Scott's profile

Scott's reviews

  4.9  
Scott has 155 reviewsacross 33 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Scott's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, honest, strategic, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Overall positive experience
almost 2 years ago
Overall positive experience

It was a very tough market we were working within. Scott was knowledgeable and professional but at times communication could have been better.

Seller review
Scott Gets The Job Done.
about 2 years ago
Scott Gets The Job Done.

We highly recommend Scott, he is very professional, has a great ability to communicate and gives great clarity when things get a little stressful. We gave Scott free reign to get our house sold and believing in the process gave us the ability and freedom to get on with our busy lives. Thank you Scott it has been great working with you.

Seller review
Professional service
about 2 years ago
Professional service

Scott was very professional throughout our sales process, from the first meeting right through to sale. His local knowledge is second to none and has a large contact network. Thanks Scott and team!

Seller review
How to sell your home without stress
about 2 years ago
How to sell your home without stress

Where do I start. Scott McElhinney has a reputation as being the best in the business and he certainly exceeded that reputation for us. He was open, honest and extremely respectful of our needs and expectations. I would recommend Scott over and above any others in the business and have confidence in the fact that he did the best job for us in a very tough market. Thank you Scott and best of luck continuing down your chosen path.

Seller review
Experienced and helpful
about 2 years ago
Experienced and helpful

Scott has a very measured approach, realistic and fair. Gets the job done in the market he is presented with.

Seller review
Job well done!
about 2 years ago
Job well done!

Scott went beyond all expectations with the sale of our property.

Seller review
Tried and tested - great results!
about 2 years ago
Tried and tested - great results!

Scott and his team are a very professional group. He is clear with his communication, provides realistic feedback depending on the market situation and is calm and collected. Even through we did not sell at auction (tough market), we got results very quickly thereafter. A great team effort and we will be in touch in the future ;) our best wishes always and highly recommended to one and all!

Seller review
Kept our best interests in mind…
about 2 years ago
Kept our best interests in mind…

Scott applied a range of different market strategies to enable the best possible outcome. Scott is very professional and provided honest feedback throughout the process. He always listened to our opinions and we felt he had our best interests in mind. Scott continued to work hard right up until the sale had gone through. Highly recommended.

Seller review
Poetic success
over 2 years ago
Poetic success

In the land where green fields stretch wide and far, Where homes like jewels under the southern star,In north Waikato, where dreams are sown, Stands a man whose skills are well and truly known. His name is Scott, a maestro of the trade,In the art of selling, he’s expertly made. In a market tough, where sales move slow, He moves with grace, making success glow. Neighboring homes, they linger on display, Months on end, through night and day. But Scott’s magic touch, so rare and sweet, Turned our challenge into a feat. Just five weeks, a whisper in time, He found a buyer, a match sublime. Cash unconditional, no strings attached, A perfect deal, so swiftly snatched. In a seller’s market, hard and stern, Scott made the tides of fortune turn. With wisdom, tact, and keen insight, He led our journey into light. Ours was not just any land, But a lifestyle property, grand and grand. Scott knew its value, knew its worth, He shared its story, its hearth, its mirth. So here’s to Scott, in north Waikato’s realm, A captain fearless at the helm. For those seeking to sell, let it be known, Scott is the champion, in a league of his own. In his hands, dreams are not deferred, With him, your voice will be heard. A testament to his unmatched ability, He brings to life, our deepest possibility. So raise a glass to Scott, the man of the hour, Whose talent blooms like the most radiant flower. In a market tough, his success speaks loud, Scott, the agent, of whom we are proud.

Seller review
Amazing Results!
over 2 years ago
Amazing Results!

We found Scott and his team to be extremely professional and very communitive. Scott's knowledge of real estate really helped us navigate the selling process. We were always kept informed in a very timely manner of all our open homes. Scott and his team made the process very easy.

Seller review
Just magic
over 2 years ago
Just magic

On a three week turn around we couldn’t ask for more. Scott and Simone’s knowledge and professionalism were exceptional. From our point of view if you let the professional do their job and take their advice you get results. In our case that is exactly what we did and couldn’t be happier with the results.

49 - 60 of 155
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent