley

Keeley couldn’t have been more professional or accommodating. If you are looking to purchase in Cromwell, I highly recommend you contact Keeley as I’m sure she’ll give you the same knowledgeable, friendly, nothing was to much trouble service that we experienced. Thanks Keeley

Keeley Anderson

Keeley Anderson

  5   (287 reviews)
Seller review
Very professional and helpful
about 4 years ago
Very professional and helpful

Very reassuring and calm in what was for us a very stressful time as we required a quick sale. She worked very hard to secure us a buyer.

Stacey Waldron

Stacey Waldron

  4.9   (176 reviews)
Seller review
Good result again
about 4 years ago
Good result again

Peter got a sale on my property at a good price. I have now sold 2 properties with Peter. My first deal with him was in 2019. I’d say he’s the best agent I’ve dealt with in 34 years of owning real estate

Peter Hishon

Peter Hishon

  4.9   (319 reviews)
1273 - 1284 of 1,659
Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
Contact Tall Poppy Real Estate - Otago
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent