Carla's profile

Carla's reviews

  5  
Carla has 23 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Carla's qualities as told by our client reviews: local expert, friendly, empathetic, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Exceptional Service and Expert Guidance!
5 months ago
Exceptional Service and Expert Guidance!

Working with Carla felt more like working with a trusted friend than an agent. Carla is knowledgeable,professional, attentive and truly goes above and beyond for her clients. Carla listened carefully to our needs, offered excellent advice, and was always available to answer questions or provide guidance. We can't recommend Carla highly enough for anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Buyer review
Good communication
7 months ago
Good communication

Helpful and easy to work with.

Seller review
Exceptional service
8 months ago
Exceptional service

We had such a fantastic experience working with Carla McCrostie on the sale of our house. Carla is everything you could hope for in a Real Estate Agent—she listens carefully, brings a wealth of knowledge, and uses her skills to achieve the best outcome for her clients. What truly stands out is how much Carla cares; it’s clear that this is far more than just a job to her. Even in a more challenging market, she managed to sell our home quickly and delivered an excellent result. Carla consistently went above and beyond, offering thoughtful ideas and practical suggestions that made the entire process smoother and less stressful. We are extremely grateful for her dedication and professionalism, and we would not hesitate to highly recommend Carla to anyone looking to sell their property.

Seller review
 Client Testimonial
8 months ago
Client Testimonial

From the moment we met Carla, we knew she was the right agent for us. Her knowledge of the market and ability to provide sound, practical advice immediately put us at ease. Selling a home can often be stressful, but with Carla the process felt seamless. She was proactive, professional, and fully committed to achieving the best outcome for us — in fact, she secured an offer under contract after the very first open home! We couldn’t have asked for a better agent and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell their home.

Seller review
Highly recommend
9 months ago
Highly recommend

Highly recommended, selling my home was a big step and I couldn't have asked for a better agent than Carla. She was incredibly professional, genuinely understanding and consistently helpful throughout the entire process. Carla went the extra mile more than once to make sure everything ran smoothly, and I felt supported every step of the way. Her dedication and care made a stressful time feel manageable and even exciting. I'm truly grateful and would recommend Carla to anyone looking for a real estate agent who combines expertise with heart.

Buyer review
Great agent to deal with
9 months ago
Great agent to deal with

Carla was very communicative, easy to deal with and very honest. She made the process of buying the house very easy and always stayed in touch, regularly checking in on the next steps and updating us as we went through the process. She was always an available when we had any queries and able to work out the timings to be there at the house for the inspections and things. Would recommend her as an agent for sure.

Buyer review
I am very happy with  Carla with the service
9 months ago
I am very happy with Carla with the service

I have found Carla very contactable on various occasions, during the purchasing process, of this property, which has made the process nice and easy and stress free , I would recommend Carla to anyone who is selling or looking at purchasing a property . I will be contacting Carla in the future for any other property i am interested in . cheers Mike

Seller review
Carla,s knowledge,communication and professionlism is excellent.
9 months ago
Carla,s knowledge,communication and professionlism is excellent.

Carla made the process of selling our property easy and stress free.Carla communicated well with us during the whole process.Carla is an excellent agent and i would recommend Carla if you are contemplating selling or buying a property.

Seller review
Professional and on-point
almost 2 years ago
Professional and on-point

Carla worked hard to make the sale. I enjoyed teaming up with her to get to a point where I was happy and she treated the buyers with respect, empathy and provided great communication between the vendor and buyer.

Buyer review
Awesome agent
almost 2 years ago
Awesome agent

Carla was the agent for the house we were buying She was super responsive and polite and always got any information we requested back to us very fast A+++

Buyer review
A Fantastically Tenacious agent!
about 2 years ago
A Fantastically Tenacious agent!

When I met Carla I found her to be very knowledgeable and great to work with. When my offer was declined and I had given up she encouraged me to think about it and gave me the confidence to retry 🫣 I was thrilled when the offer was accepted and I was moving to a Fabulous neighbourhood. The property was empty and I had envisaged picking up gravel and replacing it with grass, however this was declined by the vendors. Throughout all of this Carla was amazing and she even managed to get the garden tidied up prior to settlement as it had become scruffy. Carla works incredibly hard for her sellers and when something does not work she will approach it from a different angle! Thank you for all of your hard work and working with my ‘2 month take-over wait’ stressed self! All handled very professionally 😄

Seller review
Good comms all the way
over 2 years ago
Good comms all the way

Kept in touch all the way through to signing the agreement of sale.

1 - 12 of 23
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent