Keeley's profile

Keeley's reviews

  5  
Keeley has 296 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Keeley's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, supportive, well-prepared, responsive, friendly, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent Communication and Advice
10 months ago
Excellent Communication and Advice

We had an outstanding experience selling our home with Keeley and Niki from Tall Poppy Queenstown. Together, they guided us through a well-considered deadline sale strategy, offered smart staging advice, and suggested light renovations that helped us present the property at its absolute best. Their professionalism, pace, and communication were truly unmatched. We always felt informed, supported, and confident in the process. The live online sales platform Tall Poppy uses was a standout - fast, transparent, and incredibly efficient, making the whole experience smooth from start to finish. We’re absolutely thrilled with the result - not only for us as vendors, but for the buyers as well. Keeley and Niki delivered a wonderful outcome and made the entire journey a pleasure. Highly recommended.

Seller review
My experience.
10 months ago
My experience.

Our experience we had with Keeley and Nicki was excellent.We had good feedback and were well informed at every stage. We would recommend them to anyone selling their house.

Seller review
Keeley ANDERSON
10 months ago
Keeley ANDERSON

We found Keeley very knowledgeable, extremely professional and friendly. An overall pleasure to work with. kept us well informed regarding the sale. We would recommend her and her team to any family or friends.

Seller review
Best of the best!
10 months ago
Best of the best!

Keeley is the hardest working agent I know! From the very beginning, well before we even went to market, she went above and beyond in every way. Her guidance, attention to detail, and constant communication made the entire process so much smoother and less stressful. Keeley’s insights into the current market were incredibly valuable, but what truly set her apart was the personal touch she brought by sharing her own experiences and genuine advice of what it’s like to buy and sell a home. I couldn’t have asked for a more dedicated, knowledgeable, and supportive agent throughout the journey, and wouldn't want anyone else!

Buyer review
Excellent
10 months ago
Excellent

Working with Keeley was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. Her professionalism, market knowledge, and genuine care made the entire buying process smooth and stress-free. She was always available to answer questions, provided honest advice, and went above and beyond to ensure everything stayed on track. Thanks to her expertise, I felt confident every step of the way. I highly recommend Keeley to anyone looking for a trustworthy and dedicated real estate professional!

Seller review
Excellent, great communicator.
10 months ago
Excellent, great communicator.

Very knowledgeable, always positive. Had a great strategy and marketing campaign. Highly recommended.

Buyer review
Made everything easy
11 months ago
Made everything easy

Keeley was absolutely amazing from start to finish , had all the answers to all the questions and helped make our dream become a reality

Buyer review
VERY GOOD!
12 months ago
VERY GOOD!

From the first phone call to the surprise gift hamper at the end, both Kelley and Niki were exceptional to deal with. I’ve worked in sales for the last 20 years+ and was more than impressed with their speed of comms, efficiency and willingness to help make things happen. I will deal with them again as soon as the bank allows. Very happy

Seller review
Fantastic job Keely
12 months ago
Fantastic job Keely

This is the 3rd house that Keely has sold for us. We lived her enthusiasm, professionalism, her knowledge of the market and her commitment to get the best deal for us. We would highly recommend her if anyone was thinking of selling their home in Central or Queenstown

Seller review
Fast sale and seamless process
about 1 year ago
Fast sale and seamless process

What a great experience we had with Keeley and Niki. We had previously had our house on the market for seven months and urgently needed it sold. We decided to swap real estate agents and sign up to Tall Poppy with Keely because we’ve heard such great things about her. She got onto it right away and it was listed within four days. The house was sold in a couple weeks and we are so happy with the experience we had with Keely and the team. They have great attention to detail and such a kind happy spirit. They made the process seamless and an enjoyable experience. We’re now moving onto our next project and we can’t wait to use Keeley again in the future. Thanks so much!

Seller review
Above and beyond
about 1 year ago
Above and beyond

Keeley simply has to be one of, if not the best residential agent we have dealt with. Add in team member Niki Lord and you have a dream team focused on clients and results

49 - 60 of 296
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent