Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
369 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Above and Beyond Service
almost 5 years ago
Above and Beyond Service

Matt is fantastic in meeting with us to determine what we are looking for in a purchase. Suitable properties were identified with Matt providing all relevant information and assisting us to obtain valuations and reports where required. His after sales service is exemplary with assistance for a smooth transition of the tenanted property. I wouldn't hesitate in highly recommending Matt.

Matt Cutler

Matt Cutler

  4.9   (15 reviews)
Seller review
Friendly but highly proficient and trustworthy agent
almost 5 years ago
Friendly but highly proficient and trustworthy agent

I first ran into Matt Cutler many years ago when I was hunting for investment properties in Dunedin. His insights led to the purchase of two flats in the right location that Matt and his firm, Cutlers, managed flawlessly for almost five years. Over that time I never missed a single days rent, the flats were rented each year, with appropriate increments, without advertising, from Cutlers pool of existing and would be tenants. Every kind of issue was managed without drama. When I decided to cash up and sell, Matt and Cutlers stepped in to completely manage the process from beginning to end. Matt delivered on his price projections within a matter of weeks on both flats. Matt seems to understand the art of steering clients in the right direction with a light touch. And just by being consistently right. So, underneath the very laid back exterior is a shrewd operator, wise beyond his years, who puts his money where is mouth is, and from my perspective, a trusted safe pair of hands over many years. He took all the worry out. I'll be re-engaging Matt in future. Highly recommended.

Matt Cutler

Matt Cutler

  4.9   (15 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent in all ways
almost 5 years ago
Excellent in all ways

We met Matt back in February this year in our quest to buy a house in the university area. We finally had success when we purchased a property through him late May. We live in the BOP, had minimal local knowledge & none of the student market. Over the past 3+ months Matt has had to deal with numerous questions & queries from us, & has arranged viewings of several properties (sometimes in person & sometimes remotely with our son who is attending university there). Matt has always been super prompt with his answers & help, always straight up. He has provided really sound advice. Other agents from other companies were definitely less motivated. I'm no fan of real estate agents in general but Matt is excellent. I'm sure Matt could teach the older / more experienced agents a thing or two. In the current market it doesn't take much to sell a house, but we think Matt would definitely be a go-to guy when the market is less buoyant & you need an agent to go out of their way to market your property & maximise its return. On the flip side as a buyer he's a super helpful guy to work with. We can't recommend Matt enough.

Matt Cutler

Matt Cutler

  4.9   (15 reviews)
Seller review
Professional at best
almost 5 years ago
Professional at best

Matt is an exceptional real estate agent , dealing in our best interests in the upmost professional manner. He is very approachable, talented and has a true flare to help clients achieve their goals even if it means sacrificing a little which goes beyond the calls of duty. I really appreciate his honesty, integrity and enthusiasm in a cut throat industry. I would highly recommend his services to new clients wishing to entrust their property whether it be to sell or rent, and results speak for themselves.

Matt Cutler

Matt Cutler

  4.9   (15 reviews)
Seller review
Best agent in Dunedin
almost 5 years ago
Best agent in Dunedin

Matt was our property manager over a year before we put our house on the market. With his knowledge on local property market and the property, we would be able to sell the property above the reserve price. His communication is amazing, we never had a single issue since we are with him. I would highly recommend Matt to our friends who are looking to buy/sell property in Dunedin. We appreciate Matt again the management, professionalism, knowledge and communication for a great sale that he made for us. Take care

Matt Cutler

Matt Cutler

  4.9   (15 reviews)
Seller review
Tom Leonard
about 5 years ago
Tom Leonard

Very pleased with the marketing.Full marks to Tom for the outcome on selling a very difficult property.He also got a price over what I had expected.

Tom Leonard

Tom Leonard

  5   (22 reviews)
Buyer review
Absolute professional
about 5 years ago
Absolute professional

Tom’s communication style and approach to real estate is down to earth. He was very professional, approachable and knowledgeable about the property. Tom is an enthusiastic and clearly dedicated agent and we recommend his services to others without hesitation.

Tom Leonard

Tom Leonard

  5   (22 reviews)
Seller review
Top notch service
over 6 years ago
Top notch service

Nick is super efficient and superb communicator. He set the expectations and with his market knowledge, positioned everything nicely. Super painless and top notch agent.

Nick Beard

Nick Beard

  5   (150 reviews)
361 - 369 of 369
© 2026 RateMyAgent