Scott's profile

Scott's reviews

  4.9  
Scott has 158 reviewsacross 33 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Scott's qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, well-prepared, strategic, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
A pleasure to work with
over 3 years ago
A pleasure to work with

Scott was fantastic to deal with throughout the process. He responded quickly to any requests for information and provided honest answers even when they were not necessarily what we wanted to hear which really engendered a sense of trust. Most importantly he got us into the house we wanted for what we were happy to pay - you can't really ask for much more than that. I would not hesitate to recommend Scott.

Seller review
Thank you!
almost 4 years ago
Thank you!

Scott sold our property at auction with a satisfactory outcome. Scott is very helpful and professional at all times, in guiding the seller in securing a positive out come. We have know hesitation in recommending Scott McElhinney from Barfoot & Thompson Pukekohe.

Seller review
Awesome Scott
almost 4 years ago
Awesome Scott

We have just sold our property through Scott at Barfoot and Thompson and we could not speak highly enough of Scott and his team. We could not fault his professionalism, he kept us well informed throughout the selling process and managed to bring about a sale within ten days. He was always very personable and made the process less stressful. We definitely will be recommending Scott and his team to everyone. Many thanks Scott, we really appreciate all the work you put in to selling our property.

Seller review
Great result
almost 4 years ago
Great result

Scott and his team done a great job from apprasial to auction , we got the result we needed , highly recommend scott if you are selling lifestyle

Seller review
Research paid off
almost 4 years ago
Research paid off

Prior to listing our property we researched a number of agents catering to the local market, we went with Scott based on the reviews and feedback from previous clients. We have not been disappointed, although you always hope for more, in a tough market Scott was able to bring multiple offers and achieve results that allow us to move onto our next adventure.

Seller review
A Pleasure
almost 4 years ago
A Pleasure

We had the pleasure of working with Scott and Sunny Anand while recently selling a lifestyle property. We could not fault their professionalism and the service they both provided. They made a great team and we would have no hesitation recommending either agent.

Buyer review
Got us our lifestyle plot!
almost 4 years ago
Got us our lifestyle plot!

Working with Scott was an effortless process. He was extremely professional, to the point, and timely. We've already recommended him to friends and would use his expertise in the future when needed.

Seller review
Scott is a super agent
almost 4 years ago
Scott is a super agent

I chose Scott to market my house because he knows the house well, he sold the same house three times. I have been to Scott's other open homes many times and never bought any from Scott until one day I decided to sell my house in Mangatangi. I trust Scott will be the perfect person to sell my house . Scott and his team are professional, responsible and reliable.

Seller review
Scott is a very well connected agent and a leader in rural sales.
about 4 years ago
Scott is a very well connected agent and a leader in rural sales.

Scott has extensive market knowledge with a well oiled marketing machine behind his sales. The marketing plan might seem expensive but it covers what is needed to sell a property. Scott sold our bare land up on Drury Hills during a difficult time in the market for a reasonable price. Work with Scott and you can expect results!

Buyer review
Professional Service
about 4 years ago
Professional Service

It was a good experience dealing with Scott who was professional and courteous in my dealings both pre and post purchase. We managed to reach and agreement quite quickly without much rigmarole, thanks to his handling of the offer. Overall good service and will happily deal with him in the future.

Seller review
Couldn't ask for better!
about 4 years ago
Couldn't ask for better!

Scott was fantastic! He was extremely knowledgeable of the market, and provided a realistic and balanced view and opinion. The proof was in the pudding - selling our home in under a month, for a fantastic price in the current climate! Scott was always available via text or phone, but it was his team that were a standout. They were always available via phone and email, and we were constantly kept updated and looked after. We would recommend Scott to anyone in a heartbeat, and he will be the only agent we use going forward.

85 - 96 of 158
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent