Nic's profile

Nic's reviews

  5  
Nic has 62 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Nic's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great service
4 days ago
Great service

I really enjoyed working with Nic and would work with her again. My house took over a year to sell but she never gave up! I liked that the whole company got on board and I got to deal with many of the team and they were all lovely

Buyer review
 Excellent experience
12 days ago
Excellent experience

Nic went above and beyond to help me find my first home anything I needed she made happen. Great communication with fast replies and updates which I really appreciated when stepping into the unknown of first home buying. I highly recommend Nic to anyone thinking of buying or selling their homes.

Buyer review
Easy and uncomplicated
26 days ago
Easy and uncomplicated

Nic was very inviting and very easy to communicate with, from open home to signing contract was a breeze!

Seller review
Outstanding communication and a genuinely supportive agent
about 1 month ago
Outstanding communication and a genuinely supportive agent

After having our house on the market last year with a different agency and not getting the result we were hoping for, working with Nic was a completely different experience. We'd already moved away from Timaru and were renting the house out, so everything was done over the phone, text and Messenger. We never actually met in person, but that didn't matter. Nic kept us updated the whole way through and was always easy to get hold of. Part way through the process our tenants needed to move out urgently. It could have been a really stressful situation, but Nic worked closely with both them and us to make sure everything went as smoothly as possible. We really appreciated how she handled it and kept everyone informed. When we received multiple offers, I honestly went around in circles trying to decide what to do. Nic was amazing through it all. She never told me which offer to accept or tried to sway my decision. Instead, she listened while I talked it through (more than once!), answered all my questions, and helped me work through the pros and cons until I felt comfortable making the decision myself. I never felt pressured, which meant a lot. Nic is genuine, honest and incredibly easy to deal with. After our experience trying to sell the year before, she restored our confidence and made the whole process so much less stressful. We couldn't be happier with the result and wouldn't hesitate to recommend Nic to anyone looking to sell their home. Thanks again, Nic, for all your hard work – we really appreciate everything you did for us.

Seller review
Third property we have sold through Nic.
2 months ago
Third property we have sold through Nic.

Honest agent. Gave advice willingly and wasn't pushy to get it listed before we were ready. Listens to clients, and explains how she would market the property for best result. Knows her stuff. She was bang on her appraisal.

Seller review
Handled it like a pro from start to finish
3 months ago
Handled it like a pro from start to finish

Nic had excellent communication keeping me updated with how the sale was going the whole way through. She was helpful at answering any questions and making sure I knew what was happening at every stage of the process. She showcased the house really well in the video content and images shared on social media.

Seller review
Exceptional Support & Service from Start to Finish
3 months ago
Exceptional Support & Service from Start to Finish

Being overseas while selling our home could have been incredibly stressful, but thanks to Nic, the entire process felt smooth, manageable, and reassuring from start to finish. Despite the distance, she kept us constantly informed with prompt communication, regular updates, and thoughtful guidance every step of the way. Nic’s patience, professionalism, and genuine care never went unnoticed. Even during the months our home was on the market, she remained positive, encouraging, and fully committed to achieving the best outcome for us. We always felt supported, valued, and confident knowing she was looking after everything so diligently on our behalf. What truly stood out was how personal and caring she was throughout the journey. We are so incredibly grateful for all of her hard work, dedication, and kindness, and we could not recommend Nic more highly to anyone looking for an agent they can truly trust. Thank you for everything, Nic! Arnold and Pracilla

Seller review
Made the sale as easy
5 months ago
Made the sale as easy

Good communication. Helped get the sake across the line Easy to work with as an out of town vendor

Buyer review
Nic is just a dream to work with
6 months ago
Nic is just a dream to work with

Nic always follows thru with things and if she doesn't know she will go above and beyond to find out and give you answers in a timely manner. She is honest and straight up and extremely approachable and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend her.

Seller review
Exactally what you want
9 months ago
Exactally what you want

Very knowledgeable and awesome communication all the way through the process. Made it very easy and stress free. Highly recommend

Seller review
Patient, genuine, and always in my corner
9 months ago
Patient, genuine, and always in my corner

Working with Nic Shaw was an absolute pleasure. My home was on the market for around five months, and through that whole time she never lost patience or positivity. She listened carefully, was always receptive to feedback, and made me feel completely supported even when the process was testing at times. Nic’s communication was excellent, always timely, clear, and thoughtful. She took the time to explain every step, offered honest advice, and never pushed just to make a sale. Her calm, professional approach made all the difference and helped me stay confident throughout. If you’re looking for an agent who is genuinely caring, trustworthy, and truly works with you, Nic is the person you want on your side. I can’t thank her enough for her patience and commitment, and I’d recommend her to anyone wanting a smooth, stress-free experience.

1 - 12 of 62
© 2026 RateMyAgent