Keegan's profile

Keegan's reviews

  4.8  
Keegan has 24 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Keegan's qualities as told by our client reviews: local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Combines smart strategy with elite negotiation, Keegan is the real deal
22 days ago
Combines smart strategy with elite negotiation, Keegan is the real deal

We couldn’t have asked for a better result working with Keegan O'Malley. Selling in a down market is never easy, especially with a unique property, but Keegan’s strategy and execution were outstanding. His approach to pricing, marketing, and tightly managed open homes created real competition and momentum from day one. Where Keegan truly stands out is in the art of the deal. He took the time to understand every buyer, communicated with absolute precision, and applied just the right amount of pressure at the right moments. The result was multiple strong offers and buyers competing right to the end. We achieved a great price with great conditions and a fast settlement—well above where we believe we would have landed with a traditional pricing approach. If you want someone who combines smart strategy with elite negotiation, Keegan is the real deal.

Seller review
Above and beyond service from start to finish!
3 months ago
Above and beyond service from start to finish!

We couldn’t be happier with the service we received from Keegan. From start to finish, he was incredibly professional, proactive, and genuinely committed to achieving the best possible outcome for us. Keegan went above and beyond at every stage of the process, always making himself available, keeping us informed, and offering clear, honest advice. He even rolled up his sleeves and helped clear the yard and mow the lawns! His attention to detail, strong communication, and dedication truly set him apart. It was clear he cared not just about making a sale, but about doing what was best for us. We’re so grateful for his hard work and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Keegan to anyone looking for a reliable, knowledgeable, and hardworking real estate agent.

Seller review
Highly recommended
4 months ago
Highly recommended

"Keegan O'Malley provided exceptional service during the sale of our property. His market knowledge and proactive approach resulted in a sale within just a few weeks. As a remote seller with a demanding schedule, I greatly appreciated his communication skills; he was efficient, clear, and knew how to balance phone calls versus texts to keep things moving without disrupting my day. He went the extra mile to ensure the property was ready for market. An outstanding experience."

Seller review
Excellent service
8 months ago
Excellent service

Keegan was great to work with selling our property very good at communicating and knowledgeable with the real estate market.He was available whenever we had any questions happy with the end result.

Buyer review
Happy days
about 1 year ago
Happy days

As first time home buyers we were really happy with the process. Keegan figured out what we wanted and was able to supply a shortlist of homes that would suit our budget and requirements. He was flexible with viewing times and was always available for a quick call or text. He provided honest and open communication, didn't glaze over any details, explaining the process for novice buyers such as ourselves. We're very happy with the service and would be happy to engage with Keegan and Tall Poppy in the future.

Seller review
Linda Oliver
about 1 year ago
Linda Oliver

From first meeting Keegan to the Sale, he has been fantastic, the journey was completely new to me and along the way my many questions were answered with professionalism and honesty, communication and updates always great. Our outcome couldn't be better. Without any hesitation I highly recommend Keegan to sell for you. Thank you for doing such an amazing job.

Seller review
Smooth & No Stress Professional
about 1 year ago
Smooth & No Stress Professional

Keegan’s knowledge and guidance made my selling experience smooth with virtually zero stress. Communication throughout was top notch and on point. Made it easy to react to negotiations to achieve success basically first up. A+ from me.

Seller review
Springlands, Blenheim
about 1 year ago
Springlands, Blenheim

Keegan was up front and honest from pre listing, listing, marketing, and throughout securing a contract. He help through unexpected hurdles that popped up and solved issues we had.

1 - 12 of 24
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent