Gary's profile

Gary's reviews

  4.9  
Gary has 12 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
17 days ago
Couldn’t Have Asked for More

I had an outstanding experience working with Gary to sell my home, especially as I was based overseas for the entire process. Gary went above and beyond at every step — he took care of the garden and ensured the property was always presented beautifully for inspections, handled a complex body corporate issue on my behalf, and managed the tenants with professionalism and care. What really stood out was his proactive approach and genuine commitment. He made what could have been a very stressful experience feel smooth and manageable, and ultimately secured a fantastic buyer and a great price. I’m incredibly grateful for his support and would highly recommend Gary to anyone looking for a dedicated and trustworthy real estate agent.

4 months ago
Communication, Professionalism and market knowledge excellent.

Gary was wonderful. He was very very helpful in all aspects of the marketing process. He went the extra mile helping us market our property and his negotiation skills definitely had a major effect on our successful sale. He put many hours into the promotion of the property and was extremely helpful to us as my husband was unwell. We have absolutely no regrets choosing Gary McElroy as our agent.

almost 5 years ago
Gets results

Gary has now sold 4 properties for me and I have also purchased through him as well ,he is honest and one of the better agents I have worked with ,he works for the vendor and achieves the best Result A SALE Marty

almost 5 years ago
Professional, knowledgeable, helpful and understanding.

From the outset Gary explained the process of selling our house, including transparency around the Barfoot & Thompson legalities and systems. He continued to give sound information and advice as the process evolved. He was always available for consultation and advice and answering any questions we had. Gary has a professional work ethic and he communicates in an understanding, friendly, and relaxed manner. His organisation and attending to detail enhanced the success we had in selling our house.

about 5 years ago
An agent that really looks after his purchasers

Gary put a lot of time into our house search, and really went the extra miles when we finally found the property we've since bought. His help with the Auction process was invaluable and he made sure everything went smoothly even after we'd moved in.

about 5 years ago
Under Gary's care we were the most relaxed anyone's ever been with their house on the market!

Pragmatic and accommodating, Gary made the selling process easy and painless. Gary sold our house very quickly despite 2 out of 3 weeks of open homes being during a level 3 lockdown. In preparation for the house sale, Gary was able to work around one of us (plus the dog) working from home. He demonstrated an accurate understanding of the market and helped us set our expectations accordingly. If we go to sell in the future we will certainly be looking to list with Gary (but hopefully we are in our new house for a long time - a place that Gary also helped us with!).

about 5 years ago
His promise to sell our property was fully justified

Gary accomplished what he said he’d do.....and that was to sell our property. COVID lockdowns didn’t help on numerous occasions but Gary worked around the issues of delayed or non-existent open homes. Gary is great to deal with. He knows the area, he knows what is expected of him, he performs. Probably the one thing that stood out dealing with Gary, was that he actually listened to us and to what we desired and wanted to achieve. The eventual sale exceeded both our targets. A job well done - thank you Gary.

about 5 years ago
Gary found us our perfect place

Gary met us once, listened to what we needed and then he suggested a house we hadn't seen and would not have noticed. He helped me negotiate and secure the place quickly and at the right price. We would never have found this place without him, he gave me expert advice throughout the process and he thought outside the square to match us with a place we all love.

about 5 years ago
Fantastic service!

Gary was on top of things from the start, with fast, efficient communication and great feedback from the open homes. His energy created the interest in our property which sold quickly at auction with very pleasing results.

about 5 years ago
Knowledgeable, Honest & Attentive

We highly recommend Gary from a buyer & sellers perspective. We had engaged with Gary for a purchase and found him to be extremely helpful, patient & attentive. We wanted the same warm customer service for selling our house, so it was an easy decision. We found the process quite daunting but he took the time and effort to explain and guide us through. He was proactive and kept us informed at every stage.

1 - 12 of 12
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent