Our profile

Our reviews

  4.8  
27 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
12 months ago
VeryExcellent

We recently worked along Sheryn to sell our house, and the entire process was smooth and stree-free thanks to her experience and dedication. From our first meeting Sheryn helped us with helpful advise on extras thats she believed would help us sell our house faster. She helped us set a realistic and competitive price for our property. What impressed us most was her level of communication. Sheryn kept us informed every step of the way, providing regular updates, and ensuring we felt comfortable throughout the selling process. We felt that Sheryn went above and beyond to make sure our interest were prioritised, and we couldn’t be happier with the results. If anyone is looking for an agent we would highly recommend Sheryn.

Sheryn Botherway

Sheryn Botherway

  4.7   (14 reviews)
12 months ago
Exceptional Commitment

I have been around for a while (I’m old) and have dealt with a good number of agents in my time. None has come close to Maura in terms of work ethic and commitment. In a still depressed market she managed to secure twenty plus bidder registrations for the auction - with that number it was not surprising when the property sale price exceeded our expectations.

Maura Tootill

Maura Tootill

  4.9   (15 reviews)
about 1 year ago
Experienced agent

Sheryn has an impressive grasp of the market and she recognizes the true worth of properties. She's incredibly personable, maintained excellent communication with us and she has my confidence.

Sheryn Botherway

Sheryn Botherway

  4.7   (14 reviews)
about 1 year ago
Easy to deal with

My partner and I were in the process of cleaning up our property as it had already been on the market for several months and nothing from the agent was happening, until one day this vibrant young women knocks on the door and says "I've been stalking you and want to sell your house." There was already an agent trying to sell it but we thought why not give Sheryn a go! Eight weeks on the market and it was SOLD at auction. What a legend and it was the first sale for Sheryn. I cannot tell you just how greatful we were to Sheryn for all the hard work she put in, to market our property. Her professional attitude, towards potential clients viewing the property was outstanding and she also went above and beyond all other areas of making things happen. Thank you Sheryn, we wish you all the best for the future.

Sheryn Botherway

Sheryn Botherway

  4.7   (14 reviews)
about 1 year ago
Pure Gold.

Sheryn is definitely a gem. Sheryn is easy to communicate with and answers any question with ease. If your looking to sell or buy definitely give Sheryn a call.

Sheryn Botherway

Sheryn Botherway

  4.7   (14 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Very professional, fantastic communication

We chose to go with Sheryn as she has a high level of professionalism, Sheryn also offered us great comparable information when we were getting ready to sell our home. We were really confused on what style of selling we would use “ Auction, BEO or Fixed price.” Sheryn took the time to sit down with us and talk us through each option. Sheryn was really accommodating and was always available when we need to chat. Our property wasn’t on the market long before Sheryn brought us 3 offers to look over. Our overall the experience we had with Sheryn was nothing short of amazing, stress free and was a very enjoyable one. We would highly recommend Sheryn. Massive shout out to Sheryn and the Bayleys team. Manchester Street, Takaro, Manawatu-Wanganui

Sheryn Botherway

Sheryn Botherway

  4.7   (14 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Nice to work with

Sheryn was nice to work with. Friendly and approachable. If I was to sell again I think I would take a different sales option (rather than auction) but I took the advice given to me at the time.

Sheryn Botherway

Sheryn Botherway

  4.7   (14 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Ask Nicely Review

Maura was the perfect agent to sell my property she put in a lot of work to get the buyers to Auction. Nothing was too much trouble and she kept in regular contact with me so I know what was happening and how things were tracking along. The team at Bayleys were also very supportive - very much appreciated.

Maura Tootill

Maura Tootill

  4.9   (15 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Maura is an Amazing Agent to work with!

Maura is an amazing agent to work with, she was professional, kind and a pleasure to deal with. Maura really gave us the personal touch. I would use Maura again without a doubt. She was so lovely to deal with. Thank you Maura for helping me into my dream home and all your hard work and compassion and empathy for my situation.

Maura Tootill

Maura Tootill

  4.9   (15 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Great team work

Maura and Sherryn recently sold our property at auction. They were professional and friendly at all times and kept us informed every step of the way. What an awesome team ! We would highly recommend them to others wanting a Sold sign on their gate.

Maura Tootill

Maura Tootill

  4.9   (15 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Maura was a excellent to deal with highly reccomended

Maura communication was excellent went out of her way to help. Would highly reccomend her & will absolutly use her again if required in the future.

Maura Tootill

Maura Tootill

  4.9   (15 reviews)
over 2 years ago
A heartfelt Thankyou.

Very impressed with the professionalism of the Bayleys team, particularly with our personal agent Sheryn Botherway. Sheryn was very supportive in helping us navigate our way through the marketing and selling process of our property, which for a senior couple we found very stressful. A heartfelt Thankyou.

Sheryn Botherway

Sheryn Botherway

  4.7   (14 reviews)
13 - 24 of 27
© 2026 RateMyAgent