Sally's profile

Sally's reviews

  5  
Sally has 23 reviewsacross 19 different locations, showing 12.
3 months ago
A standout experience

After meeting many agents over the past month, Sally stands out as my top choice. From first conversation to negotiation and due diligence, she is warm, approachable, knowledgeable, and genuinely easy to work with. Nothing was ever too much trouble, and she was always happy to answer any questions I had. I would happily recommend Sally to anyone looking for a professional and caring real estate agent. She is genuinely the best!

3 months ago
Exceptional Service from Start to Finish

As first-home buyers, we couldn't have asked for a better real estate agent than Sally McMillan. From our very first phone call through to settlement, Sally was an exceptional communicator who kept us informed and supported every step of the way. She was always thoroughly prepared, arriving at our meetings and open homes with all the necessary information and documentation. Sally was consistently proactive, responsive, and available whenever we had questions, which made what could have been a stressful process feel manageable and enjoyable. What stood out most was how well Sally listened. She took the time to understand exactly what we were looking for in our first home and never tried to steer us towards something that wasn't the right fit. Instead, she genuinely worked alongside us to find a home that suited our needs and goals. Sally strikes the perfect balance between professionalism and genuine personal connection. She made us feel comfortable, valued, and confident throughout the entire purchasing process. Her knowledge, dedication, and kindness gave us complete confidence that we were in good hands. We are incredibly grateful to have had the privilege of purchasing our first home with Sally guiding us. We would recommend her without hesitation to anyone looking for an agent who truly cares about achieving the best outcome for her clients.

4 months ago
Kind agent who is helpful but not pushy

We have been in contact with many realtors while searching to buy our home over 6 months. Sally was among the best. She wasn't pushy or slimy, but seemed to have a genuine interest in us and getting the best for our situation. She was helpful and kind. I think she also ended up getting a good deal for her clients too (to our loss), so that definitely is a strength!

10 months ago
Excellent !

Sally was very approachable and welcoming. I did several views of 6b St Leonards Square on my own, and one with my sisters and best friend. Sally was calm, friendly and always was smiling. Sally is a great representative for your firm. Thank you Sally.

11 months ago
Selling our house

Sally was very knowledgeable on what the current Market is at. Sally made the whole experience of selling our house stress free. Sally was very compassionate when we felt unwell.

11 months ago
Excellent on all fronts

Really impressed by Sally's efforts to sell my property. Very easy to communicate, great advice and knowledge of the market. Couldn't have asked for better.

about 1 year ago
Absolutely Fantastic

Sally has been wonderful to work with -- throughout our viewing and buying experience, she has worked through all our questions and concerns and brought a wealth of industry knowledge to the table. Being novices to the processes of property auctions, Sally's advice was invaluable. We never felt pressured or rushed, and she was consistently thorough, open, and incredibly easy to talk to. Even after viewing the property a second time, Sally welcomed us back with more answers to our questions which made our decision to buy all the easier. We would highly recommend Sally and Harcourts Grenadier to people looking to buy property or bid at auction.

about 1 year ago
Just when I needed some help.

I was in the middle of a rather difficult buy/sell situation when I was introduced to Sally. Sally helped me though the process of purchasing my current home via auction. The whole process was made easier by having someone to guide me through a very stressful situation from initial property viewing right through to the auction. She was always there to answer my questions and organize meetings with people and viewings of properties. Thank you for your patience and guidance at a time when I really needed some help.

about 1 year ago
Professional and friendly - another successful sale with Sally

We have engaged Sally for a several of our real estate requirements. Sally is a warm and honest communicator and we were kept informed with the progress of our latest sale. We appreciated Sally's friendly and genuine personality which she brings to her professional role.

over 1 year ago
Honest Agent

Sally was good at telling us about other potential properties of interest at an open home. Net good experience!

over 1 year ago
Fab professionals

Sally and the team were amazing! From the time the appraisal was done (much quicker than other agencies) through to the auction, the support and communication was superb. I would highly recommend this team if you want great service and communication.

1 - 12 of 23
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent