Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1174 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Outstanding Agent
over 4 years ago
Outstanding Agent

To all Buyers and Sellers I have absolutely no issue in recommending Scott McElhnney's as an agent. He made the process stress free in a stressful and trying time (covid lockdown). He went well above and beyond what other agents have done for me in the past so I would'nt hesitate in working with him again. I once was a property finder and have worked with well over one hundred agents, Scott would be in my top three, easily. So if your looking for great agent Scott is the one for you. Many thanks Scott.

Scott McElhinney

Scott McElhinney

  4.9   (153 reviews)
Seller review
Fabulous Result
over 4 years ago
Fabulous Result

Both Brendon and Louise are absolute professionals at what they do. Their integrity and open communication throughout this process has been second to none! Selling a house during lockdown was difficult but they made this process as seemless as possible. I am very happy with the result and will definitely use their services in the future. Thanks again guys!

Brendon Moore

Brendon Moore

  5   (188 reviews)
Seller review
A very pleasant experience
over 4 years ago
A very pleasant experience

Simone made light work out of a difficult situation, being a deceased estate to be sold by executors of the estate who are both located in Australia. She is very professional but personable at the same time. We really appreciated how she kept us in the loop regarding all aspects of the sale, up to and including watching the auction live. Thanks Simone!

Simone Simpson

Simone Simpson

  4.9   (71 reviews)
Buyer review
In Good Hands
over 4 years ago
In Good Hands

Jason was great to deal with, very friendly and knowledgeable and able to answer any questions we had. He was able to guide us seamlessly through the auction process for the first time which was very helpful.

Jason Tabrum

Jason Tabrum

  4.9   (90 reviews)
Seller review
not a sales pitch for Scott, an honest review with merit
over 4 years ago
not a sales pitch for Scott, an honest review with merit

Scott has been in our area for a long time, the first flyer we had in the mailbox from Scott was very quirky, saying there would be traffic issues for a certain house. That got my attention, quite a unique approach with some humor. i followed Scott knowing we would be selling in the future...and buying. so, I have recently sold thru Scott, he is always available, returns calls and follows thru. He is dealing with most peoples biggest asset and the professionalism shows, as does his integrity. Through my own "indecisive" doings , i ended up with 2 properties and Scott gave me full reassurance and my panic times turned to absolute relief and calm... he delivered. His knowledge in the market, accuracy, and contacts is second to none. I cannot recommend him highly enough . There is a lot of reasons Scott is one of the best. My one worded recommendation would be due to the trustworthiness. Cant recommend him enough, I too am in business and delivery is such an underestimated result these days, you wont have any issues with Scott .

Scott McElhinney

Scott McElhinney

  4.9   (153 reviews)
Seller review
Both Brendon and Louise displayed a high level of integrity and flexibility during the sale process.
over 4 years ago
Both Brendon and Louise displayed a high level of integrity and flexibility during the sale process.

Communication from Brendon and Louise was always clear, concise and honest. They listened to any concerns I had and always answered questions promptly. While selling during a lockdown us difficult they made the process as seamless as possible and were very reassuring. I always knew I could trust their advice.

Brendon Moore

Brendon Moore

  5   (188 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Agent - Very Reliable
over 4 years ago
Excellent Agent - Very Reliable

We really appreciate Jason's professionalism while still maintaining a good relationship with his client. He is very approachable, reliable, dedicated, organised, understanding, friendly and very good at his job. To top it all off, he made an excellent full report during the sale of our house and we were always kept in the loop. We would definitely ask Jason in the future to be our agent again. :)

Jason Tabrum

Jason Tabrum

  4.9   (90 reviews)
Seller review
Great to work with
over 4 years ago
Great to work with

Had a great experience with William as our agent. This is the second time we've used him and his service and advice were greatly received and much appreciated.

William Tyndall

William Tyndall

  5   (44 reviews)
Buyer review
Great experience, good communication.
over 4 years ago
Great experience, good communication.

Louise did a great job finding a property for us in this difficult market!

Brendon Moore

Brendon Moore

  5   (188 reviews)
Seller review
Scott and his team were professional and informative
over 4 years ago
Scott and his team were professional and informative

Scott and his team were professional and informative, market our property using an amazing creative videographer and professional photos to show the best features of our property. Its was a shame we where let down by an unprofessional Auctioneer.

Scott McElhinney

Scott McElhinney

  4.9   (153 reviews)
Seller review
Ponga Hill
over 4 years ago
Ponga Hill

Scott turned up and helped us in a foreign world when Dad passed suddenly. He showed us professionalism, and did what worked for us. The whole process was easy and the result was good, he gave us options and we had to do very little. We would recommend him for selling rural lifestyle properties. Thanks Scott

Scott McElhinney

Scott McElhinney

  4.9   (153 reviews)
1009 - 1020 of 1,174
Barfoot & Thompson - Pukekohe
Contact Barfoot & Thompson - Pukekohe
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent