Nicole Penny

Nicole Penny

Sales Consultant / Property Consultant / Sales & Marketing Consultant at Barfoot & Thompson - Browns Bay
  •   5   (103 reviews)

Nicole's sales performance at a glance

See how Nicole has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

29
Reviews
21
Median days on market
8
Properties for sale
39
Sold properties
$997k
Average sale price
$37.9m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.co.nz. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • top20badge

    Recognised for being in the Top 20% for customer satisfaction.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

About Nicole

Hi, I'm Nicole. For me, real estate has never been about houses. It's about people. Helping someone sell the home they've loved for years. Watching a family collect the keys to a place where they'll create new memories. Guiding people through one of the biggest financial and emotional decisions they'll ever make. That's what I love most about what I do. Before real estate, I spent many years with one of New Zealand's largest life insurance companies, helping people navigate important life decisions. Looking back, I can see that role gave me the skills I rely on every day. Finding solutions. Communicating openly. Staying calm under pressure. Most importantly, putting people first. Born and raised on Auckland's North Shore, I feel incredibly fortunate to help people buy and sell homes in the community I've always called home. From Browns Bay and Torbay to Mairangi Bay, Rothesay Bay and the sought after Rangitoto College zone, I know this area well because it's where my family and I have built our lives. Every home has a story, and every client has different priorities. Some are looking for more space as their family grows. Others are ready to downsize after decades in the same home. Some are chasing a school zone, while others are preparing for a completely new chapter. Whatever your reason for moving, my role is the same: to understand what's important to you, create the right strategy and work tirelessly to achieve the best possible outcome. Clients often tell me they appreciate my communication just as much as the result itself. I believe you should always know what's happening, what comes next and feel confident that your sale is being handled with care and professionalism. My goal is to make the process feel less overwhelming by being there every step of the way. Negotiation is one of the parts of my job I enjoy most. It's where preparation, experience and understanding people come together. I'm committed to exploring every opportunity to maximise the outcome because I don't believe in leaving money on the table. In just a few years, I've been fortunate to build my business through repeat clients, referrals and consistent Top 10 recognition on the North Shore. While I'm incredibly proud of those achievements, they're not what motivates me. The greatest compliment I can receive is when someone recommends me to their family or friends, or calls me again when it's time for their next move. Outside of work, you'll usually find me enjoying everything that makes the North Shore such a special place to live. Whether it's an early morning walk along Browns Bay beach, spending time with my husband and our three children, or catching up with friends over a matcha, I never take this lifestyle for granted. If you're thinking about selling your home, I'd love the opportunity to help. I'll give you honest advice, keep you informed and represent your home as if it were my own, with care, commitment and determination to achieve the very best result.

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 103 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 6.
Review Nicole
Nicole's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, dedicated, responsive, supportive, friendly, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent Agent that left no stone unturned
5 days ago
Excellent Agent that left no stone unturned

Nicole was an absolute blessing to work with throughout the sale of our property. From the very beginning, she made us feel comfortable and confident about such a major decision, while also understanding the emotions involved in letting go of a home. Nicole was professional, approachable, and genuinely supportive every step of the way. She kept us informed throughout the entire process, and no question was ever too small or silly. Every phone call was answered, and she was always available when we needed guidance or reassurance. Her marketing strategy was spot on, and her expertise and attention to detail really shone through. Nicole had an incredible ability to keep us calm when needed while also helping us remain realistic and focused on the end goal. Nothing ever seemed too difficult for her to handle. We couldn't have asked for a better real estate agent and would highly recommend Nicole to anyone looking to buy or sell property.

Seller review
The excellent duo
11 days ago
The excellent duo

I couldn't be happier with the service Nicole and Bren provided. They were professional, friendly, and incredibly proactive throughout the entire process. They made what can be a stressful experience feel easy and enjoyable. I'm so grateful for all their hard work and would recommend them without hesitation ⭐️

Seller review
Communication and professionalism
15 days ago
Communication and professionalism

Nicole and Bren have excellent communication skills and knowledge of the local market. They were quick to respond, every time we communicated. They shared their knowledge and experience and guided us to make the right decisions, which resulted in a quick and easy sale. I highly recommend them!

Seller review
Thoughtful, considerate, professional and dedicated
25 days ago
Thoughtful, considerate, professional and dedicated

Nicole was dedicated and hard working with buyers. Respectful, considerate and professional in all communications and advice. She worked to sell a couple of our properties that were tidy but a little tired from years of being rented - tough sells in a slow market with few investors. The properties sold and we were happy to have had Penny selling for us.

Seller review
Outstanding team, excellent communication and would highly recommend.
about 1 month ago
Outstanding team, excellent communication and would highly recommend.

We would like to thank Bren and Nicole for their outstanding campaign in selling our house in Torbay. From the beginning, Ben and Nicole’s professionalism, excellent communication and guidance on preparing the house in a challenging market was spot on. Nicole went the extra mile meeting up with Tradesmen, while we were away, which was a great help with the preparation. Bren had a good eye for detail, to ensure the house looked perfect. During the auction, Bren and Nicole were both on hand to guide us through the process, without any pressure and got us a good result. With their help and guidance, we were able to quickly secure our future home shortly after the auction. We can’t thank them enough and would highly recommend both Bren and Nicole to anyone looking to sell or buy a house. Andrew and Margaret

Show all 103 reviews
map

Nicole's properties

Nicole has 8 properties for sale and sold 39 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldNov 10, 2026
Price not available
36 Stredwick Drive
Torbay Auckland
4
3
5
House
SoldNov 10, 2026
Price not available
14 Oban Road
Browns Bay Auckland
House
For Sale
Price not available
24 Marywil Crescent
Hillcrest Auckland
5
3
5
House
For Sale
Price not available
3 Marina Road
Torbay Auckland
4
2
6
House
Show all 47 properties

Nicole's sold properties

Nicole has sold 39 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
36 Stredwick Drive, Torbay, Auckland
36 Stredwick Drive
Torbay Auckland
4
3
5
HouseUndisclosed PriceNov 10, 2026
14 Oban Road
Browns Bay Auckland
HouseUndisclosed PriceNov 10, 2026
2/163 Deep Creek Road, Torbay, Auckland
2/163 Deep Creek Road
Torbay Auckland
2
1
1
HouseUndisclosed PriceNov 4, 2026
2/7 Sunburst Lane, Torbay, Auckland
2/7 Sunburst Lane
Torbay Auckland
3
2
3
HouseUndisclosed PriceOct 28, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent