James McElrea

James McElrea

Sales & Marketing Consultant / Licensed Real Estate Agent at eXp New Zealand Ltd
Salesperson: 20114703
  •   5   (60 reviews)

James' sales performance at a glance

See how James has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

8
Reviews
149
Median days on market
10
Properties for sale
12
Sold properties
$1.3m
Average sale price
$13.2m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.co.nz. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

About James

James McElrea brings a rare blend of craftsmanship, hospitality and hard-won real estate experience to Tutukaka — and it shows in the way he looks after every property, and every person, he works with. James's career didn't start in real estate. For twenty years he worked as a winemaker in Central Otago and around the world, learning the discipline, patience and attention to detail that comes from coaxing the best out of a single vineyard, vintage after vintage. That passion for craft led him to launch his own boutique label, Black Peak Wines, before he and his wife took on a second adventure: owning and operating Riverview Lodge, a luxury bed and breakfast in Wanaka. Years spent welcoming guests from around the world taught James what genuinely great hospitality looks like — and how much a warm welcome and a well-told story over a glass of wine can shape the way people feel about a place and get the most out of it. That combination of precision and people-first hospitality found its natural home in real estate. Over six years selling property in Wanaka, one of the country's most sought-after lifestyle areas, James built a reputation for honest advice, calm guidance through the ups and downs of a sale, and a genuine investment in getting the best outcome for his clients — not just the fastest one. Now James has brought that same energy north, relocating with his wife Nicky (and their new Cavoodle) from Wanaka to the Tutukaka Coast to be closer to the ocean, feel the sand between his toes, and immerse themselves in the close-knit coastal community. It's a move that mirrors the one so many of his clients are making themselves — trading pace for perspective and choosing a life closer to nature. That's the spirit behind Nautilus Property — a boutique agency operating under the eXp banner, built to bring highly personalised service to what is often one of the largest assets a person will ever sell. James understands, on a personal level, what draws people to this coastline and what makes a property here special — whether it's a family bach, a lifestyle block, or a forever home with a view of the water. He combines genuine local knowledge with an experienced, story-driven approach to marketing, presenting each property in a way that connects with the right buyers. Selling can be one of life's more stressful experiences, and James's role is to make it feel anything but. Straightforward advice, meticulous preparation and analytics, and a marketing approach built on the same care and attention to detail that's shaped everything he's done — because getting this right matters, to him as much as to you. If you're thinking about selling on the Tutukaka Coast, James would love to hear from you for an easy, unhurried conversation about your property, no pressure attached. James McElrea Nautilus Property | Tutukaka

Social profiles

James' reviews

  5  
James has 60 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 6.
Review James
James' qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, detail-oriented, supportive, patient, honest, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
A very committed professional
5 months ago
A very committed professional

As Vendors, James impressed us from the start of our sale process. Before our first meeting, James did extensive homework on our property and presented to us having a surprisingly good knowledge of our property and of both the current property market and of selling properties. This all proved most helpful in the process. James was consultative over all decisions made in our sale process. Nothing was ever too much trouble. He was always available, responded quickly to all queries and gave us really good feedback throughout the process. We felt he was always working for us as the Vendors. We had met James previously with another property transaction and did like his manner and low key approach, never pushy or aggressive with prospective purchasers. He was very knowledgeable and responded to all requests. We have no hesitation in recommending James to any prospective vendor and are happy to discuss our experience with any potential client. Pamela de Beer and Jeff Couch

Seller review
Professional, proactive and excellent communication throughout
7 months ago
Professional, proactive and excellent communication throughout

James recently sold my section in Ōkuru and was excellent to deal with from start to finish. He kept me well informed at every stage of the process and communicated clearly and promptly, which made the whole experience straightforward and stress-free. He provided good market insight and realistic advice around pricing and buyer interest, and I always felt he was being honest and transparent. Any questions I had were answered quickly, and he made sure I understood what was happening and what the next steps were. James was professional, organised and easy to work with. I appreciated his steady approach and the way he kept things moving without unnecessary pressure. I would happily recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell property.

Seller review
A challenging sale handled with Due Diligence!
7 months ago
A challenging sale handled with Due Diligence!

What turned out to be a challenging sale of our fairly high end Wanaka home couldn't have been handled more expertly than it was by James McElrea and his colleagues at Harcourts, Wanaka. This was one of those properties that had to wait for "just the right buyer" and it took quite a long time for that buyer to arrive. On the market for a little over a year meant a great deal of input by James. Many, many open homes for him to attend, many interested parties to follow up on and report to us about and a great deal of interaction and strategising with us as the process evolved. James handled all aspects of this tricky process with grace and enthusiasm and never wavered from the ultimate goal of achieving an appropriate outcome for us, his clients. Well done James and thank you - it took a while but we got there! Rik & Juliet Deaton

Seller review
I rate James Mc Leary
10 months ago
I rate James Mc Leary

Very expertenced and informative through the whole process of selling our property. A pleasure to work with. Would recomend.

Show all 60 reviews
map

James' properties

James has 10 properties for sale and sold 12 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 20, 2026
Price not available
11B Kidds Way
Albert Town Otago
2
1
Townhouse
SoldMar 13, 2026
Price not available
19 Fox Moth Drive
Haast West Coast
Land
SoldFeb 24, 2026
Price not available
29 Fox Moth Drive
Haast West Coast
Land
SoldFeb 23, 2026
Price not available
33 Fox Moth Drive
Haast West Coast
Land
Show all 22 properties

James' sold properties

James has sold 12 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
11B Kidds Way, Albert Town, Otago
11B Kidds Way
Albert Town Otago
2
1
TownhouseUndisclosed PriceApr 20, 2026
19 Fox Moth Drive
Haast West Coast
LandUndisclosed PriceMar 13, 2026
29 Fox Moth Drive
Haast West Coast
LandUndisclosed PriceFeb 24, 2026
33 Fox Moth Drive, Haast, West Coast
33 Fox Moth Drive
Haast West Coast
LandUndisclosed PriceFeb 23, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent