Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
328 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, friendly, honest, supportive, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Stressfree
about 1 year ago
Stressfree

Shelly has awesome people skills, provides timely, regular communication, and has a thorough understanding of the market. I would totally recommend Shelly to others.

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Seller review
Kelvin-Simply fantastic
about 1 year ago
Kelvin-Simply fantastic

Kelvin has been incredibly patient and mindful with his support and communication throughout this process. His kind friendly and thoughtful approach made him exactly the right person for our family.

Kelvin Winnie

Kelvin Winnie

  4.9   (33 reviews)
Seller review
Outstanding Service & Expertise
over 1 year ago
Outstanding Service & Expertise

We highly recommend Leon and his wonderful team. The team are incredibly knowledgeable and professional. Nothing was ever too much trouble. Very supportive during what can be a very stressful process. We truly appreciate his hard work. This is the second time working with Leon, the best of the best!

Leon Dear

Leon Dear

  4.8   (80 reviews)
Seller review
We wouldn't use anyone else.
over 1 year ago
We wouldn't use anyone else.

We engaged Nathan over a year ago to possibly list our house. We decided to hang onto it at the time as a rental. Nathan was super cool about it and we felt no pressure. When the time came that we needed to sell, there was no question who we were going to call. Marketing of our house was brilliant and service was fantastic. Thanks Nathan, Josh, and Kate for all your hard work. See you on the next one.

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (94 reviews)
Seller review
Professional and caring
over 1 year ago
Professional and caring

After having been with another agency Nathan had the market knowledge and a quiet assurance, culminating in a sale through a multi offer situation. Thank you Nathan.

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (94 reviews)
Buyer review
From the get go Leon was very helpful and easy to deal with
over 1 year ago
From the get go Leon was very helpful and easy to deal with

Dealing with Leon was great, he was very accommodating, getting us through the house to review and make a decision quickly. He gave additional advice on the area and type of house it was which helped us make our minds up. Going through the purchasing process was easy and he made this a breeze. We would deal with him and his team again.

Leon Dear

Leon Dear

  4.8   (80 reviews)
Seller review
Easy to Deal with
over 1 year ago
Easy to Deal with

This is the second time I have dealt with Caroline, first as a buyer and this time as a seller. I found her communications exceptional and her manner respectful and helpful. I would definately recommend her.

Caroline Hughes

Caroline Hughes

  4.9   (45 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Agent
over 1 year ago
Excellent Agent

Shelly was great to deal with, efficient, communicated well, listened to all my quirks and worked in with us seamlessly. I highly recommend her to those looking for an agent.

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Seller review
I enjoy working with Shelly as she is reliable, thorough and knowledgable and a great communicator
over 1 year ago
I enjoy working with Shelly as she is reliable, thorough and knowledgable and a great communicator

This is the third property I have worked with Shelly to sell. She continues to impress with her professionalism and knowledge. She is very straight and pragmatic and without airs and graces .... I appreciate these qualities :) If there is a question Shelly can't readily answer, she will research it thoroughly and come back to me. She is great and checking out Council files and advising. I was always confident that I was being kept very well informed during the whole process. I rate Shelly's skill very highly.

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Buyer review
Shelly Wtitchells - an incredible communicator.
over 1 year ago
Shelly Wtitchells - an incredible communicator.

We have recently purchased a property on Hospital Hill in Napier and can only say we feel incredibly fortunate that the previous owners put the sale of our new home in the careful hands of Shelly Witchalls. Shelly is an incredible communicator and demonstrated in her words and actions that both parties were important to her. She has a warmth which instantly put us at ease and we were able to move ahead with a complex purchase with Shelly listening and supporting us at each step. Thank you Shelly.

Shelly Witchalls

Shelly Witchalls

  5   (36 reviews)
Seller review
Great agent to deal with all round
over 1 year ago
Great agent to deal with all round

Nathan was fantastic to deal with throughout our house selling experience. We were not overly familiar with the process but Nathan is very experienced and made sure we knew our options and talked us through everything clearly. He was friendly, honest, and down to earth and has a calm demeanor which was very helpful at times! Nothing was too much trouble and we always felt he was doing his job well, with our best interests at heart, and kept us in the loop every step of the way. Nathan made what could be highly stressful, a relatively relaxed process, with great comms, and achieved a great outcome for us. We wouldn't hesitate to use him again for our next sale/ purchase.

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (94 reviews)
Seller review
 King road Meeanee and Hinton road Taradale
over 1 year ago
King road Meeanee and Hinton road Taradale

Working with Nathan was very good, he took care of everything for us and made the experience easy and hassle free. Highly recommend

Nathan Abel

Nathan Abel

  4.9   (94 reviews)
97 - 108 of 328
© 2026 RateMyAgent