Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
477 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Knowledgeable, friendly, timely and efficient.
6 months ago
Knowledgeable, friendly, timely and efficient.

Sharon and Jamie are a great team with a good back office behind them. Always pleasant and available, they have a thorough knowledge of the Wanaka market and trustful relationships with their clients. We benefitted from this in both the selling and buying of property in Wanaka and appreciated their personal approach. Jamie was also helpful (and patient!) in dealing with issues on the ground while we were overseas for several months, including the negotiation process and paperwork. The weekly updates during the sale period were also useful and provided market context for any questions that we wanted to follow up on, to which Jamie was always responsive. We would be happy to recommend the Donnelly team to any prospective real estate client in Wanaka as (bottom line) they were always professional and lovely to deal with.

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (267 reviews)
Seller review
Superb Agent
6 months ago
Superb Agent

We listed our place with Scott having been impressed in our dealings with him on the buyer side as well. As our sales agent, he was extremely proactive and worked hard to maximise our sales goals. Communication was always timely and honest. He knows the market well and kept us informed through our sales campaign, which turned out to be a very short timeframe, which reflected well on how good Scott is. We would highly recommend Scott to be your agent.

Scott McGoun

Scott McGoun

  5   (49 reviews)
Buyer review
Best in class communication and extremely helpful
6 months ago
Best in class communication and extremely helpful

Matt, provided key knowledge of the local market and really listened to what we were after in a property. Very professional and open minded. I would definitely recommend Matt, and would rely on him in buying or selling a property in the future.

Matt Ecroyd

Matt Ecroyd

  5   (96 reviews)
Seller review
Professional and accommodating
6 months ago
Professional and accommodating

Understood the market very well and always kept us informed.

Todd Soper

Todd Soper

  4.9   (7 reviews)
Seller review
Very helpful and honest
6 months ago
Very helpful and honest

Communication great even with another country

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (267 reviews)
Buyer review
Good transaprent communicator
6 months ago
Good transaprent communicator

Scott was easy to deal with and transparent. He made the process of buying our new property very straightforward.

Scott McGoun

Scott McGoun

  5   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Very good!
6 months ago
Very good!

Sharon and her team were a pleasure to deal with!

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (267 reviews)
Seller review
Professional from start to finish
6 months ago
Professional from start to finish

Scott and the Bayleys team were a pleasure to work with when selling our home. Scott’s calm, confident approach made the whole process feel straightforward and stress-free. With great communication and a strong network of buyers, our home sold on the day it was listed. We were very happy with the result and would highly recommend Scott and his team.

Scott McGoun

Scott McGoun

  5   (49 reviews)
Seller review
Only real estate agent in Wanaka i would use, best in the business
6 months ago
Only real estate agent in Wanaka i would use, best in the business

Todd was excellent to deal with. An honest straight talker who gives the best guidance and advice fuelled by his wealth of experience and knowledge of the area. He got us the best price possible in a less than ideal market and I would be more than happy to have him sell our next project. His professionalism and communication is extremely high being at the end of the phone seemingly whenever we needed. I highly recommend you look no further than Todd and the bayleys team when it comes to selling property in their area.

Todd Soper

Todd Soper

  4.9   (7 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Agency Duo
6 months ago
Great Agency Duo

We are grateful to team Sharon/Jaimie for helping us find our new home in Wanaka. From the first viewing to the final closing, they went above and beyond to make sure we felt comfortable and informed throughout the entire process. They listened to what we were looking for and despite us requiring several viewings they never made us feel pressured, which we truly appreciated. We are very pleased with our purchase and the level of service we received. If you’re looking for a professional and supportive real estate experience, we couldn’t recommend them highly enough!"

Sharon Donnelly

Sharon Donnelly

  4.9   (267 reviews)
61 - 72 of 477
© 2026 RateMyAgent