Mike's profile

Mike's reviews

  4.9  
Mike has 273 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
First home
over 1 year ago
First home

We had Fay help us negotiate the sale of our first home. She has been fantastic easy to deal with great contact and willing to help us out where needed with our questions.

Seller review
Made a complex situation a winner!
over 1 year ago
Made a complex situation a winner!

Mike and Steve were a great help as we sold an estate property which involved multiple stake holders and a drawn out land zoning process. Always calm, clear and reliable with good advice in the big moments.

Seller review
Good advice and very professional service
over 1 year ago
Good advice and very professional service

Mike Goatley gave us good advice prior to marketing regarding sales methods and the benefits and disadvantages of our selected method - "Deadline Sale". We were also impressed with his recommended marketing campaign, and the results it generated. Mike and all the One Agency staff performed extremely well during marketing, with clear communication and good analysis of the offers received. The final price was slightly higher than we expected during a quiet time in the market. We are very happy to have trusted our property to Mike and the One Agency team. Excellent outcome. We would use him again without hesitation.

Seller review
Best Agency
over 1 year ago
Best Agency

One Agency are Number 1! Mike Goatley has been exceptional in all our dealings. We have not had a straightforward run with several issues to do with the property coming up over the time it took to sell. We had several issues that came up during this process and related to the house and Mike never gave up. He could have easily run away from this but remained committed. Mike was amazing and really worked hard to get us a sale. The professionalism every step of the way was outstanding and every point and the communication always clear. He really worked hard to achieve a sale for us. Would definitely recommend anyone to Mike and his team who wants the most honest and reliable agent who gives everything to achieve a sale. We had updated provided after open homes and all private viewings, so we always knew where we stood. I love that no unrealistic expectations were given. You were amazing and thank you for all you have done.

Seller review
Agent highly recommended
over 1 year ago
Agent highly recommended

Mike was easy to work with and went the extra mile to assist me with the issues with the builder and the tenant. We achieved an optimal price for the property.

Seller review
Excellence, Competence, Integrity
over 1 year ago
Excellence, Competence, Integrity

Mike made an experience which can be uncertain and stressful as smooth and easy as it could be. Accessible through the whole process, Mike knew his stuff and his enthusiasm did not wain at any point. Being able to trust that a professional has your best interest at heart is refreshing.

Buyer review
Rewarding experience
almost 2 years ago
Rewarding experience

We had a great experience working with Mike and Fay as a first home buyer. We listened to their expertise throughout the process and we couldn’t be happier with our new home.

Seller review
A very positive and professional experience.
almost 2 years ago
A very positive and professional experience.

Our experience with Mike Goatley & Fay Hancock-Coombes was an extremely positive experience. They had excellent communication skills and treated us with the utmost respect and consideration every step of the journey. Their market knowledge was very thorough and they acted with professionalism at all times.

Buyer review
Super Agent
almost 2 years ago
Super Agent

Mike goes beyond the call of duty and this makes him different from everyone else. You can tell he loves what he does and he gets deeply involved in making the experience something to enjoy and remember. Not just to the point of sale but well after the sale. He was still answering our questions well after the sale. Even organised a personal handover between the seller and the buyer. Greatly appreciated and beyond our expectations.

Seller review
Excellent professional service
almost 2 years ago
Excellent professional service

Mike knows his stuff! His friendly and professional manner, along with knowing the market to an exceptionally high level, made this process quick and easy.

Seller review
Absolute Real Estate Excellence
almost 2 years ago
Absolute Real Estate Excellence

We can't rate Mike and his team highly enough - there aren't enough stars to adequately express our appreciation for his service. If you're looking for a real estate agent who combines expertise, market knowledge, and professionalism with genuine care and unwavering support, all while making the process enjoyable and fun, Mike Goatley is your go-to. He doesn't just meet expectations; he exceeds them in every way! We've worked with Mike since 2020, and his commitment and support have been nothing short of exceptional. Back then, when we discovered undisclosed damage and the sale fell through, Mike didn't disappear! Instead, he stayed by our side throughout the discovery and kept in touch throughout the repair, demonstrating the genuine care he holds for his clients. Now that renovations are complete, Mike has done an outstanding job marketing and selling our property. His expertise in showcasing our home's best features has been impressive, backed by his excellent market knowledge. Mike's insights into understanding the market were invaluable in positioning our property for sale. What sets Mike apart is his genuine connection with his clients, coupled with his excellent communication skills. He kept us informed every step of the way, explaining processes clearly and quickly addressing questions and concerns. His responsiveness and transparency made us feel valued and in control throughout the entire process. Mike's absolute professionalism is evident in every interaction. He handles all aspects of the sale with such competence and integrity. Yet, remarkably, he manages to keep the whole process fun and enjoyable. His positive attitude and friendly manner turned what should have been a stressful experience into an engaging and enjoyable journey.

Seller review
Mike absolutely nailed selling our house.
almost 2 years ago
Mike absolutely nailed selling our house.

I have known Mike for decades and he is committed to seeing the best outcomes for those he works with regardless of the challenges that present themselves. This man is relentless in working to help others. Multi faceted competency and professionalism are critical components to Mike and his team being able to build confidence that even when crisis hits it is being handled well. He sold our old house in a less popular suburb with multiple issues for above the expected price. The marketing achieved significant listing views over 5000 in the time on the market, the deadline sale was brought forward with multiple offers, and a backup offer was secured. Each time something happened he was there to help guid us through. The reporting and open homes were exceptional as where the referrals to other professionals across a wide range of skills. The presale property preparation guidance Mike provided was critical to its sale success. Mike definitely knows how to get things done in a practical and targeted fashion and connect you with who can help to achieve that. He helped us get presale finance which was a significant component to get the property finished for sale and resolve insurance issues.

73 - 84 of 273
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent