Nicky's profile

Nicky's reviews

  4.9  
Nicky has 364 reviewsacross 28 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Nicky's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, honest, friendly, responsive, supportive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Exceptional agent
10 months ago
Exceptional agent

Nicky and her team were amazing. Nicky had a good knowledge of the area the property was in and had a good understanding of what houses in that area sold for, while the home was not perfect it did not matter to Nicky. Nicky and her team marketed the property to its best potential. Nicky's communication with regard to open homes and interest in the property was on point, I could not fault her for her professionalism, the team she works with were excellent if I had a query there was always someone available to answer. After the open homes the follow up was within an hour of the open home which was great to get the feedback so quickly and work out if anything needed to be done. They are a driven team and want to get the best for the Vendor and work very hard no matter what time of the day. The auction was done so well, they achieved an amazing sale price and the sale price would not have been achieved without the dedication of Nicky Malloy and her team. I would recommend Nicky and her team to anyone looking for an agent whether it is to sell a property or if you are looking for a property to buy. Will use them again in the future.

Seller review
Professional and Knowledgable
11 months ago
Professional and Knowledgable

We were recommended Nicky and Team Malloy from a family friend because of their excellent reputation in the real estate business - and they did not disappoint! Nicky and Team Malloy showed great expertise and professionalism in providing advice as well as effectively navigating the sales process - e.g., expediting paperwork and coordnating viewings - leading to a quick and successful sale. We were impressed with their knowledge of market trends and strategic approach to the auction process. The team's communication was quick and showcased their dedication to keeping us as clients well-informed every step of the way. We highly recommend Nicky Malloy and Team Malloy for anyone seeking effective and knowledgable real estate agents. Thanks again Nicky and everyone at Team Malloy!

Seller review
 Sold a Leaky Home
11 months ago
Sold a Leaky Home

I had a leaky home in New Lynn which was getting to an age where major work was going to be needed soon. Living abroad I needed to sell it as trying to manage repairs from overseas was nigh on impossible. In steps Nicky and her team, confident yet realistic about trying to sell it. They communicated regularly with detailed updates and replied to emails and messages usually within the hour. In the end we took it to auction and although I ended up getting a lot less than we originally discussed and set the price at, I was relieved to be able to sell it at all. The auction again was well organized and the process clearly communicated.

Seller review
Absolutely Awesome
11 months ago
Absolutely Awesome

We needed an agent to assist our elderly parents (aged 93 and 96) who needed to sell the home that they built together in the 1950s and had lived in for the past 70 years. After meeting with Mark, Nicky and Georgia, we knew that Team Mallow (Nicky in particular) was the perfect choice, with the rest of the team behind her. She managed the entire process with compassion, gentleness combined with confidence and integrity. Nicky provided regular updates to the wider family and was always available to answer any queries along the way. The property was sold in 4 weeks and we are grateful for an amazing outcome. We would highly recommend Nicky and her team (Team Malloy).

Seller review
Delivering Gold Standard 👏
11 months ago
Delivering Gold Standard 👏

We were absolutely delighted with Nicky and Georgia's service throughout the sale of our home. ​From our very first meeting, they were incredibly open and honest, setting clear and realistic expectations for the entire process. Their ability to share deep, valuable market insights was invaluable; we felt informed and confident with every decision we made, even when we threw a few curve balls at them! ​Most importantly, they truly delivered on their promise, successfully selling our home exactly within the price range they projected - let us not forget that they did this in about two weeks of going live! The entire experience was seamless, professional, and successful. We highly recommend them to anyone looking for a trustworthy and highly effective real estate team!

Buyer review
Can we give a six star?
11 months ago
Can we give a six star?

We had a wonderful opportunity to work alongwith Georgia Malloy and her team on a recent purchase. While we have interacted with several other professionals over the last 6 months, Georgia's friendly yet highly professional approach and prompt communication throughought the process truly made her stand out. We were very impressed by the way she went above and beyond, leveraging her knowledge and industry connections to help us achieve a successful outcome. Highly recommend Georgia and her team in the West! Team Malloy is the best! Thank You!

Seller review
Knowledgeable and understanding
11 months ago
Knowledgeable and understanding

The Malloy team worked with us to find our next property and sell our existing. In both instances they were able to guide us through each step of the way. As a result of their support we were able to act with confidence and have knowledge about the best way to respond. We had great results on both transactions. They were there whenever we had questions. Highly recommend this team.

Seller review
Highly recommend for professional service.
12 months ago
Highly recommend for professional service.

Great working with a confident and experienced team with lots of energy and plenty of style! Very professional and delivered with kindness and understanding. Recommended by my Banker and was not disappointed. Highly recommend their service. A 10/10 for selling 6 Waari Ave. Now just 6a Waari to to go!!

Seller review
Awesome Team
12 months ago
Awesome Team

It was a pleasure working with the Malloy team. Very professional and knowledgeable in every aspect of the house sale

Seller review
Made the Impossible Possible – Incredible Real Estate Experience!
about 1 year ago
Made the Impossible Possible – Incredible Real Estate Experience!

We can’t speak highly enough of our experience with Georgia, Nicky and the team! After having our home sit on the market for three months with another agent—and not receiving a single offer—we were feeling discouraged and unsure of our next steps. From the moment Georgia and Nicky took over, everything changed. Their professionalism, marketing strategy, and deep understanding of the market were immediately evident. Within just three weeks, we had four strong offers on the table. Thanks to their skillful negotiation and guidance, we went unconditional just over a month after relisting! One of the standout aspects of working with Georgia and Nicky was their excellent communication. We received frequent updates throughout the entire process, including personalised video recaps after every open home, which kept us completely in the loop and reassured us that everything was on track. We truly felt supported every step of the way. Georgia and Nicky were proactive, transparent, and always had our best interests at heart. They turned what had been a stressful experience into a smooth, successful sale—and far quicker than we ever expected. If you're looking for a results-driven, trustworthy, and truly amazing real estate agent, look no further than Georgia and Nicky. We wouldn't hesitate to recommend them to anyone!

Seller review
Team Malloy Went Above and Beyond in Selling Our Family Home
about 1 year ago
Team Malloy Went Above and Beyond in Selling Our Family Home

We recently had the pleasure of working with Team Malloy to sell our family property, and they went above and beyond every step of the way. From the outset, they guided us with professionalism, honesty, and genuine care, making what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and well-supported. The whole team kept us updated throughout, answered all our questions quickly, and offered clear advice we could trust. What really stood out was the personal touch—they took the time to understand the significance of selling our family home and treated it with the respect it deserved. Their approach was warm, approachable, and always reassuring. We are incredibly grateful for their dedication and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Team Malloy to anyone looking for agents who truly care and consistently go the extra mile.

Buyer review
Excellent service
about 1 year ago
Excellent service

I engaged Nicky 4 years ago to sell a property and was impressed with her exceptional service and support. I have now purchased a property through her and found that as a purchaser she is equally as attentive to the standard of service and support. I strongly recommend working with her

49 - 60 of 364
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent