Scott's profile

Scott's reviews

  4.9  
Scott has 136 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Scott's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, hard-working, dedicated, honest, friendly, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Advertising and follow up was good but other areas need work.
about 2 years ago
Advertising and follow up was good but other areas need work.

We were pursued initially for our House with the promise of a good Sale and Price. In the early discussions was given a much lower than price for our Property than I would have liked but was assured by Scott that he could get anyone up and that he would be able to meet our Price. I explained that if we got a low offer my partner would always say yes and that it would cause conflict between us and that we would have to accept it or it would place undue strain on our relationship. But again, was assured that he could get anyone up and we would get the price we were after, which was reciprocated in feedback from customers who viewed our property with the previous agent and also viewings with Scott. This did not happen and there was no movement from the people whose offer we ultimately accepted. Yes, I did not have to accept it, but as stated earlier I knew my partner would say yes to anything so really didn't want such a low price to start with knowing this would happen. There was a lot of talk about getting us a good deal, but in the end it never eventuated and it was rolled over without a fight. So, while Property Brokers might be celebrating a Sale I am not. I feel let down and am not happy. I was aggressively pursued for our Listing and I really believed all the swag talk that we would geta good offer but this didnt eventuate. If it hadnt been for a medical event which cost us a Sale with the previous Agent we would have sold for a much higher price with them and for a much lower commission. The difference between the sale price and commission was $25k (not counting advertising) and that amount means a lot to us and for our future. There were aspects that were good however such as the advertising and feedback, but if we had of paid a similar amount with our previous Agent we would have likely done better. We did previously have numerous parties through on Open Homes but had to sell their own properties first. So, overall, not a good experience and feel let down.

Buyer review
Effective and efficient
about 2 years ago
Effective and efficient

Straight talking, great rapport, no fluffies. Easy to deal with and we had a great outcome!

Seller review
Hes on top of everything
about 2 years ago
Hes on top of everything

Very happy with Scott esy to deal with Great communication

Buyer review
Highly Motivated
about 2 years ago
Highly Motivated

Scott was easy to work with and kept us very well informed during the purchase of our new house. He was highly motivated and worked hard to sell our other property so this could happen. Much appreciated.

Buyer review
Hard-working, fast, and reliable.
about 2 years ago
Hard-working, fast, and reliable.

Scott was brilliant to work with in all aspects of the purchasing process. His communication was clear and consistent, and he was pragmatic in his approach to our purchase of the property. A good sort, with sound market knowledge, we wouldn't hesitate to work with Scott again in future.

Buyer review
Faultless and Professional
about 2 years ago
Faultless and Professional

We found Scott professional courteous in every sense. He over communicated (well received) was very knowledgeable in his profession. His local knowledge proved an absolutely bonus throughout our process. He had access to local professionals and local council. I think his loyalty to both seller and buyer was fair and professional in every way. Should we be in the market to sell in the future our first port of call will be to Scott to help us through the process. Buying a property could be stressful but this was not the case for us. Paul and Lisa Trow.

Buyer review
Good at what he does
about 2 years ago
Good at what he does

I found Scott very approachable and easy to work with. Would recommend him to anyone.

Seller review
Hard working, honest, and great communicator!
about 2 years ago
Hard working, honest, and great communicator!

Selling our property was challenging for a number of reasons outside of the control of Scott and his team. Despite this, they were awesome to work with and made things as simple as possible for us. They also put in extra work, often at late hours to get our house sold. If I had another house in the same area that I needed to sell I would definitely use Scott again.

Buyer review
Scott Mathis nice person We loved dealing with him
over 2 years ago
Scott Mathis nice person We loved dealing with him

we loved scott mathis and he friendly manner he followed through as we agreed providing regular update and commuication and we delighted with quick baugt and price wich scott was aple to negotiate for us we have already recommended him to others and would use him again with out hisitation

Seller review
Open and honest
over 2 years ago
Open and honest

We were warned that the auction process can be stressful but it was made easy with Scott and his friendly team. It was great to be able to contact them any time and have an answer asap. We felt well prepared for auction day and thank Scott, Harriet and Erin.

Buyer review
Top Notch Agent, Great Negotiator!
over 2 years ago
Top Notch Agent, Great Negotiator!

Highly recommend Scott and the team at Property Brokers. From the first initial phone call to handing over the keys at settlement, Scott was super easy to work with. We found Scott's insight to the local area very helpful. He was extremely personable and we felt like he had our best interests in mind. If the opportunity arose again we would buy or sell with Scott without hesitation.

Seller review
Good up-front agent
over 2 years ago
Good up-front agent

Scott has been great with managing the sale of my property. His calm approach has helped me with my decision making process, in this current challenging market.

121 - 132 of 136
© 2026 RateMyAgent