Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
9 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 9.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, reliable, well-prepared, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Very engaged agents!
17 days ago
Very engaged agents!

Ben and Serena were great to deal with when selling our property in a tough market. Were very engaged and great communicators through the whole process

Ben CastlemanSerena Papalii
Buyer review
Its amazing Teams....
about 1 month ago
Its amazing Teams....

Hi Ben and Serena, You both are amazing. We are truly happy with the way you handled the purchase of our home. Your dedication, commitment, and professionalism are greatly appreciated. We especially value how quickly and clearly you responded whenever we asked for documents or needed more information about the property. Your support made the entire process smooth and comfortable for us. You helped us achieve our goal, and at times, it didn’t even feel like we were dealing with a sales team—that’s how approachable and supportive you were. Thank you so much, Ben and Serena. Wishing you all the very best!

Ben CastlemanSerena Papalii
Seller review
Easy to work with and great communication
about 1 month ago
Easy to work with and great communication

Ben and Serena were quick to answer any questions and provide anything we needed. They worked with us to form a collaborative approach to the sale of the house. They heard what we wanted and did their best to facilitate. We were very happy with Ben and Serena and would definitely use them again.

Ben CastlemanSerena Papalii
Buyer review
The Dynamic Duo
about 2 months ago
The Dynamic Duo

Ben & Serena were amazing to work with. They made purchasing our first home such a positive experience with their kindness, strong work ethic, and enthusiasm to help. Their communication was excellent, readily available to address any concerns or questions we had and consistently kept us updated throughout the process. Working with Ben & Serena alleviated a lot of the stress and worries that came with being first home buyers as they looked after us with such exceptional care and skill. We highly recommend working with them. Thank you Ben & Serena! ♡

Ben CastlemanSerena Papalii
Seller review
Patient & Professional
about 2 months ago
Patient & Professional

I had the pleasure of selling our home with Ben & Serena which has been in our family for decades. It was a reluctant but necessary sale that required a lot of patience dealing with family members and hand holding through the process. We had added hiccups of insurance issues due to a neighbours house fire affecting a nearby fence, Ben & Serena were always patient, kind and were never ‘pushy’ to rush us. My Grandfather was the final decision maker and they were great with him. Took the time to sit with him and walk him through each step, explaining positives and negatives and reassuring him that the final choice was his. They were informative and kept all the family members involved, updated along the way. Thank you both for getting this over the line for us!

Serena PapaliiBen Castleman
Seller review
Outstanding service from Ben and Serena
3 months ago
Outstanding service from Ben and Serena

Ben and Serena were amazing to deal with. They gave us great advice the whole way through and made the process feel easy and stress-free. The marketing was top-notch, and the voice-over was especially well done. It all came together beautifully and presented our home in the best possible way. Super professional, friendly, and genuinely great people to work with. Highly recommend.

Ben CastlemanSerena Papalii
Seller review
Salt of the Earth
3 months ago
Salt of the Earth

Choosing Castleman &Co to help sell our home was a no brainer actually 😁from day 1 they showed genuine interest in what our end goal was and offered helpful insights with their professional advice. Excellent communicators who are true salt of the earth people. A duo we would highly recommend to anyone looking for agents who put your interests first.

Ben CastlemanSerena Papalii
Seller review
Professional, Detailed & Client-First
3 months ago
Professional, Detailed & Client-First

Ben truly went above and beyond for us. From start to finish, he showed an exceptional level of care and always kept our best interests front and centre. We chose to take a more passive market approach, and Ben and his team expertly leveraged their network to bring strong, high-quality buyers to the table. Ben took the time to walk us through every option in detail, supported us throughout negotiations, and guided us confidently through the signing process. He is not a typical transactional agent - he is relationship-focused, incredibly thorough, and has a deep understanding of his market. His approach reflects a rare blend of professionalism, expertise, and genuine humanity in a sales-driven industry. We couldn’t recommend Ben and his team more highly if you are seeking a truly professional agent to look after the sale of your property with genuine care.

Ben CastlemanSerena Papalii
Seller review
Personable & enthusiastic agents
3 months ago
Personable & enthusiastic agents

I brought my new house & sold my previous house with Ben & Serena. They went the extra mile to support this process, despite the pressure of the quick turn around needed they remained professional, positive & calm which I really appreciate. They were great at communicating in a prompt, open & honest way. Thank you, your an awesome team!

Ben CastlemanSerena Papalii
1 - 9 of 9
© 2026 RateMyAgent